{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates Saturn placed in the seventh house while not ruling the ascendant, treated as a challenging indication for marital happiness. It does not guarantee divorce, and option C reverses the stated exception."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.99,\"rationale\":\"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates Saturn placed in the seventh house while not ruling the ascendant, treated as a challenging indication for marital happiness. It does not guarantee divorce, and option C reverses the stated exception.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates a challenging marital-happiness effect when Saturn occupies the seventh house without being lord of the ascendant or seventh house. It does not guarantee divorce, and option C reverses the stated lordship exception."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.99,\"rationale\":\"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates a challenging marital-happiness effect when Saturn occupies the seventh house without being lord of the ascendant or seventh house. It does not guarantee divorce, and option C reverses the stated lordship exception.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates a challenging marriage-related effect when Saturn occupies the seventh house and is not the ascendant lord; in the VedAstro formulation, Saturn ruling the seventh is also an exception. Thus A matches. B overclaims certainty, C reverses the exception, and D is false."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The rule name SaturnIn7thNotLagnaLord indicates a challenging marriage-related effect when Saturn occupies the seventh house and is not the ascendant lord; in the VedAstro formulation, Saturn ruling the seventh is also an exception. Thus A matches. B overclaims certainty, C reverses the exception, and D is false.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, while the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh-house lord is Venus; therefore Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh, making statement A applicable under the stated rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The proposed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here those lords are Mars and Venus respectively.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A applies. The conclusion is challenging because polarity must be based solely on the applicable listed statements; no claim of certain divorce is warranted."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, while the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh-house lord is Venus; therefore Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh, making statement A applicable under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The proposed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here those lords are Mars and Venus respectively.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A applies. The conclusion is challenging because polarity must be based solely on the applicable listed statements; no claim of certain divorce is warranted.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, supporting the listed mixed indication that stability may coexist with emotional coldness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not treated here as wholly beneficial; the stated rule is mixed.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; the listed rule indicates a possible mixture of stability and emotional coldness.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart directly places Saturn in house 7. Under the supplied options, A is the applicable rule and has mixed polarity; B and C are absolute overclaims, while D is false because A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, supporting the listed mixed indication that stability may coexist with emotional coldness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not treated here as wholly beneficial; the stated rule is mixed.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; the listed rule indicates a possible mixture of stability and emotional coldness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart directly places Saturn in house 7. Under the supplied options, A is the applicable rule and has mixed polarity; B and C are absolute overclaims, while D is false because A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The proposed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart, so 'none' is incorrect.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The ascendant is Aries and is ruled by Mars, while the seventh house is Libra and is ruled by Venus. Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither relevant sign. Therefore A applies. The stated rule supports only a challenging tendency, not certainty of divorce."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The proposed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart, so 'none' is incorrect.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The ascendant is Aries and is ruled by Mars, while the seventh house is Libra and is ruled by Venus. Saturn occupies the seventh house but rules neither relevant sign. Therefore A applies. The stated rule supports only a challenging tendency, not certainty of divorce.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house, supporting the listed mixed indication that stability may coexist with emotional coldness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not treated by the stated rule as wholly beneficial; the applicable statement characterizes it as mixed.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; such certainty is not established by the placement.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established as applicable because Saturn is in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The sole chart fact places Saturn in house 7. Among the listed rules, A directly matches that placement and assigns mixed polarity. B and C make unjustified absolute claims, while D is false because A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house, supporting the listed mixed indication that stability may coexist with emotional coldness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not treated by the stated rule as wholly beneficial; the applicable statement characterizes it as mixed.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; such certainty is not established by the placement.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established as applicable because Saturn is in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The sole chart fact places Saturn in house 7. Among the listed rules, A directly matches that placement and assigns mixed polarity. B and C make unjustified absolute claims, while D is false because A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a mixed marriage indication in which stability may coexist with emotional coldness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is not treated as wholly beneficial; the listed rule characterizes it as mixed.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; such certainty is unsupported.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by Saturn's placement in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart directly places Saturn in house 7, so A applies. Because the task requires polarity based only on applicable listed statements, the conclusion is mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a mixed marriage indication in which stability may coexist with emotional coldness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is not treated as wholly beneficial; the listed rule characterizes it as mixed.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh does not necessarily end a marriage; such certainty is unsupported.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by Saturn's placement in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart directly places Saturn in house 7, so A applies. Because the task requires polarity based only on applicable listed statements, the conclusion is mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; therefore statement A applies as a challenging indication under the stated rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/sign","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The proposed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The ascendant is Aries and its lord is Mars. The seventh house is Libra and its lord is Venus. Saturn occupies the seventh but rules neither of those signs, satisfying statement A. The conclusion is challenging because polarity must reflect only the applicable listed statement; this does not establish or guarantee divorce."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; therefore statement A applies as a challenging indication under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/sign\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The proposed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The ascendant is Aries and its lord is Mars. The seventh house is Libra and its lord is Venus. Saturn occupies the seventh but rules neither of those signs, satisfying statement A. The conclusion is challenging because polarity must reflect only the applicable listed statement; this does not establish or guarantee divorce.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, supporting the listed indication of strong passion in partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/6/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated combination indicates strong passion but does not guarantee compatibility.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in the seventh house. Therefore, using only the polarity of the applicable listed statement, the conclusion is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, supporting the listed indication of strong passion in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated combination indicates strong passion but does not guarantee compatibility.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in the seventh house. Therefore, using only the polarity of the applicable listed statement, the conclusion is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, so the stated rule indicates strong passion in partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/6/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This combination may indicate strong passion, but it does not guarantee compatibility.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in house 7. Therefore, under the stated rule, the applicable polarity is supportive; neither Mars-alone nor guaranteed-compatibility claims follow."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, so the stated rule indicates strong passion in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This combination may indicate strong passion, but it does not guarantee compatibility.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in house 7. Therefore, under the stated rule, the applicable polarity is supportive; neither Mars-alone nor guaranteed-compatibility claims follow.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, so the listed rule indicating strong passion in partnership applies.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/6/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated combination indicates strong passion but does not guarantee compatibility.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in house 7. This supports the rule's positive indication of strong partnership passion, while neither proving Mars is alone nor guaranteeing compatibility."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars and Venus are conjunct in the seventh house, so the listed rule indicating strong passion in partnership applies.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars is not alone in the seventh house; Venus is also present there.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated combination indicates strong passion but does not guarantee compatibility.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars and Venus both occupy the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places both Mars and Venus in house 7. This supports the rule's positive indication of strong partnership passion, while neither proving Mars is alone nor guaranteeing compatibility.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of a considerate partner and gains through marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, Jupiter in the seventh is supportive rather than a primary indication of marital conflict.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the seventh may support favorable spouse indications, but it cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Jupiter is computed in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Jupiter is explicitly placed in house 7 and marked benefic. Therefore A applies. B reverses the stated rule, C makes an unjustified guarantee, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-04\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of a considerate partner and gains through marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, Jupiter in the seventh is supportive rather than a primary indication of marital conflict.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the seventh may support favorable spouse indications, but it cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Jupiter is computed in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Jupiter is explicitly placed in house 7 and marked benefic. Therefore A applies. B reverses the stated rule, C makes an unjustified guarantee, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, supporting the stated rule of a considerate partner and gains through marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jupiter in the seventh is treated by the stated rule as supportive, not as a primary indication of marital conflict.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A supportive placement cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Jupiter is placed in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A applies directly: Jupiter is a benefic occupying the seventh house of spouse and partnership. The listed rule is supportive, while B reverses its stated polarity and C makes an unjustified guarantee. Therefore the conclusion, based only on applicable listed statements, is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-04\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the seventh house, supporting the stated rule of a considerate partner and gains through marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the seventh is treated by the stated rule as supportive, not as a primary indication of marital conflict.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A supportive placement cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Jupiter is placed in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies directly: Jupiter is a benefic occupying the seventh house of spouse and partnership. The listed rule is supportive, while B reverses its stated polarity and C makes an unjustified guarantee. Therefore the conclusion, based only on applicable listed statements, is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-04","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the seventh house and, under the stated rule, supports a considerate partner and gains through marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jupiter in the seventh is treated by the listed rule as supportive, not as a primary indication of marital conflict.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may be supportive but cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Jupiter is in the seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Jupiter is a benefic placed in the seventh house of spouse and partnership, directly satisfying statement A. Statements B and C respectively invert the stated rule and overstate it as a guarantee; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-04\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the seventh house and, under the stated rule, supports a considerate partner and gains through marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the seventh is treated by the listed rule as supportive, not as a primary indication of marital conflict.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may be supportive but cannot guarantee a perfect spouse.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Jupiter is in the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Jupiter is a benefic placed in the seventh house of spouse and partnership, directly satisfying statement A. Statements B and C respectively invert the stated rule and overstate it as a guarantee; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the seventh may be treated as a challenging marriage indication, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a permissible interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a challenging indication into an absolute guarantee, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the seventh may be treated as a challenging marriage indication, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a permissible interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a challenging indication into an absolute guarantee, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; it is traditionally treated as a potential indicator of conflict, impatience, or tension in partnership, though it does not by itself determine the marital outcome.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a valid, proportionate Jyotish interpretation of Mars in the seventh. S2 incorrectly characterizes the placement as unambiguously harmonious, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; it is traditionally treated as a potential indicator of conflict, impatience, or tension in partnership, though it does not by itself determine the marital outcome.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a valid, proportionate Jyotish interpretation of Mars in the seventh. S2 incorrectly characterizes the placement as unambiguously harmonious, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the seventh house and may indicate clashes or tension in marriage; therefore S1 is not erroneous.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; in Jyotish it is commonly treated as a potential indicator of conflict, friction, or assertiveness in marriage.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S2 makes an unjustified categorical claim about a placement traditionally associated with possible marital friction. S3 directly contradicts the recorded house placement of Mars. S1 is doctrinally reasonable and factually applicable to this chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the seventh house and may indicate clashes or tension in marriage; therefore S1 is not erroneous.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; in Jyotish it is commonly treated as a potential indicator of conflict, friction, or assertiveness in marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S2 makes an unjustified categorical claim about a placement traditionally associated with possible marital friction. S3 directly contradicts the recorded house placement of Mars. S1 is doctrinally reasonable and factually applicable to this chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the seventh may indicate marital challenges, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage. No single placement establishes that marriage never occurs.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is not erroneous: the Sun is in the seventh house, whose significations include spouse and partnership, and treating this as a potentially challenging marital indication is doctrinally reasonable. S2 converts a possible challenge into an unsupported certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the seventh may indicate marital challenges, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage. No single placement establishes that marriage never occurs.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is not erroneous: the Sun is in the seventh house, whose significations include spouse and partnership, and treating this as a potentially challenging marital indication is doctrinally reasonable. S2 converts a possible challenge into an unsupported certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the seventh house, a placement traditionally associated with potential marital clashes or tension; therefore S1 is not erroneous.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; it is traditionally treated as a potential indicator of conflict, assertiveness, or tension in partnership, though the whole chart must qualify the outcome.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S2 makes an absolute harmonious claim inconsistent with the standard treatment of seventh-house Mars, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement. S1 is doctrinally reasonable and therefore excluded from the contradictions."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the seventh house, a placement traditionally associated with potential marital clashes or tension; therefore S1 is not erroneous.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the seventh is not unambiguously harmonious; it is traditionally treated as a potential indicator of conflict, assertiveness, or tension in partnership, though the whole chart must qualify the outcome.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Mars occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S2 makes an absolute harmonious claim inconsistent with the standard treatment of seventh-house Mars, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement. S1 is doctrinally reasonable and therefore excluded from the contradictions.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-contradiction-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the seventh may be treated as a challenging marriage indication, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/6/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is not erroneous: the Sun is in the seventh house, and describing it as a challenging indication associated with possible marital delay or trouble is a proportionate traditional interpretation. S2 improperly turns an indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the seventh may be treated as a challenging marriage indication, but it does not guarantee denial of marriage.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 7, not house 8.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is not erroneous: the Sun is in the seventh house, and describing it as a challenging indication associated with possible marital delay or trouble is a proportionate traditional interpretation. S2 improperly turns an indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is substantially pressured: it contains Sun and Mars, while Mars is in enemy dignity and combust. This can correlate with ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or excessive heat in partnership unless communication is consciously regulated.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/combust","/houses/6/occupants"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding a tendency toward detachment, dissatisfaction, unusual relationship dynamics, or intermittent distance.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, tying marriage to adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, and major transformation. This is a primary indication of complexity rather than effortless marital stability.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, and the chart explicitly records a Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yoga involving the 7th lord and ascendant lord. This can provide judgment, reconciliation capacity, or constructive growth through marital difficulties, though Jupiter's natal debility weakens uncomplicated protection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/yogas/1","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Venus in the 5th supports attraction, affection, romance, and the desire for a meaningful bond.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. Romantic life may therefore be intense, unconventional, idealized, delayed, or periodically unstable; attraction alone may not translate smoothly into settled partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The D9 repeats pressure on partnership: Sun occupies its 7th house and Mars occupies its 8th, suggesting that ego negotiation and crisis-management remain important themes after commitment.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"D9 Venus in the 5th supports affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter in Cancer provides strong underlying benefic potential; however, Jupiter is placed in the D9 12th, so support may operate through sacrifice, privacy, distance, spirituality, or substantial accommodation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house"]},{"claim":"D9 Saturn in the 11th can support endurance and gradual fulfillment of relationship goals, particularly with maturity, realistic expectations, and sustained effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/house"]},{"claim":"The debilitated Moon in the 12th can indicate emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep-related strain, or difficulty expressing vulnerability, potentially amplifying relationship misunderstandings.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord","Darakaraka","D9 house lordships, aspects, and dignity labels beyond sign placement","Shadbala and other quantitative strengths","Marriage timing or a specific date for dasha and transit assessment"],"rationale":"The dominant pattern is challenging because the 7th house is occupied by Sun and afflicted Mars, receives Ketu's aspect, and its lord Mercury is weakened in the 8th. The D9 reinforces the need to manage ego, conflict, and transformative pressures. Counterweights are meaningful: Venus supports affection, Jupiter connects protectively with the 7th lord, and D9 Venus and Saturn offer goodwill and endurance. Thus marriage is not denied by the supplied facts, but it is more likely to require maturity, transparency around intimacy and shared resources, emotional openness, and disciplined conflict management than to proceed effortlessly."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is substantially pressured: it contains Sun and Mars, while Mars is in enemy dignity and combust. This can correlate with ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or excessive heat in partnership unless communication is consciously regulated.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/houses/6/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house, adding a tendency toward detachment, dissatisfaction, unusual relationship dynamics, or intermittent distance.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, tying marriage to adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, and major transformation. This is a primary indication of complexity rather than effortless marital stability.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, and the chart explicitly records a Mercury–Jupiter mutual-aspect raja yoga involving the 7th lord and ascendant lord. This can provide judgment, reconciliation capacity, or constructive growth through marital difficulties, though Jupiter's natal debility weakens uncomplicated protection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus in the 5th supports attraction, affection, romance, and the desire for a meaningful bond.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. Romantic life may therefore be intense, unconventional, idealized, delayed, or periodically unstable; attraction alone may not translate smoothly into settled partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D9 repeats pressure on partnership: Sun occupies its 7th house and Mars occupies its 8th, suggesting that ego negotiation and crisis-management remain important themes after commitment.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Venus in the 5th supports affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter in Cancer provides strong underlying benefic potential; however, Jupiter is placed in the D9 12th, so support may operate through sacrifice, privacy, distance, spirituality, or substantial accommodation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Saturn in the 11th can support endurance and gradual fulfillment of relationship goals, particularly with maturity, realistic expectations, and sustained effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The debilitated Moon in the 12th can indicate emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep-related strain, or difficulty expressing vulnerability, potentially amplifying relationship misunderstandings.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord\",\"Darakaraka\",\"D9 house lordships, aspects, and dignity labels beyond sign placement\",\"Shadbala and other quantitative strengths\",\"Marriage timing or a specific date for dasha and transit assessment\"],\"rationale\":\"The dominant pattern is challenging because the 7th house is occupied by Sun and afflicted Mars, receives Ketu's aspect, and its lord Mercury is weakened in the 8th. The D9 reinforces the need to manage ego, conflict, and transformative pressures. Counterweights are meaningful: Venus supports affection, Jupiter connects protectively with the 7th lord, and D9 Venus and Saturn offer goodwill and endurance. Thus marriage is not denied by the supplied facts, but it is more likely to require maturity, transparency around intimacy and shared resources, emotional openness, and disciplined conflict management than to proceed effortlessly.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is strongly activated but afflicted: Sun and Mars occupy it, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate attraction and decisive partnerships alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or intermittent detachment.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"Mars in the 7th is additionally in an enemy sign and combust, increasing the need for deliberate anger management and non-confrontational communication in partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th in enemy dignity, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, or major transformation rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, and the chart explicitly records a mutual-aspect raja yoga between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. This provides a meaningful protective and problem-solving influence despite both planets' difficult natal dignity or placement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/yogas/1","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Venus, the natural marriage significator, occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting affection, attraction, and a love-oriented bond.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. This can produce intense or unconventional attraction but also idealization, irregular developments, delay, restraint, or periodic dissatisfaction in romance.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The family-sustaining 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 11th, favoring endurance, responsibility, and gradual consolidation of family and shared goals, although Ketu's conjunction can make fulfillment feel uneven or detached.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"The debilitated Moon in the 12th suggests emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy sensitivity, and a tendency to internalize relationship concerns.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"Navamsa repeats relationship pressure through Sun in the 7th and Mars in the 8th, indicating that power balance, conflict repair, and adaptation remain important after commitment.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus in the 5th supports affection and shared inspiration, while Jupiter in Cancer provides underlying benefic strength even though its 12th-house placement may express through sacrifice, privacy, distance, or spiritual growth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Saturn in the 11th supports durability and gains through patient cooperation, although results may mature gradually.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/house","/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.","Darakaraka and detailed shadbala or avastha assessments are not provided.","Navamsa house aspects and explicit divisional dignities are not provided.","No marriage date or requested forecast window was supplied, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed."],"rationale":"Marriage is neither denied nor uniformly easy. Strong 5th-house Venus, Jupiter's protective connection with the 7th lord, exalted Saturn as 2nd lord, and supportive Navamsa Venus/Jupiter/Saturn factors favor the capacity to form and sustain a meaningful bond. However, Sun-Mars in the 7th, Ketu's aspect, the 7th lord in the 8th, afflicted romance factors, and repeated Navamsa pressure indicate a relationship path requiring maturity, transparency, emotional availability, and careful conflict management. Overall the chart is mixed, with genuine sustaining factors but substantial adjustment demands."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is strongly activated but afflicted: Sun and Mars occupy it, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate attraction and decisive partnerships alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or intermittent detachment.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars in the 7th is additionally in an enemy sign and combust, increasing the need for deliberate anger management and non-confrontational communication in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th in enemy dignity, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, or major transformation rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, and the chart explicitly records a mutual-aspect raja yoga between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. This provides a meaningful protective and problem-solving influence despite both planets' difficult natal dignity or placement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the natural marriage significator, occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting affection, attraction, and a love-oriented bond.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. This can produce intense or unconventional attraction but also idealization, irregular developments, delay, restraint, or periodic dissatisfaction in romance.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The family-sustaining 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 11th, favoring endurance, responsibility, and gradual consolidation of family and shared goals, although Ketu's conjunction can make fulfillment feel uneven or detached.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The debilitated Moon in the 12th suggests emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy sensitivity, and a tendency to internalize relationship concerns.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa repeats relationship pressure through Sun in the 7th and Mars in the 8th, indicating that power balance, conflict repair, and adaptation remain important after commitment.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus in the 5th supports affection and shared inspiration, while Jupiter in Cancer provides underlying benefic strength even though its 12th-house placement may express through sacrifice, privacy, distance, or spiritual growth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Saturn in the 11th supports durability and gains through patient cooperation, although results may mature gradually.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.\",\"Darakaraka and detailed shadbala or avastha assessments are not provided.\",\"Navamsa house aspects and explicit divisional dignities are not provided.\",\"No marriage date or requested forecast window was supplied, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is neither denied nor uniformly easy. Strong 5th-house Venus, Jupiter's protective connection with the 7th lord, exalted Saturn as 2nd lord, and supportive Navamsa Venus/Jupiter/Saturn factors favor the capacity to form and sustain a meaningful bond. However, Sun-Mars in the 7th, Ketu's aspect, the 7th lord in the 8th, afflicted romance factors, and repeated Navamsa pressure indicate a relationship path requiring maturity, transparency, emotional availability, and careful conflict management. Overall the chart is mixed, with genuine sustaining factors but substantial adjustment demands.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th lord Venus occupies the 1st house and aspects the 7th, tightly linking partnership with identity and providing a basic supportive indication for marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, forming Sasa Yoga. This can support durability, duty, and endurance in partnership, though Saturn's retrogression and natural severity can manifest as delay, emotional reserve, unequal burdens, or a relationship requiring sustained maturity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Venus directly aspects Saturn in the 7th, blending the marriage significator and the 7th-house occupant; this supports commitment but combines affection with Saturnian restraint and responsibility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Ketu also aspects the 7th house, adding a possible pattern of periodic detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventionality, or reduced emotional immediacy within partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Mars is in the 3rd rather than the standard Manglik houses of 1, 2, 4, 7, 8, or 12, so the D1 chart does not show the usual house-based Manglik configuration.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, the 7th lord Venus is placed in the 11th house, which can connect marriage with companionship, networks, gains, and fulfillment of shared aims.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus is in Virgo, its debilitation sign, indicating that affection and intimacy may be filtered through criticism, perfectionism, practical obligations, or difficulty feeling fully satisfied. Its conjunction by sign and house with the Moon provides some emotional and relational support but can heighten sensitivity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/1/house"]},{"claim":"The Navamsa 7th house contains the Sun and Rahu, suggesting strong individuality, status or recognition concerns, unconventional circumstances, and possible ego or expectation conflicts in marriage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Saturn occupies Aries in the 6th, its debilitation sign and a conflict/service house, weakening the uncomplicated expression of the otherwise powerful natal 7th-house Saturn and indicating that durability may come through effort, adjustment, and problem-solving rather than ease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"The D1 lagna and 7th house receive nodal influence, reinforcing a non-simple partnership pattern involving intensity, discontinuity, unusual expectations, or periods of detachment.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord","Darakaraka","Shadbala and divisional strength metrics","Exact marriage date or requested forecast period for dasha and transit timing","Spouse's chart for compatibility assessment"],"rationale":"Marriage is clearly promised rather than denied: the 7th lord Venus links the 1st and 7th houses, while exalted Saturn gives the 7th house exceptional structural strength and endurance. The principal conflict is between D1 durability and D9 relational strain. Retrograde Saturn and Ketu make partnership serious and potentially delayed or emotionally restrained; Navamsa Venus in Virgo, debilitated Saturn in the 6th, and Sun–Rahu in the Navamsa 7th add criticism, conflict, unconventionality, and ego or expectation issues. Thus the synthesis is mixed: strong capacity for a lasting, duty-based union, but less indication of effortless harmony, with maturity, realistic expectations, and deliberate emotional communication likely important."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Venus occupies the 1st house and aspects the 7th, tightly linking partnership with identity and providing a basic supportive indication for marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, forming Sasa Yoga. This can support durability, duty, and endurance in partnership, though Saturn's retrogression and natural severity can manifest as delay, emotional reserve, unequal burdens, or a relationship requiring sustained maturity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus directly aspects Saturn in the 7th, blending the marriage significator and the 7th-house occupant; this supports commitment but combines affection with Saturnian restraint and responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu also aspects the 7th house, adding a possible pattern of periodic detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventionality, or reduced emotional immediacy within partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in the 3rd rather than the standard Manglik houses of 1, 2, 4, 7, 8, or 12, so the D1 chart does not show the usual house-based Manglik configuration.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, the 7th lord Venus is placed in the 11th house, which can connect marriage with companionship, networks, gains, and fulfillment of shared aims.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus is in Virgo, its debilitation sign, indicating that affection and intimacy may be filtered through criticism, perfectionism, practical obligations, or difficulty feeling fully satisfied. Its conjunction by sign and house with the Moon provides some emotional and relational support but can heighten sensitivity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Navamsa 7th house contains the Sun and Rahu, suggesting strong individuality, status or recognition concerns, unconventional circumstances, and possible ego or expectation conflicts in marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Saturn occupies Aries in the 6th, its debilitation sign and a conflict/service house, weakening the uncomplicated expression of the otherwise powerful natal 7th-house Saturn and indicating that durability may come through effort, adjustment, and problem-solving rather than ease.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D1 lagna and 7th house receive nodal influence, reinforcing a non-simple partnership pattern involving intensity, discontinuity, unusual expectations, or periods of detachment.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord\",\"Darakaraka\",\"Shadbala and divisional strength metrics\",\"Exact marriage date or requested forecast period for dasha and transit timing\",\"Spouse's chart for compatibility assessment\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is clearly promised rather than denied: the 7th lord Venus links the 1st and 7th houses, while exalted Saturn gives the 7th house exceptional structural strength and endurance. The principal conflict is between D1 durability and D9 relational strain. Retrograde Saturn and Ketu make partnership serious and potentially delayed or emotionally restrained; Navamsa Venus in Virgo, debilitated Saturn in the 6th, and Sun–Rahu in the Navamsa 7th add criticism, conflict, unconventionality, and ego or expectation issues. Thus the synthesis is mixed: strong capacity for a lasting, duty-based union, but less indication of effortless harmony, with maturity, realistic expectations, and deliberate emotional communication likely important.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.88,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is substantially afflicted: Sun and combust, enemy-sign Mars occupy it, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate strong attraction and initiative in partnership but also ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periods of detachment unless communication is handled carefully.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the 7th from the ascendant and the 8th sign from the natal Moon, reinforcing a notable Mangala influence on marriage; this is better read as elevated heat and conflict potential than as automatic denial.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Moon/sign"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury is in the 8th house and in enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, joint resources, sudden changes, and deep transformation. This can complicate stability or transparency.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury receives aspects from both Jupiter and exalted Saturn in the 8th house. Saturn may add seriousness, delay, duty, or endurance, while Jupiter offers some protection and capacity for constructive resolution.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"The chart explicitly identifies a mutual aspect and Raja Yoga between Mercury, lord of the 7th, and Jupiter, lord of the ascendant. This supports the possibility that partnership can contribute to growth and that difficulties need not amount to denial.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/yogas/1/grahas"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, ascendant lord and traditional marriage significator, is debilitated and retrograde in the 2nd house of family life. This weakens straightforward ease, but its placement still emphasizes building family and shared values, and its aspect to the 8th supports recovery through maturity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/aspects/Jupiter","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting romance and affection, but is joined by Rahu and the 5th is aspected by Saturn and Ketu. Romantic choices may therefore be unconventional, intense, idealized, delayed, or subject to abrupt changes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 11th, supporting the long-term construction of family resources and gains through patience, networks, and sustained commitment, although conjunction with Ketu can make gains or social expectations feel irregular or detached.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house, preserving themes of pride, visibility, authority, and the need for mutual respect within marriage.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign"]},{"claim":"The Navamsa 7th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, which supports eventual gains, fulfilment, and durability through partnership, often with a serious or gradual developmental pattern.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus in the 5th supports affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter in Cancer gives strong intrinsic dignity; however, Jupiter is in the 12th and Mars is in the 8th, retaining themes of sacrifice, privacy, expenses, intimacy adjustments, and transformational pressure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.","Darakaraka and detailed Jaimini marriage indicators are not supplied.","Shadbala, detailed aspect strength, and formal cancellation analysis for Jupiter's debility are not supplied.","No specific date or proposed marriage window was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed."],"rationale":"Marriage is indicated but not shown as effortless. The principal difficulties are the afflicted 7th house, Mars influence, and the 7th lord placed in the 8th. These suggest intensity, conflict potential, and significant adjustment rather than categorical denial. Counterweights include the Mercury–Jupiter relationship, exalted Saturn's capacity for endurance, a strong 2nd lord, Navamsa Venus in the 5th, and the Navamsa 7th lord in the 11th. The most balanced synthesis is therefore mixed: relationships can become durable and beneficial with maturity, transparent handling of joint matters, restrained conflict, and consistent mutual respect."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.88,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is substantially afflicted: Sun and combust, enemy-sign Mars occupy it, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate strong attraction and initiative in partnership but also ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periods of detachment unless communication is handled carefully.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 7th from the ascendant and the 8th sign from the natal Moon, reinforcing a notable Mangala influence on marriage; this is better read as elevated heat and conflict potential than as automatic denial.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Moon/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury is in the 8th house and in enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, joint resources, sudden changes, and deep transformation. This can complicate stability or transparency.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury receives aspects from both Jupiter and exalted Saturn in the 8th house. Saturn may add seriousness, delay, duty, or endurance, while Jupiter offers some protection and capacity for constructive resolution.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart explicitly identifies a mutual aspect and Raja Yoga between Mercury, lord of the 7th, and Jupiter, lord of the ascendant. This supports the possibility that partnership can contribute to growth and that difficulties need not amount to denial.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/yogas/1/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, ascendant lord and traditional marriage significator, is debilitated and retrograde in the 2nd house of family life. This weakens straightforward ease, but its placement still emphasizes building family and shared values, and its aspect to the 8th supports recovery through maturity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting romance and affection, but is joined by Rahu and the 5th is aspected by Saturn and Ketu. Romantic choices may therefore be unconventional, intense, idealized, delayed, or subject to abrupt changes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 11th, supporting the long-term construction of family resources and gains through patience, networks, and sustained commitment, although conjunction with Ketu can make gains or social expectations feel irregular or detached.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house, preserving themes of pride, visibility, authority, and the need for mutual respect within marriage.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Navamsa 7th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, which supports eventual gains, fulfilment, and durability through partnership, often with a serious or gradual developmental pattern.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus in the 5th supports affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter in Cancer gives strong intrinsic dignity; however, Jupiter is in the 12th and Mars is in the 8th, retaining themes of sacrifice, privacy, expenses, intimacy adjustments, and transformational pressure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.\",\"Darakaraka and detailed Jaimini marriage indicators are not supplied.\",\"Shadbala, detailed aspect strength, and formal cancellation analysis for Jupiter's debility are not supplied.\",\"No specific date or proposed marriage window was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is indicated but not shown as effortless. The principal difficulties are the afflicted 7th house, Mars influence, and the 7th lord placed in the 8th. These suggest intensity, conflict potential, and significant adjustment rather than categorical denial. Counterweights include the Mercury–Jupiter relationship, exalted Saturn's capacity for endurance, a strong 2nd lord, Navamsa Venus in the 5th, and the Navamsa 7th lord in the 11th. The most balanced synthesis is therefore mixed: relationships can become durable and beneficial with maturity, transparent handling of joint matters, restrained conflict, and consistent mutual respect.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.87,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th lord Venus occupies the ascendant and directly aspects the 7th house, strongly connecting partnership with identity and supporting the formation and importance of marriage.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"Venus is a natural benefic, non-combust, and in neutral dignity, so the principal marriage lord retains basic functional capacity in the D1 chart.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, creating Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This can support endurance, duty, and long-term commitment, but Saturn's nature and retrogression can also correlate with delay, gravity, distance, or recurring partnership lessons.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the ascendant while Venus occupies it, tightly linking self and partnership themes; this favors commitment but can make relationships feel demanding or responsibility-heavy.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 7th house, adding a potential tendency toward detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventional dynamics, or intermittent emotional distance in partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The D9 7th house contains both Sun and Rahu, indicating heightened individuality, unusual circumstances, status or control tensions, and possible volatility within the lived marital dynamic.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign"]},{"claim":"D9 Venus occupies Virgo in the 11th house. The 11th-house placement can support gains, companionship, and fulfillment through marriage, but Venus in Virgo is traditionally debilitated and may express as criticism, over-analysis, or difficulty feeling fully satisfied.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"D9 Saturn is in Aries in the 6th house, traditionally a debilitated placement associated with friction, duty, disputes, or adjustment burdens; this weakens some of the marital ease promised by exalted Saturn in D1.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house"]},{"claim":"D9 Moon joins Venus in the 11th house, offering a counterweight through emotional companionship, shared aspirations, and potential relational gains when expectations are managed constructively.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign"]},{"claim":"D9 Mercury occupies the ascendant with Ketu, suggesting that communication and analysis are central to marital functioning, while Ketu may introduce inwardness, ambiguity, or periodic disengagement.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/3/house","/vargas/D9/placements/8/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Exalted Saturn in the D1 7th house should not be read as purely harmful: its strength can give durability and commitment even while producing delay or heaviness.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/1"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The strong D1 Venus–7th-house connection does not by itself guarantee marital ease, because D9 Venus, Saturn, and the Rahu–Sun occupation of the D9 7th introduce substantial adjustment factors.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus","/vargas/D9/placements/5","/vargas/D9/placements/6","/vargas/D9/placements/0","/vargas/D9/placements/7"]}],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.","Darakaraka and Jaimini relationship indicators are not supplied.","Shadbala and detailed varga-strength measures are not supplied.","No specific date or life event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed."],"rationale":"Marriage is clearly promised and likely to be a major life theme because the 7th lord Venus is in the ascendant and aspects its own 7th house, while exalted Saturn gives the partnership house substantial strength and endurance. The same Saturn can make marriage serious, delayed, duty-bound, or emotionally restrained. D9 introduces the principal complications: debilitated Venus in Virgo, debilitated Saturn in the 6th, and Sun with Rahu in the 7th point toward criticism, adjustment burdens, unconventional circumstances, or power and autonomy tensions. Moon with Venus in the D9 11th offers companionship and shared-goal support. Overall, the chart is mixed rather than denying marriage: strong capacity for durable commitment exists, but harmony likely depends on patience, realistic expectations, emotional availability, and careful communication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.87,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Venus occupies the ascendant and directly aspects the 7th house, strongly connecting partnership with identity and supporting the formation and importance of marriage.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus is a natural benefic, non-combust, and in neutral dignity, so the principal marriage lord retains basic functional capacity in the D1 chart.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, creating Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This can support endurance, duty, and long-term commitment, but Saturn's nature and retrogression can also correlate with delay, gravity, distance, or recurring partnership lessons.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the ascendant while Venus occupies it, tightly linking self and partnership themes; this favors commitment but can make relationships feel demanding or responsibility-heavy.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 7th house, adding a potential tendency toward detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventional dynamics, or intermittent emotional distance in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D9 7th house contains both Sun and Rahu, indicating heightened individuality, unusual circumstances, status or control tensions, and possible volatility within the lived marital dynamic.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Venus occupies Virgo in the 11th house. The 11th-house placement can support gains, companionship, and fulfillment through marriage, but Venus in Virgo is traditionally debilitated and may express as criticism, over-analysis, or difficulty feeling fully satisfied.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Saturn is in Aries in the 6th house, traditionally a debilitated placement associated with friction, duty, disputes, or adjustment burdens; this weakens some of the marital ease promised by exalted Saturn in D1.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Moon joins Venus in the 11th house, offering a counterweight through emotional companionship, shared aspirations, and potential relational gains when expectations are managed constructively.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Mercury occupies the ascendant with Ketu, suggesting that communication and analysis are central to marital functioning, while Ketu may introduce inwardness, ambiguity, or periodic disengagement.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/8/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Exalted Saturn in the D1 7th house should not be read as purely harmful: its strength can give durability and commitment even while producing delay or heaviness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The strong D1 Venus–7th-house connection does not by itself guarantee marital ease, because D9 Venus, Saturn, and the Rahu–Sun occupation of the D9 7th introduce substantial adjustment factors.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.\",\"Darakaraka and Jaimini relationship indicators are not supplied.\",\"Shadbala and detailed varga-strength measures are not supplied.\",\"No specific date or life event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is clearly promised and likely to be a major life theme because the 7th lord Venus is in the ascendant and aspects its own 7th house, while exalted Saturn gives the partnership house substantial strength and endurance. The same Saturn can make marriage serious, delayed, duty-bound, or emotionally restrained. D9 introduces the principal complications: debilitated Venus in Virgo, debilitated Saturn in the 6th, and Sun with Rahu in the 7th point toward criticism, adjustment burdens, unconventional circumstances, or power and autonomy tensions. Moon with Venus in the D9 11th offers companionship and shared-goal support. Overall, the chart is mixed rather than denying marriage: strong capacity for durable commitment exists, but harmony likely depends on patience, realistic expectations, emotional availability, and careful communication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-02","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The marriage axis is prominent and potentially durable because exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, forming Sasa Yoga; this favors commitment, responsibility, endurance, and a mature or serious partnership, while retrogradation can make relationships slow to settle or repeatedly reconsidered.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Venus is in the 1st house and directly aspects the 7th, strongly connecting partnership with identity and supporting attraction, relationship orientation, and the capacity to sustain the marital axis.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the ascendant from the 7th, so partnership obligations can weigh heavily on personal freedom or self-expression even while increasing perseverance.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Ketu also aspects the natal 7th house, adding intermittent detachment, unconventional expectations, or periods of reduced emotional engagement that require conscious communication.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Mercury, ruler of communication-related matters in this chart, is in its own sign in the 3rd house, supporting problem-solving and articulate negotiation; however, conjunction there with Mars and Ketu can also produce sharp, impatient, or discontinuous communication.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/sign","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"The Moon in the 5th supports affection, romance, and emotional investment in relationship, although Rahu's aspect can amplify desire, idealization, or emotional fluctuation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, the 7th house contains Sun and Rahu, indicating that partnership can involve strong individuality, status concerns, unconventional circumstances, or power and expectation management.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus and Moon occupy the 11th house, supporting companionship, shared aspirations, social connection, and gains through partnership, though Venus's Virgo placement makes practical adjustment and criticism important themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Saturn occupies the 6th house, reinforcing the need to manage duties, disagreements, routines, and unequal burdens rather than expecting partnership to operate effortlessly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/house","/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter in a kendra provides a broad protective and conciliatory influence in the natal chart, supporting wisdom, ethics, and recovery from domestic strain, although it does not directly aspect the natal 7th house in the supplied aspect model.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/0","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.","Darakaraka is not identified.","Navamsa aspects and explicit Navamsa dignity assessments are not supplied.","The subject's gender and preferred spouse-karaka framework are unspecified.","No marriage date or requested forecast window is given, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed."],"rationale":"The chart strongly promises partnership significance: the 7th lord occupies the ascendant and aspects its own house, while exalted Saturn gives the 7th considerable structural strength. The same Saturn can delay, formalize, or burden relationship matters, and Ketu's influence adds detachment. Navamsa factors are less smooth—Sun and Rahu occupy the 7th and Saturn the 6th—showing that ego, unconventional expectations, conflict management, and daily responsibilities require sustained work. Venus and Moon in the Navamsa 11th preserve potential for companionship and shared goals. Overall, the marriage indications are mixed but viable and potentially durable rather than weak: stability is supported, while ease and emotional spontaneity are less consistently indicated."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The marriage axis is prominent and potentially durable because exalted Saturn occupies the 7th house, forming Sasa Yoga; this favors commitment, responsibility, endurance, and a mature or serious partnership, while retrogradation can make relationships slow to settle or repeatedly reconsidered.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Venus is in the 1st house and directly aspects the 7th, strongly connecting partnership with identity and supporting attraction, relationship orientation, and the capacity to sustain the marital axis.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the ascendant from the 7th, so partnership obligations can weigh heavily on personal freedom or self-expression even while increasing perseverance.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu also aspects the natal 7th house, adding intermittent detachment, unconventional expectations, or periods of reduced emotional engagement that require conscious communication.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, ruler of communication-related matters in this chart, is in its own sign in the 3rd house, supporting problem-solving and articulate negotiation; however, conjunction there with Mars and Ketu can also produce sharp, impatient, or discontinuous communication.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/sign\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon in the 5th supports affection, romance, and emotional investment in relationship, although Rahu's aspect can amplify desire, idealization, or emotional fluctuation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, the 7th house contains Sun and Rahu, indicating that partnership can involve strong individuality, status concerns, unconventional circumstances, or power and expectation management.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus and Moon occupy the 11th house, supporting companionship, shared aspirations, social connection, and gains through partnership, though Venus's Virgo placement makes practical adjustment and criticism important themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Saturn occupies the 6th house, reinforcing the need to manage duties, disagreements, routines, and unequal burdens rather than expecting partnership to operate effortlessly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter in a kendra provides a broad protective and conciliatory influence in the natal chart, supporting wisdom, ethics, and recovery from domestic strain, although it does not directly aspect the natal 7th house in the supplied aspect model.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.\",\"Darakaraka is not identified.\",\"Navamsa aspects and explicit Navamsa dignity assessments are not supplied.\",\"The subject's gender and preferred spouse-karaka framework are unspecified.\",\"No marriage date or requested forecast window is given, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart strongly promises partnership significance: the 7th lord occupies the ascendant and aspects its own house, while exalted Saturn gives the 7th considerable structural strength. The same Saturn can delay, formalize, or burden relationship matters, and Ketu's influence adds detachment. Navamsa factors are less smooth—Sun and Rahu occupy the 7th and Saturn the 6th—showing that ego, unconventional expectations, conflict management, and daily responsibilities require sustained work. Venus and Moon in the Navamsa 11th preserve potential for companionship and shared goals. Overall, the marriage indications are mixed but viable and potentially durable rather than weak: stability is supported, while ease and emotional spontaneity are less consistently indicated.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-knowledge-01","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes mixed health over time—comparatively weaker health earlier in life and improvement later. It does not indicate uniformly poor lifelong health or diagnose a specific illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.96,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes mixed health over time—comparatively weaker health earlier in life and improvement later. It does not indicate uniformly poor lifelong health or diagnose a specific illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-knowledge-01","confidence":0.93,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes a mixed health pattern over time: weaker health earlier in life followed by improved health later. It neither indicates uniformly poor lifelong health nor diagnoses a specific illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.93,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes a mixed health pattern over time: weaker health earlier in life followed by improved health later. It neither indicates uniformly poor lifelong health nor diagnoses a specific illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-knowledge-01","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes health as mixed over time—comparatively weaker earlier in life and improving later. It does not indicate uniformly poor lifelong health or diagnose a specific illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.96,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House2LordInHouse9 describes health as mixed over time—comparatively weaker earlier in life and improving later. It does not indicate uniformly poor lifelong health or diagnose a specific illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is occupied by the benefic Moon, supporting emotional engagement and the importance of partnership in life.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, linking marriage with gains, support networks, and fulfilment of desires.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, reinforcing protection and constructive partnership potential.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The reciprocal placement of the Moon as 11th lord in the 7th and Jupiter as 7th lord in the 11th strengthens the connection between partnership and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Mercury occupies the 8th house. Because Mercury rules Virgo, the Navamsa 7th sign from Pisces, this indicates that marriage may require adaptation through periods of vulnerability or transformation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/3/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus is in the 5th house with the Moon, supporting affection and emotional bonding, but Rahu's placement in the same sign and house adds intensity or unconventional expectations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house of family continuity contains exalted Saturn, which can support endurance and responsibility, while Ketu's aspect introduces some detachment or discontinuity in family dynamics.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["The condition, aspects, and dignity of the Navamsa 7th house and its lord are not explicitly supplied beyond sign and house placement, limiting doctrinal depth.","No Upapada Lagna, Darakaraka, or relevant marriage-timing periods were requested or provided for corroboration."],"rationale":"The Rasi chart gives substantial support: the 7th house contains a benefic Moon, its exalted lord Jupiter occupies the gainful 11th house, and Jupiter aspects its own 7th house. The Navamsa is less uniformly favorable because its inferred 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th, while Venus and Moon together in the 5th are complicated by Rahu. These factors support marriage potential and capacity for meaningful partnership, but also indicate emotional intensity and adjustment demands; therefore a mixed conclusion is more proportionate than an unequivocally supportive one."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is occupied by the benefic Moon, supporting emotional engagement and the importance of partnership in life.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, linking marriage with gains, support networks, and fulfilment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, reinforcing protection and constructive partnership potential.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The reciprocal placement of the Moon as 11th lord in the 7th and Jupiter as 7th lord in the 11th strengthens the connection between partnership and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Mercury occupies the 8th house. Because Mercury rules Virgo, the Navamsa 7th sign from Pisces, this indicates that marriage may require adaptation through periods of vulnerability or transformation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus is in the 5th house with the Moon, supporting affection and emotional bonding, but Rahu's placement in the same sign and house adds intensity or unconventional expectations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house of family continuity contains exalted Saturn, which can support endurance and responsibility, while Ketu's aspect introduces some detachment or discontinuity in family dynamics.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"The condition, aspects, and dignity of the Navamsa 7th house and its lord are not explicitly supplied beyond sign and house placement, limiting doctrinal depth.\",\"No Upapada Lagna, Darakaraka, or relevant marriage-timing periods were requested or provided for corroboration.\"],\"rationale\":\"The Rasi chart gives substantial support: the 7th house contains a benefic Moon, its exalted lord Jupiter occupies the gainful 11th house, and Jupiter aspects its own 7th house. The Navamsa is less uniformly favorable because its inferred 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th, while Venus and Moon together in the 5th are complicated by Rahu. These factors support marriage potential and capacity for meaningful partnership, but also indicate emotional intensity and adjustment demands; therefore a mixed conclusion is more proportionate than an unequivocally supportive one.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.97,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord Venus is placed in the ninth house; therefore the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/houses/1/sign","/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor lifelong health.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement rule provides only a broad health tendency and does not diagnose a specific illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the second lord Venus occupies the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A alone matches both the supplied rule and the computed chart placement. Accordingly, the polarity of the applicable listed statement is mixed."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.97,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord Venus is placed in the ninth house; therefore the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/houses/1/sign\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor lifelong health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement rule provides only a broad health tendency and does not diagnose a specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the second lord Venus occupies the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A alone matches both the supplied rule and the computed chart placement. Accordingly, the polarity of the applicable listed statement is mixed.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, so the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor lifelong health.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement-based rule does not diagnose a specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the second-house lord Venus occupies the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the computed chart places Venus in house 9. Therefore A is applicable. The polarity is mixed because the applicable statement itself combines an earlier challenge with later improvement. This is an astrological rule assessment, not a medical diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, so the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor lifelong health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement-based rule does not diagnose a specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the second-house lord Venus occupies the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the computed chart places Venus in house 9. Therefore A is applicable. The polarity is mixed because the applicable statement itself combines an earlier challenge with later improvement. This is an astrological rule assessment, not a medical diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord is Venus, and it is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule, this supports a mixed trajectory of weaker health early and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule describes change over time rather than uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement-based rule does not diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus, lord of the second house, occupies the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A directly matches the chart and the stated interpretive rule. Options B and C add claims the rule does not support, while D is excluded because A is established. The conclusion is therefore mixed, based only on the polarity of the applicable listed statement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord is Venus, and it is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule, this supports a mixed trajectory of weaker health early and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule describes change over time rather than uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement-based rule does not diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus, lord of the second house, occupies the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A directly matches the chart and the stated interpretive rule. Options B and C add claims the rule does not support, while D is excluded because A is established. The conclusion is therefore mixed, based only on the polarity of the applicable listed statement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is occupied by the benefic Moon, supporting emotional engagement and the importance of partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, connecting marriage with gains, networks, and fulfillment of desires.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, providing a substantial protective influence on partnership matters.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter/2","/houses/6/aspectedBy/0"]},{"claim":"The Moon as 11th lord occupies the 7th while the 7th lord occupies the 11th, creating a reciprocal connection between partnership and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Venus and Moon occupy the 5th house, which can support affection and emotional bonding, although Rahu in the same house may add unconventionality, intensity, or fluctuation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house"]},{"claim":"For the Pisces Navamsa ascendant, the 7th-sign ruler Mercury is placed in the 8th house, indicating that marriage may involve adjustment, vulnerability, or transformative pressures rather than operating entirely smoothly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/3/house"]},{"claim":"Mercury, which rules Virgo and therefore the natal ascendant, is combust; this may weaken clarity or communication in relationship dynamics, though it does not negate the stronger 7th-house protections.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific marriage event, date, or forecast window was supplied, so dasha and transit timing are not assessed.","Navamsa aspects and explicit Navamsa dignity data are not provided; no claims about them can be made.","The chart alone does not establish the lived quality, status, or history of a marriage without contextual information from the subject."],"rationale":"The D1 marriage indicators are notably supportive: the benefic Moon occupies the 7th, while exalted 7th lord Jupiter sits in the gainful 11th and aspects its own 7th house. The reciprocal 7th–11th lord connection further links partnership with gains and fulfillment. The D9 is less uniformly favorable because its 7th-sign ruler Mercury occupies the 8th, and Rahu joins Moon and Venus in the 5th. These factors suggest adjustment, intensity, or unconventional emotional patterns rather than denial. Overall, the evidence supports marriage potential but indicates a mixed relationship experience, so a wholly supportive conclusion would overstate the represented doctrine."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is occupied by the benefic Moon, supporting emotional engagement and the importance of partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, connecting marriage with gains, networks, and fulfillment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, providing a substantial protective influence on partnership matters.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter/2\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon as 11th lord occupies the 7th while the 7th lord occupies the 11th, creating a reciprocal connection between partnership and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Venus and Moon occupy the 5th house, which can support affection and emotional bonding, although Rahu in the same house may add unconventionality, intensity, or fluctuation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"For the Pisces Navamsa ascendant, the 7th-sign ruler Mercury is placed in the 8th house, indicating that marriage may involve adjustment, vulnerability, or transformative pressures rather than operating entirely smoothly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, which rules Virgo and therefore the natal ascendant, is combust; this may weaken clarity or communication in relationship dynamics, though it does not negate the stronger 7th-house protections.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific marriage event, date, or forecast window was supplied, so dasha and transit timing are not assessed.\",\"Navamsa aspects and explicit Navamsa dignity data are not provided; no claims about them can be made.\",\"The chart alone does not establish the lived quality, status, or history of a marriage without contextual information from the subject.\"],\"rationale\":\"The D1 marriage indicators are notably supportive: the benefic Moon occupies the 7th, while exalted 7th lord Jupiter sits in the gainful 11th and aspects its own 7th house. The reciprocal 7th–11th lord connection further links partnership with gains and fulfillment. The D9 is less uniformly favorable because its 7th-sign ruler Mercury occupies the 8th, and Rahu joins Moon and Venus in the 5th. These factors suggest adjustment, intensity, or unconventional emotional patterns rather than denial. Overall, the evidence supports marriage potential but indicates a mixed relationship experience, so a wholly supportive conclusion would overstate the represented doctrine.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-03","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.79,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The natal 7th house is occupied by benefic Moon, supporting emotional investment in partnership and public relationships.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/houses/6/significations"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, connecting marriage with gains, networks, and fulfillment of desires.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, reinforcing protection and constructive potential for partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The Moon as 11th lord occupies the 7th while the 7th lord occupies the 11th, creating a strong reciprocal connection between partnership and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Venus and Moon share the 5th house in Cancer, providing support for affection, emotional bonding, and relational warmth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Rahu also occupies the 5th house with Moon and Venus, suggesting that romance or emotional expectations may sometimes become unconventional, amplified, or difficult to regulate.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/1/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/7/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Mercury occupies the 8th house, indicating that communication and adjustment may encounter periods of strain or require deeper mutual transparency.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/3/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["The task does not specify whether the question concerns marriage potential, timing, spouse characteristics, or marital stability; therefore no event timing or narrowly targeted judgment is possible.","Navamsa house lordships, aspects, dignity classifications, and conjunction data are not explicitly supplied, limiting more detailed doctrinal assessment."],"rationale":"The represented evidence is predominantly supportive: the natal 7th house contains benefic Moon, receives Jupiter's aspect, and its lord Jupiter is exalted in the gains-oriented 11th house. The reciprocal linkage between the 7th and 11th houses further strengthens partnership potential. The Navamsa adds affectionate indications through Moon and Venus together in the 5th, but Rahu's participation and Mercury in the 8th introduce complexity in expectations, communication, and adjustment. Thus the chart supports marriage overall without establishing that married life must be uniformly easy or guaranteeing a particular outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.79,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The natal 7th house is occupied by benefic Moon, supporting emotional investment in partnership and public relationships.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Jupiter is exalted in the 11th house, connecting marriage with gains, networks, and fulfillment of desires.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter directly aspects the 7th house, reinforcing protection and constructive potential for partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon as 11th lord occupies the 7th while the 7th lord occupies the 11th, creating a strong reciprocal connection between partnership and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Venus and Moon share the 5th house in Cancer, providing support for affection, emotional bonding, and relational warmth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Rahu also occupies the 5th house with Moon and Venus, suggesting that romance or emotional expectations may sometimes become unconventional, amplified, or difficult to regulate.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/7/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Mercury occupies the 8th house, indicating that communication and adjustment may encounter periods of strain or require deeper mutual transparency.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"The task does not specify whether the question concerns marriage potential, timing, spouse characteristics, or marital stability; therefore no event timing or narrowly targeted judgment is possible.\",\"Navamsa house lordships, aspects, dignity classifications, and conjunction data are not explicitly supplied, limiting more detailed doctrinal assessment.\"],\"rationale\":\"The represented evidence is predominantly supportive: the natal 7th house contains benefic Moon, receives Jupiter's aspect, and its lord Jupiter is exalted in the gains-oriented 11th house. The reciprocal linkage between the 7th and 11th houses further strengthens partnership potential. The Navamsa adds affectionate indications through Moon and Venus together in the 5th, but Rahu's participation and Mercury in the 8th introduce complexity in expectations, communication, and adjustment. Thus the chart supports marriage overall without establishing that married life must be uniformly easy or guaranteeing a particular outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury, the second-house lord, is placed in the eleventh house; under the stated rule this is treated as a challenging childhood-health indication.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement may indicate childhood-health challenges under the rule, but it does not guarantee lifelong illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats this placement as challenging rather than as independently establishing strong childhood vitality.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the second-house lord in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A directly matches the supplied placement and the stated rule. Options B and C improperly expand or reverse that limited indication, while D is false because A applies. This is an astrological indication, not a medical diagnosis or certainty."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury, the second-house lord, is placed in the eleventh house; under the stated rule this is treated as a challenging childhood-health indication.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement may indicate childhood-health challenges under the rule, but it does not guarantee lifelong illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats this placement as challenging rather than as independently establishing strong childhood vitality.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the second-house lord in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A directly matches the supplied placement and the stated rule. Options B and C improperly expand or reverse that limited indication, while D is false because A applies. This is an astrological indication, not a medical diagnosis or certainty.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second-house lord is Mercury and is placed in the eleventh house, matching the stated challenging childhood-health rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may be treated as a challenging childhood-health indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee lifelong illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, this placement does not by itself establish strong childhood vitality.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart places the second lord in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A applies directly: the chart explicitly records the second-house lord in house 11. The resulting polarity is challenging, limited to a non-certain childhood-health indication. Options B and C improperly strengthen or reverse that indication, so D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second-house lord is Mercury and is placed in the eleventh house, matching the stated challenging childhood-health rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may be treated as a challenging childhood-health indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee lifelong illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, this placement does not by itself establish strong childhood vitality.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart places the second lord in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies directly: the chart explicitly records the second-house lord in house 11. The resulting polarity is challenging, limited to a non-certain childhood-health indication. Options B and C improperly strengthen or reverse that indication, so D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"For Capricorn lagna, Jupiter rules the twelfth house and is placed in the sixth; under the stated rule, this is treated as supportive of general physical resilience.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement may be treated as supportive, but it does not guarantee freedom from illness.","evidence":["/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as supportive rather than necessarily indicating weak vitality.","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the twelfth lord Jupiter is placed in the sixth house.","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A applies. The chart explicitly places Jupiter, lord of the twelfth house, in the sixth and identifies this dusthana-lord-in-dusthana configuration as Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Its health implication should remain proportionate: supportive of resilience, not immunity from illness or a guaranteed medical outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"For Capricorn lagna, Jupiter rules the twelfth house and is placed in the sixth; under the stated rule, this is treated as supportive of general physical resilience.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement may be treated as supportive, but it does not guarantee freedom from illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as supportive rather than necessarily indicating weak vitality.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the twelfth lord Jupiter is placed in the sixth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies. The chart explicitly places Jupiter, lord of the twelfth house, in the sixth and identifies this dusthana-lord-in-dusthana configuration as Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Its health implication should remain proportionate: supportive of resilience, not immunity from illness or a guaranteed medical outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, the twelfth-house lord, occupies the sixth house; under the stated rule this is supportive of general physical resilience, without implying immunity from illness.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2/because"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement may support resilience through a viparita pattern, but it does not guarantee freedom from illness.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2/because"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as a supportive viparita placement, not as necessarily indicating weak vitality.","evidence":["/yogas/2/name","/yogas/2/because"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the twelfth lord Jupiter in the sixth house.","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A applies. The chart identifies Jupiter as lord of the twelfth and places it in the sixth, explicitly recognizing Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Its polarity under the listed rule is supportive, while B improperly guarantees health and C reverses the rule's stated implication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, the twelfth-house lord, occupies the sixth house; under the stated rule this is supportive of general physical resilience, without implying immunity from illness.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2/because\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement may support resilience through a viparita pattern, but it does not guarantee freedom from illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2/because\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as a supportive viparita placement, not as necessarily indicating weak vitality.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2/name\",\"/yogas/2/because\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the twelfth lord Jupiter in the sixth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A applies. The chart identifies Jupiter as lord of the twelfth and places it in the sixth, explicitly recognizing Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Its polarity under the listed rule is supportive, while B improperly guarantees health and C reverses the rule's stated implication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the twelfth house, occupies the sixth house; under the stated rule this is treated as supportive of general physical resilience.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2/because"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement may support resilience but does not guarantee freedom from illness.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as supportive rather than necessarily indicating weak vitality.","evidence":["/yogas/2/because"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the twelfth lord Jupiter is placed in the sixth house.","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A alone applies. The chart explicitly identifies Jupiter as twelfth-house lord placed in the sixth and classifies this dusthana-lord-in-dusthana configuration as Vipareeta Raja Yoga. This supports a qualified resilience reading; it neither guarantees absence of illness nor necessarily denotes weak vitality."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the twelfth house, occupies the sixth house; under the stated rule this is treated as supportive of general physical resilience.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2/because\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement may support resilience but does not guarantee freedom from illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the twelfth lord in the sixth as supportive rather than necessarily indicating weak vitality.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2/because\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the twelfth lord Jupiter is placed in the sixth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A alone applies. The chart explicitly identifies Jupiter as twelfth-house lord placed in the sixth and classifies this dusthana-lord-in-dusthana configuration as Vipareeta Raja Yoga. This supports a qualified resilience reading; it neither guarantees absence of illness nor necessarily denotes weak vitality.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.97,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart facts provide a lord placed in the eleventh house, but identify it at /houses/1 rather than supplying the second-house lord; therefore the stated second-lord rule cannot be applied.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"omission","correction":"Applicability requires evidence that the second-house lord is placed in the eleventh house; that fact is absent.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"No supplied fact or stated rule supports a guarantee of lifelong illness.","evidence":[]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The available placement does not by itself establish strong childhood vitality.","evidence":[]}],"missing_information":["The identity and house placement of the second-house lord."],"rationale":"Option D is applicable because the supplied chart data do not establish the required second-lord-in-eleventh premise. Options B and C also make unsupported absolute or affirmative health claims."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.97,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart facts provide a lord placed in the eleventh house, but identify it at /houses/1 rather than supplying the second-house lord; therefore the stated second-lord rule cannot be applied.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"Applicability requires evidence that the second-house lord is placed in the eleventh house; that fact is absent.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"No supplied fact or stated rule supports a guarantee of lifelong illness.\",\"evidence\":[]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The available placement does not by itself establish strong childhood vitality.\",\"evidence\":[]}],\"missing_information\":[\"The identity and house placement of the second-house lord.\"],\"rationale\":\"Option D is applicable because the supplied chart data do not establish the required second-lord-in-eleventh premise. Options B and C also make unsupported absolute or affirmative health claims.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","domain":"health","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single astrological placement cannot prove a medical diagnosis.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The stated rule classifies Venus in the third as challenging rather than as an unqualified strong-vitality indication.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart places Venus in the third house. Therefore A is the sole applicable listed statement. This is only an astrological vitality indication and not a medical diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-04\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single astrological placement cannot prove a medical diagnosis.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule classifies Venus in the third as challenging rather than as an unqualified strong-vitality indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart places Venus in the third house. Therefore A is the sole applicable listed statement. This is only an astrological vitality indication and not a medical diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun’s placement in the 6th house may be treated as a general health-related challenge in Jyotish, but it does not prove or diagnose heart disease.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/5/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is acceptable because it gives a non-diagnostic astrological interpretation of the Sun in the health-related 6th house. S2 improperly turns that indication into a specific medical diagnosis. S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun’s placement in the 6th house may be treated as a general health-related challenge in Jyotish, but it does not prove or diagnose heart disease.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is acceptable because it gives a non-diagnostic astrological interpretation of the Sun in the health-related 6th house. S2 improperly turns that indication into a specific medical diagnosis. S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","domain":"health","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single astrological placement does not prove a medical diagnosis.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the rule being tested, Venus in the third is challenging rather than an unqualified strong-vitality indication.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly places Venus in the third house. Therefore A is the sole applicable listed statement. This is an astrological vitality indication only and not a medical diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-04\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single astrological placement does not prove a medical diagnosis.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the rule being tested, Venus in the third is challenging rather than an unqualified strong-vitality indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly places Venus in the third house. Therefore A is the sole applicable listed statement. This is an astrological vitality indication only and not a medical diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-04","domain":"health","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A single astrological placement does not prove a medical diagnosis.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, Venus in the third is challenging rather than an unqualified strong-vitality indication.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart places Venus in the third house. Therefore A applies under the rule supplied in the task. B improperly converts an astrological indication into diagnostic proof, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-04\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the third house, so under the stated rule it is treated as a challenging indication for vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A single astrological placement does not prove a medical diagnosis.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, Venus in the third is challenging rather than an unqualified strong-vitality indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus is computed in house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart places Venus in the third house. Therefore A applies under the rule supplied in the task. B improperly converts an astrological indication into diagnostic proof, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun occupies the sixth house, a house associated with disease and health challenges, but this placement does not prove heart disease or establish any medical diagnosis.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/5/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is not erroneous because it describes a general astrological health indication without diagnosing a condition. S2 improperly converts that indication into a certain medical diagnosis, while S3 misstates the Sun's house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies the sixth house, a house associated with disease and health challenges, but this placement does not prove heart disease or establish any medical diagnosis.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is not erroneous because it describes a general astrological health indication without diagnosing a condition. S2 improperly converts that indication into a certain medical diagnosis, while S3 misstates the Sun's house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun’s placement in the 6th may be treated as a general health-related challenge, but it does not prove heart disease or establish any medical diagnosis.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/5/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a cautious, non-diagnostic interpretation consistent with the Sun occupying the disease-signifying 6th house. S2 improperly converts an astrological indication into a certain medical diagnosis. S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun’s placement in the 6th may be treated as a general health-related challenge, but it does not prove heart disease or establish any medical diagnosis.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The Sun occupies house 6, not house 7.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a cautious, non-diagnostic interpretation consistent with the Sun occupying the disease-signifying 6th house. S2 improperly converts an astrological indication into a certain medical diagnosis. S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vitality, or a robust physique, but it does not guarantee perfect health.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list because Mars occupies its own sign, Scorpio, in the 4th house, a kendra.","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S1 is a proportionate interpretation of the listed Ruchaka Yoga; S2 improperly turns a supportive indication into a health guarantee, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vitality, or a robust physique, but it does not guarantee perfect health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list because Mars occupies its own sign, Scorpio, in the 4th house, a kendra.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S1 is a proportionate interpretation of the listed Ruchaka Yoga; S2 improperly turns a supportive indication into a health guarantee, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vigor, and physical resilience, but it does not guarantee perfect health.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga is present in the computed yoga list because Mars occupies its own sign, Scorpio, in the 4th house, a kendra.","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a proportionate interpretation of Ruchaka Yoga and is not erroneous. S2 improperly converts a supportive indication into a certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vigor, and physical resilience, but it does not guarantee perfect health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga is present in the computed yoga list because Mars occupies its own sign, Scorpio, in the 4th house, a kendra.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a proportionate interpretation of Ruchaka Yoga and is not erroneous. S2 improperly converts a supportive indication into a certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-contradiction-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Ruchaka Yoga is present because Mars occupies a kendra in its own sign; treating this as supportive of physical strength is reasonable, but it does not guarantee health.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vitality, courage, or a robust constitution, but it cannot guarantee perfect health; health assessment requires the broader chart.","evidence":["/yogas/0","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list.","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S1 is a proportionate interpretation of the listed Ruchaka Yoga. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Ruchaka Yoga is present because Mars occupies a kendra in its own sign; treating this as supportive of physical strength is reasonable, but it does not guarantee health.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga may support strength, vitality, courage, or a robust constitution, but it cannot guarantee perfect health; health assessment requires the broader chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ruchaka Yoga is explicitly present in the computed yoga list.\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only S2 and S3 are erroneous. S1 is a proportionate interpretation of the listed Ruchaka Yoga. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the computed yoga list.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The lagna lord Saturn is placed in the 11th, an upachaya associated with gradual development, but it is in enemy dignity and joined Mars and Rahu; this suggests resilience that may require sustained discipline amid intermittent strain.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the 1st house, placing a restrictive or chronic-pressure influence directly on the body and vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"The Sun occupies the 1st house in enemy dignity, indicating that vitality is prominent but not uniformly protected.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury also occupies the 1st house and is the 6th-house lord, directly linking disease, service and daily-health themes with the body; its benefic status and lack of combustion offer some capacity for management and adaptation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"The 6th house is unoccupied, avoiding direct natal occupation, but receives Mars's aspect; this can signify acute, inflammatory, injury-prone or conflict-related stress without establishing any specific medical condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th house in friend dignity, offering some protective or recovery-oriented capacity in chronic and transformative matters; however, its retrogression and the 8th-house placement make this protection complex rather than straightforward.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"The 8th house is also aspected by Saturn and the Moon, combining pressure or persistence with a benefic lunar influence; this reinforces a mixed picture around chronic vulnerability and recovery.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Moon/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The Moon is marked combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter in the 2nd house, suggesting sensitivity or fluctuation moderated by Jupiter's benefic influence; this is an astrological indication, not a psychological or medical diagnosis.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Jupiter is placed in the 8th, forming the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga; this can indicate an ability to derive eventual improvement or resilience through difficult periods, though it does not eliminate health stress.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because"]},{"claim":"No graha occupies the 12th house, but Jupiter aspects it, providing a benefic influence over hospitalization, isolation, expenditure and recuperative themes.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/houses/11/aspectedBy","/aspects/Jupiter"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D6/Shashtamsha or another dedicated disease divisional chart is not provided.","No current symptoms, diagnoses, medical history, lifestyle factors or family history are supplied; the chart cannot establish a medical condition.","No specific assessment date was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not incorporated."],"rationale":"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable pressure. Protective elements include an unoccupied 6th house, benefic Jupiter in friend dignity in the 8th, Jupiter's aspect to the 12th, and the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Challenges arise because the lagna lord is in enemy dignity and conjoined Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the lagna, the 6th lord occupies the 1st, and Mars aspects the 6th. Jupiter and other benefic influences moderate—but do not cancel—these factors. Overall, the natal health indication is mixed: capacity for endurance and recovery is present, while disciplined routines and ordinary preventive medical care are especially appropriate. Astrology should not replace clinical evaluation."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The lagna lord Saturn is placed in the 11th, an upachaya associated with gradual development, but it is in enemy dignity and joined Mars and Rahu; this suggests resilience that may require sustained discipline amid intermittent strain.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the 1st house, placing a restrictive or chronic-pressure influence directly on the body and vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the 1st house in enemy dignity, indicating that vitality is prominent but not uniformly protected.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury also occupies the 1st house and is the 6th-house lord, directly linking disease, service and daily-health themes with the body; its benefic status and lack of combustion offer some capacity for management and adaptation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house is unoccupied, avoiding direct natal occupation, but receives Mars's aspect; this can signify acute, inflammatory, injury-prone or conflict-related stress without establishing any specific medical condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th house in friend dignity, offering some protective or recovery-oriented capacity in chronic and transformative matters; however, its retrogression and the 8th-house placement make this protection complex rather than straightforward.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house is also aspected by Saturn and the Moon, combining pressure or persistence with a benefic lunar influence; this reinforces a mixed picture around chronic vulnerability and recovery.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is marked combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter in the 2nd house, suggesting sensitivity or fluctuation moderated by Jupiter's benefic influence; this is an astrological indication, not a psychological or medical diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Jupiter is placed in the 8th, forming the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga; this can indicate an ability to derive eventual improvement or resilience through difficult periods, though it does not eliminate health stress.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"No graha occupies the 12th house, but Jupiter aspects it, providing a benefic influence over hospitalization, isolation, expenditure and recuperative themes.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D6/Shashtamsha or another dedicated disease divisional chart is not provided.\",\"No current symptoms, diagnoses, medical history, lifestyle factors or family history are supplied; the chart cannot establish a medical condition.\",\"No specific assessment date was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not incorporated.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable pressure. Protective elements include an unoccupied 6th house, benefic Jupiter in friend dignity in the 8th, Jupiter's aspect to the 12th, and the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Challenges arise because the lagna lord is in enemy dignity and conjoined Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the lagna, the 6th lord occupies the 1st, and Mars aspects the 6th. Jupiter and other benefic influences moderate—but do not cancel—these factors. Overall, the natal health indication is mixed: capacity for endurance and recovery is present, while disciplined routines and ordinary preventive medical care are especially appropriate. Astrology should not replace clinical evaluation.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, an upachaya associated with gradual development, but it is in enemy dignity and joined Mars and Rahu; this suggests resilience may improve through discipline while health pressures can become persistent or episodically aggravated.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the 1st house, directly connecting the ascendant lord to the body but adding a restrictive or chronic-pressure quality to vitality.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 1st house contains Sun and Mercury. Mercury is benefic and not combust, supporting adaptability and management capacity; Sun is in enemy dignity, reducing the consistency of the vitality indicator.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/0/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury occupies the 1st house, tightly linking disease, strain, service, and daily routines with the body. This can increase health sensitivity, although Mercury's benefic status and lack of combustion offer some capacity for practical management.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, indicating forceful resistance and capacity to confront difficulties, but also a tendency toward inflammatory, acute, competitive, or overexertion-type astrological pressures; this is an indication, not a medical diagnosis.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a benefic in friendly dignity, occupies the 8th house and can provide protection, recovery capacity, and constructive transformation in chronic or sudden matters. Its retrogression and the 8th-house placement make the protection less straightforward.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"The 8th house receives aspects from Moon and Saturn. Moon supplies a benefic influence, while Saturn adds persistence, delay, or chronicity, producing a mixed indication for recovery and long-running vulnerabilities.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/placements/Saturn/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 8th lord Sun is placed in the 1st house, linking transformative, sudden, or chronic themes directly to the body; Sun's enemy dignity makes this a notable vulnerability factor.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/7/lord","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Jupiter is in the 8th and aspects the 12th, creating a viparita-type configuration that may support recovery through adversity, retreat, or sustained care, while still emphasizing expenditure, isolation, and chronic-management themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Jupiter","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a general indicator of mental and bodily rhythms, is marked combust in the supplied data and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter through its 2nd-house placement; this combines sensitivity or depletion with some benefic protection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Shadbala and avastha measurements are unavailable, so the exact functional strength of the ascendant lord, Sun, Mercury, and Jupiter cannot be quantified.","A health-specific divisional chart such as D6 or D30 is not provided.","No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle context, or event date is supplied; therefore this synthesis cannot identify a condition or assess timing.","Dashas and transits were not used because the task requests a general chart synthesis rather than analysis for a specified date."],"rationale":"The chart combines meaningful resilience with substantial pressure. Protective features include Mercury in the ascendant, benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity in the 8th, Jupiter's aspect to the 12th, and the ascendant lord occupying an upachaya. Challenges arise because Saturn is in enemy dignity and conjoined Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the ascendant, the 6th lord occupies the 1st, Mars aspects the 6th, and the 8th lord occupies the 1st in enemy dignity. Overall, the natal pattern is mixed rather than uniformly weak: it suggests capacity to manage and recover, but with a need for consistent routines and appropriate professional care when concerns arise. It does not support diagnosing any specific illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, an upachaya associated with gradual development, but it is in enemy dignity and joined Mars and Rahu; this suggests resilience may improve through discipline while health pressures can become persistent or episodically aggravated.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the 1st house, directly connecting the ascendant lord to the body but adding a restrictive or chronic-pressure quality to vitality.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 1st house contains Sun and Mercury. Mercury is benefic and not combust, supporting adaptability and management capacity; Sun is in enemy dignity, reducing the consistency of the vitality indicator.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury occupies the 1st house, tightly linking disease, strain, service, and daily routines with the body. This can increase health sensitivity, although Mercury's benefic status and lack of combustion offer some capacity for practical management.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, indicating forceful resistance and capacity to confront difficulties, but also a tendency toward inflammatory, acute, competitive, or overexertion-type astrological pressures; this is an indication, not a medical diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a benefic in friendly dignity, occupies the 8th house and can provide protection, recovery capacity, and constructive transformation in chronic or sudden matters. Its retrogression and the 8th-house placement make the protection less straightforward.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house receives aspects from Moon and Saturn. Moon supplies a benefic influence, while Saturn adds persistence, delay, or chronicity, producing a mixed indication for recovery and long-running vulnerabilities.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Saturn/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th lord Sun is placed in the 1st house, linking transformative, sudden, or chronic themes directly to the body; Sun's enemy dignity makes this a notable vulnerability factor.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Jupiter is in the 8th and aspects the 12th, creating a viparita-type configuration that may support recovery through adversity, retreat, or sustained care, while still emphasizing expenditure, isolation, and chronic-management themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a general indicator of mental and bodily rhythms, is marked combust in the supplied data and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter through its 2nd-house placement; this combines sensitivity or depletion with some benefic protection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and avastha measurements are unavailable, so the exact functional strength of the ascendant lord, Sun, Mercury, and Jupiter cannot be quantified.\",\"A health-specific divisional chart such as D6 or D30 is not provided.\",\"No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle context, or event date is supplied; therefore this synthesis cannot identify a condition or assess timing.\",\"Dashas and transits were not used because the task requests a general chart synthesis rather than analysis for a specified date.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines meaningful resilience with substantial pressure. Protective features include Mercury in the ascendant, benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity in the 8th, Jupiter's aspect to the 12th, and the ascendant lord occupying an upachaya. Challenges arise because Saturn is in enemy dignity and conjoined Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the ascendant, the 6th lord occupies the 1st, Mars aspects the 6th, and the 8th lord occupies the 1st in enemy dignity. Overall, the natal pattern is mixed rather than uniformly weak: it suggests capacity to manage and recover, but with a need for consistent routines and appropriate professional care when concerns arise. It does not support diagnosing any specific illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Constitutional resilience is supported by a Cancer lagna whose lord Moon occupies the auspicious 5th house, although the Moon's debilitation makes vitality and emotional equilibrium potentially variable rather than uniformly strong.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"The lagna receives pressure from strong Mars and exalted Saturn, suggesting endurance and capacity to withstand strain but also a tendency toward stress, overexertion, or periods of reduced ease; Venusian influence provides some mitigation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/aspects/Venus"]},{"claim":"The lagna lord Moon is debilitated and aspected by Mars, which is a vulnerability factor for fluctuations in subjective well-being, reactivity, and recuperative balance. This is an astrological tendency, not a medical diagnosis.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of illness and recovery contains Rahu and receives Saturn and Ketu influences, indicating potentially irregular, persistent, or complicated health challenges that may require disciplined management.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/significations","/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Jupiter occupies the 12th house in enemy dignity and is retrograde, linking health burdens with expenditure, withdrawal, sleep or institutional settings; however, its placement forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, traditionally indicating capacity to overcome adversity after difficulty.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"The 8th house, relevant to chronic and transformative matters, contains Mercury and receives Jupiter and Ketu influences. This adds complexity, while Jupiter's benefic influence offers partial protection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/significations","/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 12th house contains Jupiter and Ketu and is ruled by Mercury placed in the 8th, reinforcing links among health strain, recuperative isolation, expenses, and chronic or hidden matters. The listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga provides a countervailing indication of resilience through adversity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"Mars is exceptionally strong in its own sign in the 10th and forms Ruchaka Yoga, supporting drive, physical initiative, and recovery capacity, though its aspect to the lagna and Moon's house can make that energy forceful or taxing.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/yogas/0","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"The Sun, a general vitality significator, occupies the auspicious 9th house in friendly dignity without combustion, providing a modest protective factor.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/combust"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, supporting endurance, discipline, and long-term management, but its aspects to the 1st and 6th houses can also signify sustained burdens or slower recovery patterns.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1","/aspects/Saturn"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No medical history, symptoms, diagnoses, lifestyle data, or treatment context is provided; astrology cannot replace clinical assessment.","No specific date or health event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used."],"rationale":"The chart combines substantial resilience—strong Mars, exalted Saturn, two Vipareeta Raja Yogas, and a well-placed Sun—with meaningful vulnerabilities involving a debilitated lagna lord, Rahu in the 6th, and interconnected 6th, 8th, and 12th houses. The technical balance is therefore mixed: endurance and capacity to manage adversity appear stronger than average, but health may be sensitive to stress, irregularity, overexertion, and issues requiring persistent management. These are broad Jyotish indications and not medical findings."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Constitutional resilience is supported by a Cancer lagna whose lord Moon occupies the auspicious 5th house, although the Moon's debilitation makes vitality and emotional equilibrium potentially variable rather than uniformly strong.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The lagna receives pressure from strong Mars and exalted Saturn, suggesting endurance and capacity to withstand strain but also a tendency toward stress, overexertion, or periods of reduced ease; Venusian influence provides some mitigation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/aspects/Venus\"]},{\"claim\":\"The lagna lord Moon is debilitated and aspected by Mars, which is a vulnerability factor for fluctuations in subjective well-being, reactivity, and recuperative balance. This is an astrological tendency, not a medical diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of illness and recovery contains Rahu and receives Saturn and Ketu influences, indicating potentially irregular, persistent, or complicated health challenges that may require disciplined management.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/significations\",\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Jupiter occupies the 12th house in enemy dignity and is retrograde, linking health burdens with expenditure, withdrawal, sleep or institutional settings; however, its placement forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, traditionally indicating capacity to overcome adversity after difficulty.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house, relevant to chronic and transformative matters, contains Mercury and receives Jupiter and Ketu influences. This adds complexity, while Jupiter's benefic influence offers partial protection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/significations\",\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th house contains Jupiter and Ketu and is ruled by Mercury placed in the 8th, reinforcing links among health strain, recuperative isolation, expenses, and chronic or hidden matters. The listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga provides a countervailing indication of resilience through adversity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is exceptionally strong in its own sign in the 10th and forms Ruchaka Yoga, supporting drive, physical initiative, and recovery capacity, though its aspect to the lagna and Moon's house can make that energy forceful or taxing.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun, a general vitality significator, occupies the auspicious 9th house in friendly dignity without combustion, providing a modest protective factor.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Sun/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, supporting endurance, discipline, and long-term management, but its aspects to the 1st and 6th houses can also signify sustained burdens or slower recovery patterns.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No medical history, symptoms, diagnoses, lifestyle data, or treatment context is provided; astrology cannot replace clinical assessment.\",\"No specific date or health event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines substantial resilience—strong Mars, exalted Saturn, two Vipareeta Raja Yogas, and a well-placed Sun—with meaningful vulnerabilities involving a debilitated lagna lord, Rahu in the 6th, and interconnected 6th, 8th, and 12th houses. The technical balance is therefore mixed: endurance and capacity to manage adversity appear stronger than average, but health may be sensitive to stress, irregularity, overexertion, and issues requiring persistent management. These are broad Jyotish indications and not medical findings.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The lagna and its lord retain functional support: Saturn, lord of the Capricorn lagna, occupies the gain-oriented 11th house, suggesting endurance and capacity to recover through sustained routines.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"The lagna is pressured by Saturn and Ketu, while the Sun occupies the lagna in enemy dignity; this can indicate fluctuating vitality or a tendency for strain to become noticeable in the body, without specifying a disease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 6th house of illness and daily health management, is placed in the 1st house. This tightly links health outcomes with habits, workload, and self-management; Mercury is benefic and non-combust here, providing some capacity for practical adaptation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding heat, urgency, conflict, or overexertion themes to health and daily labour. Because Mars is strong in its own sign but naturally malefic, this may support resistance while also increasing stress or inflammatory symbolism.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 8th house, connecting a natural benefic with chronic, hidden, or transformative matters. Its friendly dignity is protective, but retrogression and 8th-house placement make the indication complex rather than uniformly favorable.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a benefic indicator of emotional and bodily rhythms, is in the 2nd house and receives both Mars and Jupiter aspects. Jupiter offers support, while Mars introduces agitation; the chart also marks the Moon combust, increasing the mixed quality.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Exalted Venus is a significant protective factor. For Capricorn lagna it rules both the 5th and 10th houses and is identified as a single-lordship Raja Yoga planet, although its placement in the 3rd emphasizes benefits gained through personal effort and consistent practice.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/3/because","/yogas/3/grahas"]},{"claim":"The 11th house contains strong Mars together with Saturn and debilitated Rahu. This can produce substantial persistence and goal-directed effort, but the concentration of malefics suggests that excessive ambition, social pressure, or irregular routines may tax resilience.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Jupiter placed in the 8th forms the chart's listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, symbolically supporting the ability to derive resilience from difficult or disruptive periods, though it does not cancel other health pressures or guarantee recovery.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["A D6/Shashtamsha health chart is not provided.","Quantified planetary strength measures such as Shadbala and detailed avasthas are absent.","No specific date or health event was supplied, so date-dependent dasha and transit assessment was not undertaken.","Symptoms, diagnoses, lifestyle, family history, and medical findings are outside the chart facts and are necessary for real clinical assessment."],"rationale":"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable stress signatures. Support comes from the lagna lord in the 11th, strong Mars, benefic Mercury in the lagna, exalted yogakaraka Venus, and a benefic Jupiter participating in the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Challenges arise because the lagna receives Saturn and Ketu influence, the 6th lord occupies the lagna, Mars aspects the 6th, and Jupiter occupies the 8th. These factors support a mixed conclusion: potentially durable constitution and adaptive capacity, but with sensitivity to accumulated strain, overexertion, and inconsistent routines. This is an astrological synthesis, not a medical diagnosis; actual symptoms or treatment decisions require qualified clinical evaluation."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The lagna and its lord retain functional support: Saturn, lord of the Capricorn lagna, occupies the gain-oriented 11th house, suggesting endurance and capacity to recover through sustained routines.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The lagna is pressured by Saturn and Ketu, while the Sun occupies the lagna in enemy dignity; this can indicate fluctuating vitality or a tendency for strain to become noticeable in the body, without specifying a disease.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 6th house of illness and daily health management, is placed in the 1st house. This tightly links health outcomes with habits, workload, and self-management; Mercury is benefic and non-combust here, providing some capacity for practical adaptation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding heat, urgency, conflict, or overexertion themes to health and daily labour. Because Mars is strong in its own sign but naturally malefic, this may support resistance while also increasing stress or inflammatory symbolism.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 8th house, connecting a natural benefic with chronic, hidden, or transformative matters. Its friendly dignity is protective, but retrogression and 8th-house placement make the indication complex rather than uniformly favorable.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a benefic indicator of emotional and bodily rhythms, is in the 2nd house and receives both Mars and Jupiter aspects. Jupiter offers support, while Mars introduces agitation; the chart also marks the Moon combust, increasing the mixed quality.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Venus is a significant protective factor. For Capricorn lagna it rules both the 5th and 10th houses and is identified as a single-lordship Raja Yoga planet, although its placement in the 3rd emphasizes benefits gained through personal effort and consistent practice.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/3/because\",\"/yogas/3/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th house contains strong Mars together with Saturn and debilitated Rahu. This can produce substantial persistence and goal-directed effort, but the concentration of malefics suggests that excessive ambition, social pressure, or irregular routines may tax resilience.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Jupiter placed in the 8th forms the chart's listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, symbolically supporting the ability to derive resilience from difficult or disruptive periods, though it does not cancel other health pressures or guarantee recovery.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"A D6/Shashtamsha health chart is not provided.\",\"Quantified planetary strength measures such as Shadbala and detailed avasthas are absent.\",\"No specific date or health event was supplied, so date-dependent dasha and transit assessment was not undertaken.\",\"Symptoms, diagnoses, lifestyle, family history, and medical findings are outside the chart facts and are necessary for real clinical assessment.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable stress signatures. Support comes from the lagna lord in the 11th, strong Mars, benefic Mercury in the lagna, exalted yogakaraka Venus, and a benefic Jupiter participating in the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Challenges arise because the lagna receives Saturn and Ketu influence, the 6th lord occupies the lagna, Mars aspects the 6th, and Jupiter occupies the 8th. These factors support a mixed conclusion: potentially durable constitution and adaptive capacity, but with sensitivity to accumulated strain, overexertion, and inconsistent routines. This is an astrological synthesis, not a medical diagnosis; actual symptoms or treatment decisions require qualified clinical evaluation.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Constitutional resilience is uneven because the ascendant lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio, although its placement in the auspicious 5th house and Mars's aspect provide some support.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The ascendant receives pressure from Mars and exalted Saturn, suggesting endurance and recovery capacity alongside susceptibility to strain, overexertion, or prolonged burdens; benefic Venus also aspects the ascendant and moderates this pattern.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Venus/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of disease contains Rahu and is influenced by Saturn and Ketu, indicating potentially complicated, recurring, atypical, or slow-to-resolve health themes rather than a uniformly easy health profile.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Saturn/retrograde"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Jupiter occupies the 12th house and is retrograde in an enemy sign, linking illness or daily-health burdens with expenditure, isolation, sleep, or institutional settings and weakening straightforward protection from the 6th lord.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord in the 12th is explicitly identified as a Vipareeta Raja Yoga, which can indicate an ability to overcome adversity or derive eventual improvement through managing 6th-house problems; this partly offsets the difficult placement without eliminating it.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4/name","/yogas/4/because","/yogas/4/grahas"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 8th house and receives influence from Jupiter and Ketu, emphasizing chronic, hidden, fluctuating, or investigative dimensions in health matters; as 12th lord in the 8th, Mercury also forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga that may improve coping with adversity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because"]},{"claim":"Jupiter and Ketu together in the 12th, with Rahu influencing that house, reinforce themes of withdrawal, expenditure, sleep disruption, or periods requiring seclusion and careful monitoring.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/houses/11/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"Strong Mars in its own sign in the 10th forms Ruchaka Yoga, while exalted Saturn in the 4th forms Sasa Yoga; these strong angular planets can contribute stamina, discipline, and persistence even though both also pressure health-related houses.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are unavailable.","A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 is unavailable.","No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, or clinical findings are supplied; astrology cannot diagnose a condition or replace medical assessment."],"rationale":"The chart combines substantial resilience from strong Mars and Saturn and two Vipareeta Raja Yogas with clear vulnerability from a debilitated ascendant lord, Rahu in the 6th, multiple influences on the 6th, and both the 6th and 12th lords placed in dusthanas. The best synthesis is therefore mixed: the symbolism suggests recurring or complicated burdens and a need for disciplined health management, but also meaningful endurance and capacity to navigate adversity. These are broad astrological tendencies, not a medical diagnosis or certainty about outcomes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Constitutional resilience is uneven because the ascendant lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio, although its placement in the auspicious 5th house and Mars's aspect provide some support.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant receives pressure from Mars and exalted Saturn, suggesting endurance and recovery capacity alongside susceptibility to strain, overexertion, or prolonged burdens; benefic Venus also aspects the ascendant and moderates this pattern.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of disease contains Rahu and is influenced by Saturn and Ketu, indicating potentially complicated, recurring, atypical, or slow-to-resolve health themes rather than a uniformly easy health profile.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Jupiter occupies the 12th house and is retrograde in an enemy sign, linking illness or daily-health burdens with expenditure, isolation, sleep, or institutional settings and weakening straightforward protection from the 6th lord.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord in the 12th is explicitly identified as a Vipareeta Raja Yoga, which can indicate an ability to overcome adversity or derive eventual improvement through managing 6th-house problems; this partly offsets the difficult placement without eliminating it.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4/name\",\"/yogas/4/because\",\"/yogas/4/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 8th house and receives influence from Jupiter and Ketu, emphasizing chronic, hidden, fluctuating, or investigative dimensions in health matters; as 12th lord in the 8th, Mercury also forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga that may improve coping with adversity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter and Ketu together in the 12th, with Rahu influencing that house, reinforce themes of withdrawal, expenditure, sleep disruption, or periods requiring seclusion and careful monitoring.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"Strong Mars in its own sign in the 10th forms Ruchaka Yoga, while exalted Saturn in the 4th forms Sasa Yoga; these strong angular planets can contribute stamina, discipline, and persistence even though both also pressure health-related houses.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are unavailable.\",\"A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 is unavailable.\",\"No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, or clinical findings are supplied; astrology cannot diagnose a condition or replace medical assessment.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines substantial resilience from strong Mars and Saturn and two Vipareeta Raja Yogas with clear vulnerability from a debilitated ascendant lord, Rahu in the 6th, multiple influences on the 6th, and both the 6th and 12th lords placed in dusthanas. The best synthesis is therefore mixed: the symbolism suggests recurring or complicated burdens and a need for disciplined health management, but also meaningful endurance and capacity to navigate adversity. These are broad astrological tendencies, not a medical diagnosis or certainty about outcomes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, competence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, competence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-02","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Baseline vitality has meaningful structural support because the lagna receives the influence of strong Mars, benefic Venus, and exalted Saturn; however, the simultaneous Mars–Saturn influence can indicate alternating pressure, strain, or delayed recovery rather than uniformly easy health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Venus/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio, making physical equilibrium comparatively sensitive to emotional fluctuation, stress, habits, and mental load. Its placement in the 5th is not itself a dusthana placement, which moderates the weakness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/sign","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of illness and recovery is heavily activated: Rahu occupies it, while Jupiter, Saturn, and Ketu aspect it. This can correspond astrologically to complicated, fluctuating, recurrent, or difficult-to-interpret health pressures, without identifying any specific condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/significations","/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 12th with Ketu. This connects health burdens with expenditure, isolation, sleep/rest, or institutional settings, but as a dusthana lord in another dusthana it also forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting capacity to overcome difficulties after disruption.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Ketu/house","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"The 8th house, associated with chronic or transformative matters, contains Mercury and receives Jupiter and Ketu aspects. This increases complexity around chronic patterns, while Jupiter's benefic influence provides some moderation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/significations","/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 8th lord Saturn is exalted in a kendra, giving endurance, persistence, and the ability to manage prolonged pressures, though Saturn's natural delaying quality can make improvement gradual.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/7/lord","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mars is exceptionally strong in its own sign in the 10th and forms Ruchaka Yoga. As a direct aspecting influence on the lagna, it supports drive, resilience, and recuperative effort, while also adding a tendency toward intensity or overexertion.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"The Sun, a general vitality significator, is in friendly dignity in the 9th and is neither combust nor debilitated, providing a secondary protective factor.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Sun/combust"]},{"claim":"Two listed Vipareeta Raja Yogas involving the 6th and 12th lords suggest that adversity-management and recovery potential coexist with the chart's dusthana emphasis; these yogas do not erase the underlying health sensitivities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/4","/yogas/5"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D6/Shashtamsha, which is commonly used for a more specialized health assessment, is not provided.","No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle information, or clinical data are supplied; astrology cannot diagnose a medical condition.","No specific date or health event was requested, so date-dependent dasha and transit activation has not been assessed."],"rationale":"The chart combines substantial resilience with notable vulnerability. Strong Mars, exalted Saturn, a reasonably placed Sun, and Vipareeta Raja Yogas support endurance and the ability to overcome periods of difficulty. Against this, the debilitated lagna lord and the heavily afflicted 6th house and 6th lord indicate sensitivity to stress and potentially complicated or recurring health pressures. The synthesis is therefore mixed rather than uniformly challenging: constitutional recovery capacity appears significant, but maintenance, moderation, rest, and timely professional evaluation of actual symptoms remain important."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Baseline vitality has meaningful structural support because the lagna receives the influence of strong Mars, benefic Venus, and exalted Saturn; however, the simultaneous Mars–Saturn influence can indicate alternating pressure, strain, or delayed recovery rather than uniformly easy health.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The lagna lord Moon is debilitated in Scorpio, making physical equilibrium comparatively sensitive to emotional fluctuation, stress, habits, and mental load. Its placement in the 5th is not itself a dusthana placement, which moderates the weakness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of illness and recovery is heavily activated: Rahu occupies it, while Jupiter, Saturn, and Ketu aspect it. This can correspond astrologically to complicated, fluctuating, recurrent, or difficult-to-interpret health pressures, without identifying any specific condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/significations\",\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 12th with Ketu. This connects health burdens with expenditure, isolation, sleep/rest, or institutional settings, but as a dusthana lord in another dusthana it also forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting capacity to overcome difficulties after disruption.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house, associated with chronic or transformative matters, contains Mercury and receives Jupiter and Ketu aspects. This increases complexity around chronic patterns, while Jupiter's benefic influence provides some moderation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/significations\",\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th lord Saturn is exalted in a kendra, giving endurance, persistence, and the ability to manage prolonged pressures, though Saturn's natural delaying quality can make improvement gradual.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is exceptionally strong in its own sign in the 10th and forms Ruchaka Yoga. As a direct aspecting influence on the lagna, it supports drive, resilience, and recuperative effort, while also adding a tendency toward intensity or overexertion.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun, a general vitality significator, is in friendly dignity in the 9th and is neither combust nor debilitated, providing a secondary protective factor.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Sun/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Two listed Vipareeta Raja Yogas involving the 6th and 12th lords suggest that adversity-management and recovery potential coexist with the chart's dusthana emphasis; these yogas do not erase the underlying health sensitivities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/4\",\"/yogas/5\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D6/Shashtamsha, which is commonly used for a more specialized health assessment, is not provided.\",\"No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle information, or clinical data are supplied; astrology cannot diagnose a medical condition.\",\"No specific date or health event was requested, so date-dependent dasha and transit activation has not been assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines substantial resilience with notable vulnerability. Strong Mars, exalted Saturn, a reasonably placed Sun, and Vipareeta Raja Yogas support endurance and the ability to overcome periods of difficulty. Against this, the debilitated lagna lord and the heavily afflicted 6th house and 6th lord indicate sensitivity to stress and potentially complicated or recurring health pressures. The synthesis is therefore mixed rather than uniformly challenging: constitutional recovery capacity appears significant, but maintenance, moderation, rest, and timely professional evaluation of actual symptoms remain important.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, prominence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, prominence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, prominence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse10 treats the ascendant lord placed in the tenth house as supportive of professional success, prominence, or specialization. It is not primarily a career-loss indication and does not guarantee any specific profession.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Cancer ascendant is ruled by the Moon, and the Moon occupies the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as an indication of career loss.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A applies. The computed chart places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, matching the supportive rule. Options B and C respectively reverse the rule and overstate its specificity, so D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Cancer ascendant is ruled by the Moon, and the Moon occupies the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as an indication of career loss.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A applies. The computed chart places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, matching the supportive rule. Options B and C respectively reverse the rule and overstate its specificity, so D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant is Cancer, so its lord is the Moon; the Moon is placed in the tenth house. Under the stated career rule, this supports professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support professional development or specialization, but it does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A applies. The computed chart directly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, matching the supportive rule. Options B and C respectively reverse the rule and overstate its specificity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant is Cancer, so its lord is the Moon; the Moon is placed in the tenth house. Under the stated career rule, this supports professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support professional development or specialization, but it does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A applies. The computed chart directly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, matching the supportive rule. Options B and C respectively reverse the rule and overstate its specificity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Cancer ascendant makes the Moon the ascendant lord, and the Moon is placed in the tenth house; under the stated rule this supports professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive rather than primarily indicating career loss.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee a specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon occupies the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly identifies the Moon as lord of the Cancer ascendant and places it in house 10. Therefore A is applicable. B reverses the stated polarity, C claims unjustified certainty and specificity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Cancer ascendant makes the Moon the ascendant lord, and the Moon is placed in the tenth house; under the stated rule this supports professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive rather than primarily indicating career loss.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee a specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon occupies the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly identifies the Moon as lord of the Cancer ascendant and places it in house 10. Therefore A is applicable. B reverses the stated polarity, C claims unjustified certainty and specificity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant receives pressure from Saturn and Rahu, indicating potential fluctuations or strain affecting general vitality, without identifying a specific condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house with enemy dignity, giving initiative and resilience but not an unambiguously strong constitutional foundation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Benefic Venus occupies the 1st house, providing a supportive influence on the body and general well-being.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury is in its own sign, suggesting capacity to manage disease, obstacles, and daily health routines, although its conjunction by house with Mars and Ketu complicates that support.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding conflict or inflammatory symbolism to health matters while also supplying capacity to confront them.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter aspects the 8th and 12th houses, offering a protective or moderating influence over chronic adversity and hospitalization or loss-related themes.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"The chart contains Hamsa Yoga from exalted Jupiter in a kendra, which supports overall resilience but does not negate afflictions to the ascendant.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific symptom, health event, or date is supplied, so timing cannot be assessed.","A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 is not represented in the supplied facts.","The supplied evidence does not support diagnosis of any medical condition or assessment of clinical severity."],"rationale":"The natal evidence is balanced rather than decisive. Venus in the ascendant and exalted Jupiter's protective aspects support resilience, while Saturn and Rahu influencing the ascendant and Mars influencing the 6th introduce strain. Mercury's own-sign strength as 6th lord supports management of difficulties, but its association with Mars and Ketu prevents a wholly supportive judgment. The appropriate synthesis is mixed and limited to broad constitutional indications, not medical diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.72,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant receives pressure from Saturn and Rahu, indicating potential fluctuations or strain affecting general vitality, without identifying a specific condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house with enemy dignity, giving initiative and resilience but not an unambiguously strong constitutional foundation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Benefic Venus occupies the 1st house, providing a supportive influence on the body and general well-being.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury is in its own sign, suggesting capacity to manage disease, obstacles, and daily health routines, although its conjunction by house with Mars and Ketu complicates that support.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding conflict or inflammatory symbolism to health matters while also supplying capacity to confront them.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter aspects the 8th and 12th houses, offering a protective or moderating influence over chronic adversity and hospitalization or loss-related themes.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart contains Hamsa Yoga from exalted Jupiter in a kendra, which supports overall resilience but does not negate afflictions to the ascendant.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific symptom, health event, or date is supplied, so timing cannot be assessed.\",\"A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 is not represented in the supplied facts.\",\"The supplied evidence does not support diagnosis of any medical condition or assessment of clinical severity.\"],\"rationale\":\"The natal evidence is balanced rather than decisive. Venus in the ascendant and exalted Jupiter's protective aspects support resilience, while Saturn and Rahu influencing the ascendant and Mars influencing the 6th introduce strain. Mercury's own-sign strength as 6th lord supports management of difficulties, but its association with Mars and Ketu prevents a wholly supportive judgment. The appropriate synthesis is mixed and limited to broad constitutional indications, not medical diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.72,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Venus, a natural benefic, occupies the 1st house, providing some support to constitution and recovery capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Mars is in the 3rd house in enemy dignity, suggesting that vitality may depend on sustained effort rather than operating without strain.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn aspects the 1st house. Its strength can support endurance and discipline, while its natural malefic influence may also correspond to pressure or heaviness affecting vitality.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/isBenefic","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury is strong in its own sign but is joined by Mars and Ketu. This combines capacity to manage obstacles with potentially disruptive influences around 6th-house health significations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding a challenging influence to matters represented by disease and daily health maintenance.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"The Moon is benefic, in friendly dignity, and placed in the 5th house, offering some support for emotional resilience and general well-being.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter forms Hamsa Yoga from the 4th house, indicating a strong benefic foundation relevant to inner stability, though this does not by itself establish medical outcomes.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/0"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific symptom, diagnosis, health event, or date was supplied, so condition-specific or time-dependent assessment is unsupported.","No dedicated medical divisional chart or additional health-strength metrics are represented in the supplied facts.","Astrological placements cannot establish a medical diagnosis or replace clinical evaluation."],"rationale":"The chart contains both resilience and strain indicators. Benefic Venus in the ascendant, a well-placed Moon, and exalted Jupiter support constitution and recuperative potential. Against this, the ascendant lord has weak dignity, Saturn aspects the ascendant, and Mars influences the 6th house while conjoining its lord Mercury with Ketu. The supported doctrine therefore favors a mixed assessment rather than a definite claim of either robust or poor health; no particular illness can responsibly be inferred."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.72,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Venus, a natural benefic, occupies the 1st house, providing some support to constitution and recovery capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Mars is in the 3rd house in enemy dignity, suggesting that vitality may depend on sustained effort rather than operating without strain.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn aspects the 1st house. Its strength can support endurance and discipline, while its natural malefic influence may also correspond to pressure or heaviness affecting vitality.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/isBenefic\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury is strong in its own sign but is joined by Mars and Ketu. This combines capacity to manage obstacles with potentially disruptive influences around 6th-house health significations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding a challenging influence to matters represented by disease and daily health maintenance.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is benefic, in friendly dignity, and placed in the 5th house, offering some support for emotional resilience and general well-being.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter forms Hamsa Yoga from the 4th house, indicating a strong benefic foundation relevant to inner stability, though this does not by itself establish medical outcomes.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific symptom, diagnosis, health event, or date was supplied, so condition-specific or time-dependent assessment is unsupported.\",\"No dedicated medical divisional chart or additional health-strength metrics are represented in the supplied facts.\",\"Astrological placements cannot establish a medical diagnosis or replace clinical evaluation.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart contains both resilience and strain indicators. Benefic Venus in the ascendant, a well-placed Moon, and exalted Jupiter support constitution and recuperative potential. Against this, the ascendant lord has weak dignity, Saturn aspects the ascendant, and Mars influences the 6th house while conjoining its lord Mercury with Ketu. The supported doctrine therefore favors a mixed assessment rather than a definite claim of either robust or poor health; no particular illness can responsibly be inferred.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be supportive, but it does not guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated placement is not necessarily an indication of dependent career; the applicable rule instead associates it with personal effort and independent advancement.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the tenth lord in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart states that the tenth-house lord is Mars and that it is placed in house 1. This directly satisfies statement A. Statements B and C add unsupported absolutes, while D is false because A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be supportive, but it does not guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated placement is not necessarily an indication of dependent career; the applicable rule instead associates it with personal effort and independent advancement.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the tenth lord in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart states that the tenth-house lord is Mars and that it is placed in house 1. This directly satisfies statement A. Statements B and C add unsupported absolutes, while D is false because A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-03","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.76,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Vitality has some strain because the ascendant is occupied by Venus but also receives aspects from Saturn and Rahu, producing mixed influences on the body and general resilience.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/houses/0/occupants/0","/houses/0/aspectedBy/0","/houses/0/aspectedBy/1","/reference/houseSignifications/1"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Mars is in the 3rd house in enemy dignity, so constitutional support from the lagna lord is not uniformly strong, although its placement in a house of initiative can favor active coping.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of disease and daily health challenges is unoccupied, but it receives Mars's aspect; this can indicate periods of inflammatory, stressful, or conflict-like health pressure in general Jyotish terms, without identifying a medical condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy/0","/placements/Mars/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury is strong by sign because it occupies its own sign, which can support the capacity to manage obstacles and health routines.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/sign","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury, as 6th lord, is closely joined in the 3rd house by Mars and Ketu, adding volatility to the otherwise strong 6th lord and making the indication mixed rather than clearly protective.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"The 8th house, associated with chronic matters and vulnerability to disruptions, is unoccupied and receives Jupiter's benefic aspect as well as the Sun's aspect; exalted Jupiter supplies a meaningful protective influence.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Jupiter","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter in a kendra forms the listed Hamsa Yoga, providing broad supportive potential for resilience and recovery, though it cannot by itself establish freedom from illness.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"Exalted retrograde Saturn in the 7th aspects the ascendant and 4th house. Its strength may support endurance, while its malefic influence can correlate with sustained burdens or slower restoration, so its health contribution is mixed.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Saturn","/houses/0/aspectedBy/0"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No medical history, symptoms, diagnosis, treatment context, or specific health question is supplied.","No date or life period is specified, so date-dependent dasha and transit activation cannot be assessed.","The supplied facts do not include specialized medical divisional charts, quantified planetary strengths, or other health-specific calculations; therefore no organ-specific or disease-specific conclusion is supported."],"rationale":"The chart presents both protection and pressure. Strong factors include the 6th lord Mercury in its own sign and exalted Jupiter aspecting the 8th house. Countervailing factors include Saturn and Rahu influencing the ascendant, the ascendant lord Mars being in enemy dignity, Mars aspecting the 6th, and the 6th lord sharing a house with Mars and Ketu. These support a mixed assessment of constitutional resilience and potential health stress, but the represented doctrine and available evidence are insufficient for diagnosis, severity estimates, or a time-specific forecast."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.76,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Vitality has some strain because the ascendant is occupied by Venus but also receives aspects from Saturn and Rahu, producing mixed influences on the body and general resilience.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/houses/0/occupants/0\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy/0\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy/1\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Mars is in the 3rd house in enemy dignity, so constitutional support from the lagna lord is not uniformly strong, although its placement in a house of initiative can favor active coping.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of disease and daily health challenges is unoccupied, but it receives Mars's aspect; this can indicate periods of inflammatory, stressful, or conflict-like health pressure in general Jyotish terms, without identifying a medical condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy/0\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury is strong by sign because it occupies its own sign, which can support the capacity to manage obstacles and health routines.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/sign\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, as 6th lord, is closely joined in the 3rd house by Mars and Ketu, adding volatility to the otherwise strong 6th lord and making the indication mixed rather than clearly protective.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house, associated with chronic matters and vulnerability to disruptions, is unoccupied and receives Jupiter's benefic aspect as well as the Sun's aspect; exalted Jupiter supplies a meaningful protective influence.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter in a kendra forms the listed Hamsa Yoga, providing broad supportive potential for resilience and recovery, though it cannot by itself establish freedom from illness.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted retrograde Saturn in the 7th aspects the ascendant and 4th house. Its strength may support endurance, while its malefic influence can correlate with sustained burdens or slower restoration, so its health contribution is mixed.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy/0\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No medical history, symptoms, diagnosis, treatment context, or specific health question is supplied.\",\"No date or life period is specified, so date-dependent dasha and transit activation cannot be assessed.\",\"The supplied facts do not include specialized medical divisional charts, quantified planetary strengths, or other health-specific calculations; therefore no organ-specific or disease-specific conclusion is supported.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart presents both protection and pressure. Strong factors include the 6th lord Mercury in its own sign and exalted Jupiter aspecting the 8th house. Countervailing factors include Saturn and Rahu influencing the ascendant, the ascendant lord Mars being in enemy dignity, Mars aspecting the 6th, and the 6th lord sharing a house with Mars and Ketu. These support a mixed assessment of constitutional resilience and potential health stress, but the represented doctrine and available evidence are insufficient for diagnosis, severity estimates, or a time-specific forecast.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be professionally supportive but does not guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated placement is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; the applicable rule treats it as supportive of advancement through personal effort.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the tenth lord in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart states that the tenth-house lord is Mars and that it is placed in house 1. Therefore A applies. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, C asserts the opposite necessity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house, supporting independent professional advancement through personal effort under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be professionally supportive but does not guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated placement is not necessarily a dependent-career indication; the applicable rule treats it as supportive of advancement through personal effort.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the tenth lord in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart states that the tenth-house lord is Mars and that it is placed in house 1. Therefore A applies. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, C asserts the opposite necessity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The natal Sun occupies the tenth house, so the stated rule supports professional success, visibility, and authority.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A tenth-house Sun may support authority and visibility but does not guarantee government employment.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily indicative of loss of status.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Sun is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The Sun is in house 10, whose stated significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports career visibility and authority but cannot guarantee a specific employment sector."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The natal Sun occupies the tenth house, so the stated rule supports professional success, visibility, and authority.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A tenth-house Sun may support authority and visibility but does not guarantee government employment.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily indicative of loss of status.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Sun is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The Sun is in house 10, whose stated significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports career visibility and authority but cannot guarantee a specific employment sector.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house; under the stated rule this supports independent professional advancement through personal effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be professionally supportive but does not guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated placement is treated as supportive of personal initiative, not as necessarily indicating a dependent career.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart because the tenth lord is explicitly placed in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly gives Mars as the tenth-house lord and places that lord in the first house. This directly satisfies statement A. Statements B and C add unsupported certainty or reverse the stated interpretation, so the polarity of the applicable listed statement is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The tenth lord, Mars, is placed in the first house; under the stated rule this supports independent professional advancement through personal effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the tenth lord in the first may be professionally supportive but does not guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated placement is treated as supportive of personal initiative, not as necessarily indicating a dependent career.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart because the tenth lord is explicitly placed in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly gives Mars as the tenth-house lord and places that lord in the first house. This directly satisfies statement A. Statements B and C add unsupported certainty or reverse the stated interpretation, so the polarity of the applicable listed statement is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Sun occupies the tenth house, supporting professional visibility, authority, and success under the stated career rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the tenth may support authority and professional prominence, but it does not guarantee government employment.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily an indication of status loss.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart places the Sun in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The computed chart explicitly places the Sun in house 10, whose significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports the stated rule but cannot guarantee a specific employment sector."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the tenth house, supporting professional visibility, authority, and success under the stated career rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the tenth may support authority and professional prominence, but it does not guarantee government employment.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily an indication of status loss.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart places the Sun in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The computed chart explicitly places the Sun in house 10, whose significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports the stated rule but cannot guarantee a specific employment sector.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Sun occupies the tenth house, supporting professional visibility, authority, and success under the stated career rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The Sun in the tenth may support authority and visibility but does not guarantee government employment.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily indicating loss of status.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Sun is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The computed chart places the Sun in house 10, whose stated significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports the listed positive rule but neither guarantees a specific employment sector nor primarily signifies status loss."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the tenth house, supporting professional visibility, authority, and success under the stated career rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The Sun in the tenth may support authority and visibility but does not guarantee government employment.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the Sun in the tenth is supportive rather than primarily indicating loss of status.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Sun is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The computed chart places the Sun in house 10, whose stated significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. This supports the listed positive rule but neither guarantees a specific employment sector nor primarily signifies status loss.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury occupies the tenth house, so the stated rule supports knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mercury in the tenth may be supportive, but it does not guarantee success in every undertaking.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, Mercury in the tenth is supportive rather than necessarily obstructive.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Mercury is explicitly placed in house 10, the house of career, status, public action, authority, and standing. This establishes A under the supplied rule. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-04\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the tenth house, so the stated rule supports knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mercury in the tenth may be supportive, but it does not guarantee success in every undertaking.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, Mercury in the tenth is supportive rather than necessarily obstructive.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Mercury is explicitly placed in house 10, the house of career, status, public action, authority, and standing. This establishes A under the supplied rule. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into a certainty and specifies a government post without sufficient evidence. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into a certainty and specifies a government post without sufficient evidence. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, or principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, or principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the tenth may support professional standing, responsibility, and principled authority, but it does not guarantee a government post.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a reasonable interpretive statement and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into an unjustified certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury occupies the tenth house and is treated by the stated rule as supportive of knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mercury in the tenth may support professional success but does not guarantee success in every undertaking.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, Mercury in the tenth is supportive rather than necessarily career-obstructive.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Mercury is placed in house 10, so A directly applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-04\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the tenth house and is treated by the stated rule as supportive of knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mercury in the tenth may support professional success but does not guarantee success in every undertaking.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, Mercury in the tenth is supportive rather than necessarily career-obstructive.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Mercury is placed in house 10, so A directly applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-04","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury occupies the tenth house and is therefore supportive, under the stated rule, of knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mercury in the tenth may support professional success but does not guarantee success in every undertaking.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats Mercury in the tenth as supportive rather than necessarily obstructive.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Mercury is placed in house 10 and has friendly dignity. Thus A applies. B converts a supportive indication into an unjustified guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; consequently D is false."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-04\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the tenth house and is therefore supportive, under the stated rule, of knowledge-oriented work, professional reputation, and career success.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mercury in the tenth may support professional success but does not guarantee success in every undertaking.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats Mercury in the tenth as supportive rather than necessarily obstructive.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mercury is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Mercury is placed in house 10 and has friendly dignity. Thus A applies. B converts a supportive indication into an unjustified guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; consequently D is false.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the tenth can indicate sustained responsibility, discipline, delay, pressure, or status developed through effort; it does not establish uninterrupted career success.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a permissible mixed interpretation rather than an error. S2 makes an absolute promise unsupported by Saturn's placement, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded tenth-house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the tenth can indicate sustained responsibility, discipline, delay, pressure, or status developed through effort; it does not establish uninterrupted career success.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a permissible mixed interpretation rather than an error. S2 makes an absolute promise unsupported by Saturn's placement, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded tenth-house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the tenth house, while Mars aspects the tenth, supporting a mixed rather than uniformly smooth career interpretation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the tenth can indicate sustained responsibility, discipline, delayed advancement, or status through effort, but it does not imply uninterrupted career success; Mars also aspects the tenth, adding potential pressure or volatility.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is not erroneous because it presents Saturn in the tenth as a mixed indication rather than guaranteeing a result. S2 improperly converts that placement into certainty and ignores the possibility of obstacles or fluctuations. S3 directly contradicts Saturn's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the tenth house, while Mars aspects the tenth, supporting a mixed rather than uniformly smooth career interpretation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the tenth can indicate sustained responsibility, discipline, delayed advancement, or status through effort, but it does not imply uninterrupted career success; Mars also aspects the tenth, adding potential pressure or volatility.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is not erroneous because it presents Saturn in the tenth as a mixed indication rather than guaranteeing a result. S2 improperly converts that placement into certainty and ignores the possibility of obstacles or fluctuations. S3 directly contradicts Saturn's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-contradiction-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the tenth can indicate responsibility, endurance, delay, pressure, or eventual status, but it does not guarantee uninterrupted career success. Here the tenth house is also aspected by Mars, reinforcing a mixed rather than uniformly smooth indication.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S2 converts a potentially constructive but demanding tenth-house Saturn placement into a certainty of uninterrupted success, which is an unjustified guarantee. S3 directly contradicts Saturn's recorded house placement. S1 is not flagged because it appropriately characterizes the career indication as mixed rather than certain."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the tenth can indicate responsibility, endurance, delay, pressure, or eventual status, but it does not guarantee uninterrupted career success. Here the tenth house is also aspected by Mars, reinforcing a mixed rather than uniformly smooth indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Saturn occupies house 10, not house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S2 converts a potentially constructive but demanding tenth-house Saturn placement into a certainty of uninterrupted success, which is an unjustified guarantee. S3 directly contradicts Saturn's recorded house placement. S1 is not flagged because it appropriately characterizes the career indication as mixed rather than certain.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly linking identity, life direction, knowledge and guidance with career and public standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter also rules the 4th and 1st houses and is explicitly identified as producing a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting responsibility, visibility and advancement through constructive action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in enemy dignity, indicating that professional confidence, recognition or direction may develop through revision, delayed consolidation or an unconventional path rather than effortlessly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury occupies the 2nd house, directly connecting career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce or advisory abilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening communication, diplomacy, presentation, negotiation and value-oriented commercial skills.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus is also in the 2nd house, forming a strong income–gains–accumulation connection; professional networks and marketable interpersonal skills can translate into resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/1/significations","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting enterprise, technical or strategic intelligence, initiative and an ability to pursue gains competitively.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/houses/4/significations","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Sun in the 3rd house favors self-directed effort, communication and initiative, although enemy dignity can create friction with authority, recognition or confidence.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th can produce substantial professional expenditure, institutional pressure, isolation or foreign/behind-the-scenes work; Saturn's enemy dignity and Rahu's debility make this a significant source of strain.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Saturn occupying the 12th complicates wealth retention: earning combinations are strong, but savings may be reduced by obligations, foreign links, institutions or recurring expenditure.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, suggesting periodic detachment from titles, dissatisfaction with conventional success or abrupt professional redirection.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/9/aspectedBy","/placements/Ketu/dignity"]},{"claim":"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing career gains through intellect, communication, planning, trade and networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, supporting competence in service, problem-solving, administration, counsel or regulated environments, while emphasizing workload, competition and responsibility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn occupies Capricorn in the 12th, showing endurance and organizational capacity in large institutions, foreign settings or secluded operations, but also possible delay, isolation and heavy obligations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"D10 Sun, Moon and Venus cluster in the 2nd house, emphasizing livelihood through knowledge, speech, client relations, aesthetics, support functions or stewardship of resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/2/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/2/house","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No career history, occupation, education or milestones were supplied for validation.","No specific date or forecasting window was requested; therefore, time-dependent dasha and transit predictions are excluded."],"rationale":"The dominant pattern is favorable: the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects career to the 2nd house of earnings and speech, the 11th lord reinforces accumulation, and D10 Mercury supports gains through intellectual and commercial networks. This favors advisory, analytical, educational, financial, administrative, communication-oriented or institutional work. The result is not effortless: Jupiter's natal condition, Ketu's influence on the 10th, the 2nd lord in the 12th, and the Saturn–Rahu emphasis can bring revisions, delayed recognition, organizational pressure and uneven wealth retention. Overall, the chart supports meaningful professional capacity and eventual standing, especially where expertise, communication and structured service are central, but requires disciplined expense management and tolerance for nonlinear career development."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly linking identity, life direction, knowledge and guidance with career and public standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter also rules the 4th and 1st houses and is explicitly identified as producing a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting responsibility, visibility and advancement through constructive action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in enemy dignity, indicating that professional confidence, recognition or direction may develop through revision, delayed consolidation or an unconventional path rather than effortlessly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury occupies the 2nd house, directly connecting career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce or advisory abilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening communication, diplomacy, presentation, negotiation and value-oriented commercial skills.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus is also in the 2nd house, forming a strong income–gains–accumulation connection; professional networks and marketable interpersonal skills can translate into resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting enterprise, technical or strategic intelligence, initiative and an ability to pursue gains competitively.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/4/significations\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 3rd house favors self-directed effort, communication and initiative, although enemy dignity can create friction with authority, recognition or confidence.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th can produce substantial professional expenditure, institutional pressure, isolation or foreign/behind-the-scenes work; Saturn's enemy dignity and Rahu's debility make this a significant source of strain.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Saturn occupying the 12th complicates wealth retention: earning combinations are strong, but savings may be reduced by obligations, foreign links, institutions or recurring expenditure.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, suggesting periodic detachment from titles, dissatisfaction with conventional success or abrupt professional redirection.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing career gains through intellect, communication, planning, trade and networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, supporting competence in service, problem-solving, administration, counsel or regulated environments, while emphasizing workload, competition and responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn occupies Capricorn in the 12th, showing endurance and organizational capacity in large institutions, foreign settings or secluded operations, but also possible delay, isolation and heavy obligations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Sun, Moon and Venus cluster in the 2nd house, emphasizing livelihood through knowledge, speech, client relations, aesthetics, support functions or stewardship of resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No career history, occupation, education or milestones were supplied for validation.\",\"No specific date or forecasting window was requested; therefore, time-dependent dasha and transit predictions are excluded.\"],\"rationale\":\"The dominant pattern is favorable: the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects career to the 2nd house of earnings and speech, the 11th lord reinforces accumulation, and D10 Mercury supports gains through intellectual and commercial networks. This favors advisory, analytical, educational, financial, administrative, communication-oriented or institutional work. The result is not effortless: Jupiter's natal condition, Ketu's influence on the 10th, the 2nd lord in the 12th, and the Saturn–Rahu emphasis can bring revisions, delayed recognition, organizational pressure and uneven wealth retention. Overall, the chart supports meaningful professional capacity and eventual standing, especially where expertise, communication and structured service are central, but requires disciplined expense management and tolerance for nonlinear career development.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house with Venus, linking profession and public activity with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, advising, or other knowledge-based work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 10th house and is also the ascendant and 4th lord; this supports responsibility, guidance, education, consulting, administration, and a generally meaningful or respected professional role.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign in D1, so its career promise may emerge through revision, nonlinear development, or imperfect institutional fit rather than effortless recognition.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/sign"]},{"claim":"Mercury, the 10th lord, is in neutral dignity and receives Jupiter's aspect in the 2nd house, strengthening the connection between expertise, communication, earnings, and professional judgment.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/1/occupants","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house containing Mercury and Venus is also aspected by Saturn and Ketu; income and professional speech may therefore combine refinement and intellect with restraint, discontinuity, austerity, or periodic financial pressure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Mars is strong in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th house, supporting initiative, technical or strategic intelligence, leadership in projects, competitiveness, and gains generated through personal capability.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The Sun in the 3rd house emphasizes self-directed effort, communication, skills, enterprise, and persistence, although enemy-sign dignity can complicate relations with authority or confidence in formal hierarchies.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/sign","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th house, indicating potential career involvement with large institutions, foreign environments, remote or behind-the-scenes work, while also increasing exposure to isolation, bureaucracy, expenditure, or delayed rewards.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"In D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, directly supporting professional gains, networks, and fulfillment through Mercurial abilities such as analysis, negotiation, writing, management, or commerce.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, combining strong Jupiterian capacity with service, problem-solving, competition, and institutional responsibilities; advancement is supported but tends to require sustained engagement with demanding work.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Sun, Moon, and Venus cluster in Pisces in the 2nd house, reinforcing livelihood through communication, values, counsel, interpersonal skill, creativity, or stewardship of resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/1","/vargas/D10/placements/4","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th house in Capricorn; Saturn's own sign gives endurance and organizational capacity, but the 12th-house emphasis can bring heavy institutional duties, low-visibility labor, foreign connections, detachment from titles, or periodic withdrawal from conventional career structures.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/placements/8","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"D10 Mars in the 9th house favors initiative connected with higher knowledge, strategy, travel, policy, mentoring, or principled leadership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2/house","/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign","/reference/houseSignifications/9"]},{"claim":"The chart's Raja Yoga designation for Jupiter reinforces the career relevance of Jupiter's 10th-house placement, joining personal direction, foundational security, and public action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Shadbala and other quantified planetary-strength measures are not supplied.","D10 house lords, aspects, conjunction rules, and dignity labels are not explicitly supplied, limiting finer vocational ranking.","No specific career history, industry, role, or dated question was provided for event-level validation."],"rationale":"The main career structure is favorable: the ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th, the 10th lord Mercury connects career with the income-producing 2nd house, and D10 Mercury occupies the gains-oriented 11th. Strong Mars adds initiative and gain-producing skill. The principal counterweight is the repeated 12th-house Saturn–Ketu/Rahu theme, together with Jupiter's weaker D1 dignity, suggesting delays, institutional burdens, foreign or behind-the-scenes settings, and periods when effort exceeds visible recognition. Overall, the chart supports a substantial knowledge-, communication-, advisory-, administrative-, commercial-, or institution-centered career, with progress most likely through expertise and persistence rather than a uniformly smooth trajectory."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house with Venus, linking profession and public activity with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, advising, or other knowledge-based work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 10th house and is also the ascendant and 4th lord; this supports responsibility, guidance, education, consulting, administration, and a generally meaningful or respected professional role.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in an enemy sign in D1, so its career promise may emerge through revision, nonlinear development, or imperfect institutional fit rather than effortless recognition.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, the 10th lord, is in neutral dignity and receives Jupiter's aspect in the 2nd house, strengthening the connection between expertise, communication, earnings, and professional judgment.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house containing Mercury and Venus is also aspected by Saturn and Ketu; income and professional speech may therefore combine refinement and intellect with restraint, discontinuity, austerity, or periodic financial pressure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is strong in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th house, supporting initiative, technical or strategic intelligence, leadership in projects, competitiveness, and gains generated through personal capability.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun in the 3rd house emphasizes self-directed effort, communication, skills, enterprise, and persistence, although enemy-sign dignity can complicate relations with authority or confidence in formal hierarchies.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/sign\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th house, indicating potential career involvement with large institutions, foreign environments, remote or behind-the-scenes work, while also increasing exposure to isolation, bureaucracy, expenditure, or delayed rewards.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, directly supporting professional gains, networks, and fulfillment through Mercurial abilities such as analysis, negotiation, writing, management, or commerce.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, combining strong Jupiterian capacity with service, problem-solving, competition, and institutional responsibilities; advancement is supported but tends to require sustained engagement with demanding work.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Sun, Moon, and Venus cluster in Pisces in the 2nd house, reinforcing livelihood through communication, values, counsel, interpersonal skill, creativity, or stewardship of resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn and Ketu occupy the 12th house in Capricorn; Saturn's own sign gives endurance and organizational capacity, but the 12th-house emphasis can bring heavy institutional duties, low-visibility labor, foreign connections, detachment from titles, or periodic withdrawal from conventional career structures.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mars in the 9th house favors initiative connected with higher knowledge, strategy, travel, policy, mentoring, or principled leadership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/9\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart's Raja Yoga designation for Jupiter reinforces the career relevance of Jupiter's 10th-house placement, joining personal direction, foundational security, and public action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and other quantified planetary-strength measures are not supplied.\",\"D10 house lords, aspects, conjunction rules, and dignity labels are not explicitly supplied, limiting finer vocational ranking.\",\"No specific career history, industry, role, or dated question was provided for event-level validation.\"],\"rationale\":\"The main career structure is favorable: the ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th, the 10th lord Mercury connects career with the income-producing 2nd house, and D10 Mercury occupies the gains-oriented 11th. Strong Mars adds initiative and gain-producing skill. The principal counterweight is the repeated 12th-house Saturn–Ketu/Rahu theme, together with Jupiter's weaker D1 dignity, suggesting delays, institutional burdens, foreign or behind-the-scenes settings, and periods when effort exceeds visible recognition. Overall, the chart supports a substantial knowledge-, communication-, advisory-, administrative-, commercial-, or institution-centered career, with progress most likely through expertise and persistence rather than a uniformly smooth trajectory.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly linking identity and life direction with vocation, responsibility, and public contribution.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 10th supports advisory, educational, managerial, institutional, ethical, or knowledge-based work, though its enemy-sign dignity and retrogression suggest a nonlinear path, periodic reassessment, or recognition earned through experience rather than ease.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's combined rulership of the 1st and 4th is explicitly identified as a Raja Yoga, adding potential for responsibility, standing, and constructive influence when Jupiter is activated.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, finance, consulting, teaching, or other knowledge-and-communication functions.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with Venus, the 11th lord, creating a practical link between profession, earnings, networks, and client-facing or refined communication skills.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Venus also rules the 6th house, so the career-income combination can involve service, problem-solving, competition, administration, or demanding client and workplace obligations rather than effortless gains.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, technical or strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, and active pursuit of gains; it can also produce forceful risk-taking or friction around objectives.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from titles, unusual professional turns, specialization, or intermittent dissatisfaction even where competence and status are present.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The D10 confirms earning and communication themes: Mercury occupies the 11th house, while Sun, Moon, and Venus occupy the 2nd house, supporting gains through knowledge, communication, relationships, visibility, or value-producing work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, combining strong Jupiterian capacity with service, institutional duties, competition, and problem-solving; advancement is therefore more likely through competence and useful contribution than through an unopposed rise.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn occupies its own sign Capricorn in the 12th house, favoring endurance in large institutions, foreign or remote settings, research, back-office work, or roles requiring solitude and sustained discipline, while also indicating heavy responsibilities, delayed rewards, or periodic withdrawal from public visibility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor"]},{"claim":"Rahu in the D10 6th can intensify ambition and competitive problem-solving, but may also produce unconventional workplace dynamics or recurring disputes that require careful boundaries.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/7/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/sign"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact career history, occupation, and major professional event dates are absent, so the indicated fields and patterns cannot be validated against lived outcomes.","Planetary strength metrics such as shadbala and D10 aspects are not provided; conclusions about relative strength therefore remain qualitative.","No specific forecast period was requested, so the synthesis does not time career events."],"rationale":"The chart is broadly supportive for a substantial career because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects profession to the wealth house, and the 11th lord joins the 10th lord. D10 reinforces communication, income, service, institutional work, and gains. The main conflict is between strong vocational capacity and more demanding delivery conditions: natal Jupiter is retrograde in enemy dignity, Ketu influences the 10th, and D10 Jupiter, Rahu, and Saturn emphasize the 6th and 12th houses. The most coherent synthesis is career growth through analytical, advisory, educational, financial, administrative, technical, client-facing, or institutional work, with recognition developing through persistence, specialization, and service rather than a uniformly smooth trajectory."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly linking identity and life direction with vocation, responsibility, and public contribution.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 10th supports advisory, educational, managerial, institutional, ethical, or knowledge-based work, though its enemy-sign dignity and retrogression suggest a nonlinear path, periodic reassessment, or recognition earned through experience rather than ease.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's combined rulership of the 1st and 4th is explicitly identified as a Raja Yoga, adding potential for responsibility, standing, and constructive influence when Jupiter is activated.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, finance, consulting, teaching, or other knowledge-and-communication functions.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with Venus, the 11th lord, creating a practical link between profession, earnings, networks, and client-facing or refined communication skills.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus also rules the 6th house, so the career-income combination can involve service, problem-solving, competition, administration, or demanding client and workplace obligations rather than effortless gains.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, technical or strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, and active pursuit of gains; it can also produce forceful risk-taking or friction around objectives.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from titles, unusual professional turns, specialization, or intermittent dissatisfaction even where competence and status are present.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 confirms earning and communication themes: Mercury occupies the 11th house, while Sun, Moon, and Venus occupy the 2nd house, supporting gains through knowledge, communication, relationships, visibility, or value-producing work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer in the 6th house, combining strong Jupiterian capacity with service, institutional duties, competition, and problem-solving; advancement is therefore more likely through competence and useful contribution than through an unopposed rise.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn occupies its own sign Capricorn in the 12th house, favoring endurance in large institutions, foreign or remote settings, research, back-office work, or roles requiring solitude and sustained discipline, while also indicating heavy responsibilities, delayed rewards, or periodic withdrawal from public visibility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu in the D10 6th can intensify ambition and competitive problem-solving, but may also produce unconventional workplace dynamics or recurring disputes that require careful boundaries.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/sign\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact career history, occupation, and major professional event dates are absent, so the indicated fields and patterns cannot be validated against lived outcomes.\",\"Planetary strength metrics such as shadbala and D10 aspects are not provided; conclusions about relative strength therefore remain qualitative.\",\"No specific forecast period was requested, so the synthesis does not time career events.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is broadly supportive for a substantial career because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects profession to the wealth house, and the 11th lord joins the 10th lord. D10 reinforces communication, income, service, institutional work, and gains. The main conflict is between strong vocational capacity and more demanding delivery conditions: natal Jupiter is retrograde in enemy dignity, Ketu influences the 10th, and D10 Jupiter, Rahu, and Saturn emphasize the 6th and 12th houses. The most coherent synthesis is career growth through analytical, advisory, educational, financial, administrative, technical, client-facing, or institutional work, with recognition developing through persistence, specialization, and service rather than a uniformly smooth trajectory.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The primary career signature is exceptionally strong: lagna lord Saturn occupies the 10th house in exaltation, forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This supports sustained responsibility, administration, institutional authority, discipline, and status earned over time.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Venus is also the 5th lord, creating yogakaraka/Raja Yoga potential for achievement through skill, judgment, creativity, education, or strategy.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/9/lord","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Venus, however, is placed in the 12th house with Rahu. Career may therefore involve foreign environments, large institutions, behind-the-scenes work, research, seclusion, or substantial expenditure; it can also produce unconventional ambitions and periodic dissatisfaction or redirection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/occupants"]},{"claim":"The Dashamsa reinforces professional visibility because Venus occupies the D10 10th house. This substantially offsets the D1 10th lord's placement in the 12th and suggests that Venusian capacities can manifest directly through vocation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter occupies Pisces in the 11th house alongside Mercury and Rahu, supporting gains through knowledge, advisory activity, networks, communication, and broad or nontraditional professional circles, although Rahu can make gains uneven or highly ambitious.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]},{"claim":"Natal Jupiter occupies the 6th and aspects the 10th. This connects career with service, problem-solving, competition, disputes, or demanding daily work; its retrograde condition and enemy-sign dignity indicate that growth may require repeated adjustment rather than arriving effortlessly.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/aspects/Jupiter"]},{"claim":"The 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter, and Ketu. Jupiter offers guidance, while Mars adds drive and technical initiative; Mars and Ketu can also produce conflict with authority, abrupt professional changes, or impatience with routine structures.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Mars in the 3rd supports initiative, courage, communication, technical skill, and self-directed effort, and its aspect to the 10th makes personal enterprise important to career development.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Mercury in the 2nd links income and professional value to speech, analysis, records, commerce, or advisory skills, but combustion and retrogradation can correlate with revisions, misunderstandings, or nonlinear financial and communication patterns.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 7th house, supporting public interaction, clients, contracts, trade, and partnership-based work. Saturn's aspect adds seriousness and durability but may make partnerships demanding or slow to mature.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"The Sun in the 1st can increase ambition, visibility, and identification with professional standing, although its enemy-sign dignity suggests that authority and recognition may be developed through persistence rather than assumed naturally.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Vipareeta Raja Yoga involving the 12th lord Jupiter in the 6th suggests an ability to derive advancement from difficult assignments, institutional problems, competitors, or adverse circumstances.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are unavailable.","D10 aspects, conjunction rules, and planetary dignities are not supplied, limiting finer vocational specialization.","No specific career event or date was requested, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed."],"rationale":"The synthesis is supportive because exalted lagna lord Saturn in the 10th, Sasa Yoga, yogakaraka Venus, and Venus in the D10 10th provide unusually strong structural career promise. The chart favors durable authority, administration, institutional or foreign-linked work, service, problem-solving, technical initiative, advisory functions, and public or client-facing responsibilities. The principal tension is that the D1 10th lord occupies the 12th with Rahu while the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, indicating that progress may include unconventional settings, heavy expenditure, conflict, periodic redirection, or work performed away from conventional visibility. The D10 placement of Venus in the 10th and Jupiter-centered 11th-house emphasis reconcile this conflict by showing that such complexity need not deny achievement; rather, success is more likely through disciplined specialization, networks, and difficult or institutional assignments than through a simple linear path."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The primary career signature is exceptionally strong: lagna lord Saturn occupies the 10th house in exaltation, forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This supports sustained responsibility, administration, institutional authority, discipline, and status earned over time.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Venus is also the 5th lord, creating yogakaraka/Raja Yoga potential for achievement through skill, judgment, creativity, education, or strategy.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, however, is placed in the 12th house with Rahu. Career may therefore involve foreign environments, large institutions, behind-the-scenes work, research, seclusion, or substantial expenditure; it can also produce unconventional ambitions and periodic dissatisfaction or redirection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Dashamsa reinforces professional visibility because Venus occupies the D10 10th house. This substantially offsets the D1 10th lord's placement in the 12th and suggests that Venusian capacities can manifest directly through vocation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter occupies Pisces in the 11th house alongside Mercury and Rahu, supporting gains through knowledge, advisory activity, networks, communication, and broad or nontraditional professional circles, although Rahu can make gains uneven or highly ambitious.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Jupiter occupies the 6th and aspects the 10th. This connects career with service, problem-solving, competition, disputes, or demanding daily work; its retrograde condition and enemy-sign dignity indicate that growth may require repeated adjustment rather than arriving effortlessly.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter, and Ketu. Jupiter offers guidance, while Mars adds drive and technical initiative; Mars and Ketu can also produce conflict with authority, abrupt professional changes, or impatience with routine structures.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars in the 3rd supports initiative, courage, communication, technical skill, and self-directed effort, and its aspect to the 10th makes personal enterprise important to career development.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury in the 2nd links income and professional value to speech, analysis, records, commerce, or advisory skills, but combustion and retrogradation can correlate with revisions, misunderstandings, or nonlinear financial and communication patterns.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 7th house, supporting public interaction, clients, contracts, trade, and partnership-based work. Saturn's aspect adds seriousness and durability but may make partnerships demanding or slow to mature.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun in the 1st can increase ambition, visibility, and identification with professional standing, although its enemy-sign dignity suggests that authority and recognition may be developed through persistence rather than assumed naturally.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Vipareeta Raja Yoga involving the 12th lord Jupiter in the 6th suggests an ability to derive advancement from difficult assignments, institutional problems, competitors, or adverse circumstances.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are unavailable.\",\"D10 aspects, conjunction rules, and planetary dignities are not supplied, limiting finer vocational specialization.\",\"No specific career event or date was requested, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The synthesis is supportive because exalted lagna lord Saturn in the 10th, Sasa Yoga, yogakaraka Venus, and Venus in the D10 10th provide unusually strong structural career promise. The chart favors durable authority, administration, institutional or foreign-linked work, service, problem-solving, technical initiative, advisory functions, and public or client-facing responsibilities. The principal tension is that the D1 10th lord occupies the 12th with Rahu while the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, indicating that progress may include unconventional settings, heavy expenditure, conflict, periodic redirection, or work performed away from conventional visibility. The D10 placement of Venus in the 10th and Jupiter-centered 11th-house emphasis reconcile this conflict by showing that such complexity need not deny achievement; rather, success is more likely through disciplined specialization, networks, and difficult or institutional assignments than through a simple linear path.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.87,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Career capacity and public standing are strongly supported by exalted Saturn occupying the 10th house and forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga, favoring sustained responsibility, administration, organization, and authority developed through disciplined effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Saturn is also the Capricorn lagna lord and is placed in the 10th, closely connecting identity and life direction with profession; as ruler of the 2nd house, it also links accumulated resources and livelihood with career.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating a stated Raja Yoga and linking profession with intelligence, creativity, counsel, strategy, or cultivated expertise.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/9/lord","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Venus occupies the 12th house with Rahu. This can direct work toward foreign environments, large institutions, remote or behind-the-scenes settings, research, expenditure management, or unconventional sectors, but may also bring professional discontinuity, high expenses, or unclear boundaries.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter, and Ketu. Mars adds initiative and technical or competitive pressure; Jupiter can contribute advisory, educational, or service-oriented content; Ketu can produce specialization or periodic detachment from status and conventional career paths.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Jupiter","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, the 12th lord, occupies the 6th and forms a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, indicating potential advancement through solving difficult service, institutional, debt, dispute, compliance, or operational problems rather than through an entirely smooth path.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity in the 6th with Ketu, so judgment, mentors, workplace alliances, or service conditions may periodically require reassessment; success is more likely through problem-solving than effortless patronage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Mars in the 3rd supports initiative, courage, practical execution, communication, and self-directed skill development, while its aspect to the 10th can make the professional style forceful or technically oriented but may also create conflict with authority if poorly moderated.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury in the 2nd connects communication and analytical ability with earnings, but its retrograde and combust conditions suggest that speech, documentation, negotiations, and financial decisions benefit from careful review.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"The D10 strongly reinforces career potential because Venus occupies the D10 10th house, while Jupiter occupies Pisces in the 11th, supporting gains through knowledge, guidance, institutions, or broad professional networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/4"]},{"claim":"D10 Mercury and Rahu also occupy the 11th with Jupiter, suggesting gains through communication, technology, unusual networks, or nontraditional professional ecosystems, although expectations and alliances may fluctuate.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn in the 3rd emphasizes persistent effort, structured communication, and gradual skill accumulation; professional results are more consistent with endurance and mastery than rapid or effortless elevation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No profession, employment history, education, or career objectives were supplied, so the chart cannot identify a single occupation with high confidence.","D10 aspects, dignity scores, Shadbala, and other quantitative strength measures are not provided; finer ranking of career factors is therefore limited.","No target date or career event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not used in this natal synthesis."],"rationale":"The dominant signature is strong and career-centered: exalted lagna lord Saturn in the 10th, Sasa Yoga, and a 5th-and-10th-lord Venus Raja Yoga are reinforced by Venus in the D10 10th. These combinations support durable achievement, responsibility, administration, structured leadership, and public credibility. The main conflict is that the 10th lord occupies the 12th with Rahu while the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, making the path less conventional and potentially marked by institutional or foreign settings, periodic detachment, pressure, or changes in direction. Jupiter in the 6th and the D10 11th emphasis favor advancement through specialized problem-solving, service, advisory work, operations, communication, technology, or broad networks. Overall, the career promise is supportive and substantial, but realization is most likely through patience, disciplined expertise, and careful management of workplace conflict, communication, expenses, and unconventional opportunities."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.87,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Career capacity and public standing are strongly supported by exalted Saturn occupying the 10th house and forming Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga, favoring sustained responsibility, administration, organization, and authority developed through disciplined effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is also the Capricorn lagna lord and is placed in the 10th, closely connecting identity and life direction with profession; as ruler of the 2nd house, it also links accumulated resources and livelihood with career.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating a stated Raja Yoga and linking profession with intelligence, creativity, counsel, strategy, or cultivated expertise.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Venus occupies the 12th house with Rahu. This can direct work toward foreign environments, large institutions, remote or behind-the-scenes settings, research, expenditure management, or unconventional sectors, but may also bring professional discontinuity, high expenses, or unclear boundaries.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter, and Ketu. Mars adds initiative and technical or competitive pressure; Jupiter can contribute advisory, educational, or service-oriented content; Ketu can produce specialization or periodic detachment from status and conventional career paths.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, the 12th lord, occupies the 6th and forms a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, indicating potential advancement through solving difficult service, institutional, debt, dispute, compliance, or operational problems rather than through an entirely smooth path.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity in the 6th with Ketu, so judgment, mentors, workplace alliances, or service conditions may periodically require reassessment; success is more likely through problem-solving than effortless patronage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars in the 3rd supports initiative, courage, practical execution, communication, and self-directed skill development, while its aspect to the 10th can make the professional style forceful or technically oriented but may also create conflict with authority if poorly moderated.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury in the 2nd connects communication and analytical ability with earnings, but its retrograde and combust conditions suggest that speech, documentation, negotiations, and financial decisions benefit from careful review.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 strongly reinforces career potential because Venus occupies the D10 10th house, while Jupiter occupies Pisces in the 11th, supporting gains through knowledge, guidance, institutions, or broad professional networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mercury and Rahu also occupy the 11th with Jupiter, suggesting gains through communication, technology, unusual networks, or nontraditional professional ecosystems, although expectations and alliances may fluctuate.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn in the 3rd emphasizes persistent effort, structured communication, and gradual skill accumulation; professional results are more consistent with endurance and mastery than rapid or effortless elevation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No profession, employment history, education, or career objectives were supplied, so the chart cannot identify a single occupation with high confidence.\",\"D10 aspects, dignity scores, Shadbala, and other quantitative strength measures are not provided; finer ranking of career factors is therefore limited.\",\"No target date or career event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not used in this natal synthesis.\"],\"rationale\":\"The dominant signature is strong and career-centered: exalted lagna lord Saturn in the 10th, Sasa Yoga, and a 5th-and-10th-lord Venus Raja Yoga are reinforced by Venus in the D10 10th. These combinations support durable achievement, responsibility, administration, structured leadership, and public credibility. The main conflict is that the 10th lord occupies the 12th with Rahu while the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, making the path less conventional and potentially marked by institutional or foreign settings, periodic detachment, pressure, or changes in direction. Jupiter in the 6th and the D10 11th emphasis favor advancement through specialized problem-solving, service, advisory work, operations, communication, technology, or broad networks. Overall, the career promise is supportive and substantial, but realization is most likely through patience, disciplined expertise, and careful management of workplace conflict, communication, expenses, and unconventional opportunities.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-02","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Career and public standing are major strengths: the ascendant lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, and the chart explicitly identifies Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This favors sustained responsibility, organization, authority and achievement through persistence.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating the stated single-lordship Raja Yoga; this connects intelligence, creativity and merit with profession.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Venus occupies the 12th house with Rahu. Career may therefore involve foreign environments, large institutions, remote or behind-the-scenes work, research, retreat settings, or substantial professional expenditure; it can also produce unconventional career choices.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"The D10 reinforces professional prominence because Venus occupies its 10th house.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter, Mercury and Rahu occupy the 11th house, concentrating career indications around income, networks, audiences and goal fulfillment, although Rahu can make gains irregular or highly ambitious.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/4","/vargas/D10/placements/7","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"The natal 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter and Ketu. Jupiter offers a constructive influence, while Mars and Ketu can correlate with pressure, abrupt redirection, conflict or periods of detachment from a role.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Jupiter","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the 3rd house and rules the 11th, linking gains with initiative, technical or hands-on ability, communication, enterprise and self-directed effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/3","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Jupiter and Ketu in the 6th emphasize service, problem-solving, competition and difficult operational environments. Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity, so growth may come through overcoming workplace complications rather than through an effortless path.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"The stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga—12th lord Jupiter in the 6th—suggests an ability to derive advancement from adversity, institutional complexity, disputes or demanding service conditions.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Mercury in the 2nd supports earning through speech, analysis, commerce or information, but its retrograde and combust conditions can produce revisions, misunderstandings or uneven confidence in financial and professional communication.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"The Sun in the ascendant can strengthen visibility and leadership motivation, but its enemy dignity and opposition to the 7th-house Moon indicate possible tension between personal authority and partners, clients or public expectations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/aspects/Sun","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 7th, supporting public dealings, trade, contracts and client-facing work, although Saturn's aspect can add seriousness, delay or demanding obligations in partnerships.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/houses/6/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Career history, education, industry and role are not provided, so the chart cannot identify one definitive occupation.","No specific forecast date or career event was requested; therefore date-dependent dasha and transit judgment is excluded."],"rationale":"The synthesis is strongly supportive because exalted ascendant lord Saturn occupies the 10th and forms Sasa Yoga, while the 5th-and-10th lord Venus forms a stated Raja Yoga and occupies the D10 10th. These are substantial indicators of durable professional capacity, responsibility and public standing. The principal complication is that natal Venus lies in the 12th with Rahu and the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, making the path potentially unconventional, foreign or institutional, expenditure-heavy, and subject to periodic redirection. Service-house emphasis further suggests that success is earned through solving difficult problems. Overall, the chart favors long-term career achievement more than a smooth or linear career trajectory."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Career and public standing are major strengths: the ascendant lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, and the chart explicitly identifies Sasa Mahapurusha Yoga. This favors sustained responsibility, organization, authority and achievement through persistence.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating the stated single-lordship Raja Yoga; this connects intelligence, creativity and merit with profession.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Venus occupies the 12th house with Rahu. Career may therefore involve foreign environments, large institutions, remote or behind-the-scenes work, research, retreat settings, or substantial professional expenditure; it can also produce unconventional career choices.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 reinforces professional prominence because Venus occupies its 10th house.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter, Mercury and Rahu occupy the 11th house, concentrating career indications around income, networks, audiences and goal fulfillment, although Rahu can make gains irregular or highly ambitious.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"The natal 10th house receives aspects from Mars, Jupiter and Ketu. Jupiter offers a constructive influence, while Mars and Ketu can correlate with pressure, abrupt redirection, conflict or periods of detachment from a role.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 3rd house and rules the 11th, linking gains with initiative, technical or hands-on ability, communication, enterprise and self-directed effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/3\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter and Ketu in the 6th emphasize service, problem-solving, competition and difficult operational environments. Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity, so growth may come through overcoming workplace complications rather than through an effortless path.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga—12th lord Jupiter in the 6th—suggests an ability to derive advancement from adversity, institutional complexity, disputes or demanding service conditions.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury in the 2nd supports earning through speech, analysis, commerce or information, but its retrograde and combust conditions can produce revisions, misunderstandings or uneven confidence in financial and professional communication.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun in the ascendant can strengthen visibility and leadership motivation, but its enemy dignity and opposition to the 7th-house Moon indicate possible tension between personal authority and partners, clients or public expectations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/aspects/Sun\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 7th, supporting public dealings, trade, contracts and client-facing work, although Saturn's aspect can add seriousness, delay or demanding obligations in partnerships.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Career history, education, industry and role are not provided, so the chart cannot identify one definitive occupation.\",\"No specific forecast date or career event was requested; therefore date-dependent dasha and transit judgment is excluded.\"],\"rationale\":\"The synthesis is strongly supportive because exalted ascendant lord Saturn occupies the 10th and forms Sasa Yoga, while the 5th-and-10th lord Venus forms a stated Raja Yoga and occupies the D10 10th. These are substantial indicators of durable professional capacity, responsibility and public standing. The principal complication is that natal Venus lies in the 12th with Rahu and the 10th receives Mars and Ketu influences, making the path potentially unconventional, foreign or institutional, expenditure-heavy, and subject to periodic redirection. Service-house emphasis further suggests that success is earned through solving difficult problems. Overall, the chart favors long-term career achievement more than a smooth or linear career trajectory.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord placed in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It indicates potential rather than guaranteeing enormous profits, so B overclaims; C states the opposite tendency, and D is therefore incorrect."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord placed in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It indicates potential rather than guaranteeing enormous profits, so B overclaims; C states the opposite tendency, and D is therefore incorrect.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord placed in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It does not guarantee enormous profits, and it is not primarily a financial-loss indication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord placed in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It does not guarantee enormous profits, and it is not primarily a financial-loss indication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-knowledge-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-knowledge-01","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"rationale":"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord’s placement in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It does not guarantee enormous profits, and it is not primarily a financial-loss indication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-knowledge-01\",\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"confidence\":0.98,\"rationale\":\"The VedAstro rule House1LordInHouse11 treats the ascendant lord’s placement in the eleventh house as supportive of gains and earning capacity. It does not guarantee enormous profits, and it is not primarily a financial-loss indication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is also the ascendant lord and is identified as forming a single-lord Raja Yoga, supporting career importance, initiative, and potential visibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 4th house and aspects the 10th, linking professional activity with education, property, administration, home-based matters, or intellectual and communicative work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/aspects/Mercury","/houses/3/significations","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury is combust, which can qualify the otherwise favorable career yoga through pressure on judgment, communication, recognition, or consistency.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, irregular professional direction, or periodic changes in vocational priorities.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellect with ambition or unconventionality; this can produce visibility but also a nonlinear career pattern.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Sun","/aspects/Mercury","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains, networks, and fulfillment through professional or social connections.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"In the D10 career chart, Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 10th house, suggesting scope for influence and expansion alongside unconventional ambition or volatility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Venus occupies the ascendant, supporting diplomacy, relationship management, presentation, creativity, or client-facing capability in professional life.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Mercury and Saturn occupy the 12th house, which may connect work with institutions, remote or foreign settings, research, back-office responsibilities, or periods of reduced visibility; the result cannot be narrowed further from the supplied facts.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific career event, occupation, decision, or date was supplied, so timing and suitability for a particular role cannot be assessed.","D10 house lordships, aspects, conjunction rules, and planetary dignities are not provided; therefore the divisional-chart judgment must remain limited.","No supported strength metrics beyond the listed natal dignities and combustion status are available."],"rationale":"The chart contains substantial career-supporting factors: the ascendant and 10th lord Mercury is explicitly associated with Raja Yoga, aspects the 10th house, and exalted Jupiter occupies the house of gains. The D10 also places Jupiter in the 10th and Venus in the ascendant. These are qualified by Mercury's combustion, Ketu in the natal 10th, Rahu joining Jupiter in the D10 10th, and Mercury-Saturn in the D10 12th. The supported synthesis is therefore meaningful professional potential with unconventional, periodically detached, or less linear expression rather than an unambiguously favorable career outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is also the ascendant lord and is identified as forming a single-lord Raja Yoga, supporting career importance, initiative, and potential visibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 4th house and aspects the 10th, linking professional activity with education, property, administration, home-based matters, or intellectual and communicative work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/aspects/Mercury\",\"/houses/3/significations\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is combust, which can qualify the otherwise favorable career yoga through pressure on judgment, communication, recognition, or consistency.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, irregular professional direction, or periodic changes in vocational priorities.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellect with ambition or unconventionality; this can produce visibility but also a nonlinear career pattern.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Sun\",\"/aspects/Mercury\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter in the 11th supports gains, networks, and fulfillment through professional or social connections.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10 career chart, Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 10th house, suggesting scope for influence and expansion alongside unconventional ambition or volatility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Venus occupies the ascendant, supporting diplomacy, relationship management, presentation, creativity, or client-facing capability in professional life.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mercury and Saturn occupy the 12th house, which may connect work with institutions, remote or foreign settings, research, back-office responsibilities, or periods of reduced visibility; the result cannot be narrowed further from the supplied facts.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific career event, occupation, decision, or date was supplied, so timing and suitability for a particular role cannot be assessed.\",\"D10 house lordships, aspects, conjunction rules, and planetary dignities are not provided; therefore the divisional-chart judgment must remain limited.\",\"No supported strength metrics beyond the listed natal dignities and combustion status are available.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart contains substantial career-supporting factors: the ascendant and 10th lord Mercury is explicitly associated with Raja Yoga, aspects the 10th house, and exalted Jupiter occupies the house of gains. The D10 also places Jupiter in the 10th and Venus in the ascendant. These are qualified by Mercury's combustion, Ketu in the natal 10th, Rahu joining Jupiter in the D10 10th, and Mercury-Saturn in the D10 12th. The supported synthesis is therefore meaningful professional potential with unconventional, periodically detached, or less linear expression rather than an unambiguously favorable career outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh may support gains, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats this placement as supportive of gains rather than primarily as a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord, Sun, is placed in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A correctly applies the listed rule. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in the eleventh house, whose significations include gains and income. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh may support gains, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats this placement as supportive of gains rather than primarily as a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord, Sun, is placed in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A correctly applies the listed rule. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in the eleventh house, whose significations include gains and income. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the eleventh as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A correctly applies the listed rule. The chart explicitly places the Leo ascendant lord, Sun, in house 11, whose significations include gains and income. Option B converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses its stated polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the eleventh as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A correctly applies the listed rule. The chart explicitly places the Leo ascendant lord, Sun, in house 11, whose significations include gains and income. Option B converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses its stated polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is also the ascendant lord and forms a stated Raja Yoga, supporting professional capability, initiative, and the potential to connect personal strengths with career responsibilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 4th house with the Sun, forming the stated Budha-Aditya Yoga; this can support intellect, administration, communication, education, property, or institution-related work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Sun/house","/yogas/0","/houses/3/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury is combust, qualifying the strength and consistency of the 10th lord and the Budha-Aditya indication.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, discontinuity, specialization, or an unconventional professional path rather than straightforward career satisfaction.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/9/occupants"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter occupies the 11th house of gains and networks, supporting income, professional alliances, and fulfillment through knowledgeable or advisory roles.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellectual activity with ambition or unconventional influences; this makes professional expression potent but potentially irregular.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Sun","/aspects/Mercury","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"In the D10 career chart, Jupiter occupies the 10th house, supporting responsibility, guidance, expertise, or respected professional functions, while Rahu in the same house adds strong ambition and nontraditional career themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha"]},{"claim":"D10 Venus in the 1st house can support diplomacy, relationship management, presentation, and an ability to attract cooperation in professional settings.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/graha"]},{"claim":"D10 Mercury and Saturn in the 12th house suggest that career results may involve behind-the-scenes work, large or foreign institutions, isolation, expenditure, or periods when effort and recognition do not align directly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/6/graha","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"Mars, lord of the 8th, occupies the 6th and forms the stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting some capacity to overcome competition, disputes, service pressures, or difficult professional conditions.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/7/lord","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific career field, event, or decision is supplied, so the chart cannot identify one definite occupation or outcome.","No date or time window is requested; therefore dasha and transit timing is not evaluated.","Shadbala, exact divisional dignity assessments, and other quantitative strength measures are not provided."],"rationale":"The chart contains substantial career support through the dual lordship of Mercury, the stated Raja and Budha-Aditya yogas, exalted Jupiter in the 11th, and Jupiter in the D10 10th. These are offset by Mercury's combustion, natal Ketu in the 10th, Rahu's influence, and D10 Mercury-Saturn in the 12th. The supported synthesis is therefore a capable but potentially unconventional or uneven professional trajectory, with gains possible through knowledge, communication, administration, advisory work, institutions, networks, or specialized roles. The evidence does not justify a single occupation or an assured level of success."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is also the ascendant lord and forms a stated Raja Yoga, supporting professional capability, initiative, and the potential to connect personal strengths with career responsibilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 4th house with the Sun, forming the stated Budha-Aditya Yoga; this can support intellect, administration, communication, education, property, or institution-related work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/houses/3/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is combust, qualifying the strength and consistency of the 10th lord and the Budha-Aditya indication.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, discontinuity, specialization, or an unconventional professional path rather than straightforward career satisfaction.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/9/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter occupies the 11th house of gains and networks, supporting income, professional alliances, and fulfillment through knowledgeable or advisory roles.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellectual activity with ambition or unconventional influences; this makes professional expression potent but potentially irregular.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Sun\",\"/aspects/Mercury\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10 career chart, Jupiter occupies the 10th house, supporting responsibility, guidance, expertise, or respected professional functions, while Rahu in the same house adds strong ambition and nontraditional career themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Venus in the 1st house can support diplomacy, relationship management, presentation, and an ability to attract cooperation in professional settings.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mercury and Saturn in the 12th house suggest that career results may involve behind-the-scenes work, large or foreign institutions, isolation, expenditure, or periods when effort and recognition do not align directly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/graha\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars, lord of the 8th, occupies the 6th and forms the stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting some capacity to overcome competition, disputes, service pressures, or difficult professional conditions.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/2\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific career field, event, or decision is supplied, so the chart cannot identify one definite occupation or outcome.\",\"No date or time window is requested; therefore dasha and transit timing is not evaluated.\",\"Shadbala, exact divisional dignity assessments, and other quantitative strength measures are not provided.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart contains substantial career support through the dual lordship of Mercury, the stated Raja and Budha-Aditya yogas, exalted Jupiter in the 11th, and Jupiter in the D10 10th. These are offset by Mercury's combustion, natal Ketu in the 10th, Rahu's influence, and D10 Mercury-Saturn in the 12th. The supported synthesis is therefore a capable but potentially unconventional or uneven professional trajectory, with gains possible through knowledge, communication, administration, advisory work, institutions, networks, or specialized roles. The evidence does not justify a single occupation or an assured level of success.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is a gains indication rather than primarily a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Sun in the eleventh house, whose stated significations include gains and income. B converts a supportive indication into an unjustified guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is a gains indication rather than primarily a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Sun in the eleventh house, whose stated significations include gains and income. B converts a supportive indication into an unjustified guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second-house lord is placed in the first house, supporting wealth through personal effort, intelligence, or learning under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support wealth but does not guarantee it.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the second lord in the first as supportive rather than primarily indicating inability to earn.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart fact that the second lord is placed in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly places the second-house lord, Venus, in the first house. Therefore A applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the rule's polarity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second-house lord is placed in the first house, supporting wealth through personal effort, intelligence, or learning under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support wealth but does not guarantee it.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the second lord in the first as supportive rather than primarily indicating inability to earn.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart fact that the second lord is placed in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly places the second-house lord, Venus, in the first house. Therefore A applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the rule's polarity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-03","domain":"career","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Mercury rules both the ascendant and the 10th house, creating a strong structural connection between identity, skills, and career direction; the supplied chart explicitly identifies this as a Raja Yoga.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/9/lord","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mercury is placed in the 4th house and directly aspects the 10th, supporting intellectual, administrative, communicative, educational, property-related, or home-based contributions to work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/aspects/Mercury/0","/houses/3/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury is combust and shares the 4th house with the Sun and Rahu, so the otherwise favorable career lord may operate with periodic pressure, ambiguity, restlessness, or complications involving judgment and authority.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/houses/3/occupants","/placements/Rahu/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, discontinuity, specialization, or changes in professional direction rather than an entirely linear career path.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellect with an unconventional or volatile influence on public standing.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Sun/0","/aspects/Mercury/0","/aspects/Rahu/1"]},{"claim":"Exalted Jupiter in the 11th house supports gains, networks, income, and fulfillment of objectives, providing a favorable resource for career outcomes even though it does not remove the 10th-house complications.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn in the 2nd house can support disciplined accumulation and sustained effort, although its aspect on the 11th may make gains gradual or responsibility-laden.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/aspects/Saturn/2","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"In the D10, Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 10th house, suggesting potential visibility, expansion, ambition, and unconventional professional developments, but also a need for sound judgment around status and opportunity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha"]},{"claim":"D10 Mercury is in its own sign Gemini but placed in the 12th house, supporting specialized intellectual or communicative ability while also connecting career activity with institutions, foreign settings, seclusion, expenditure, or behind-the-scenes work.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/dispositor","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"D10 Venus occupies the ascendant, adding a potentially diplomatic, relational, aesthetic, or client-facing quality to professional expression.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/graha"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific career event, profession, decision, or target date was supplied, so timing and suitability for a particular role cannot be assessed."],"rationale":"The chart contains substantial career support through Mercury's dual lordship of the 1st and 10th houses, its aspect to the 10th, exalted Jupiter in the gains house, and notable D10 emphasis on the 10th. However, Mercury's combustion, Rahu's involvement, Ketu in the natal 10th, and D10 Mercury in the 12th complicate a uniformly supportive judgment. The evidence therefore favors meaningful professional capacity and gains, but with unconventional direction, periodic instability, or work occurring away from straightforward public-status pathways."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mercury rules both the ascendant and the 10th house, creating a strong structural connection between identity, skills, and career direction; the supplied chart explicitly identifies this as a Raja Yoga.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is placed in the 4th house and directly aspects the 10th, supporting intellectual, administrative, communicative, educational, property-related, or home-based contributions to work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/aspects/Mercury/0\",\"/houses/3/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury is combust and shares the 4th house with the Sun and Rahu, so the otherwise favorable career lord may operate with periodic pressure, ambiguity, restlessness, or complications involving judgment and authority.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/houses/3/occupants\",\"/placements/Rahu/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu occupies the natal 10th house, indicating possible detachment from conventional status, discontinuity, specialization, or changes in professional direction rather than an entirely linear career path.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th house receives aspects from the Sun, Mercury, and Rahu, combining authority and intellect with an unconventional or volatile influence on public standing.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Sun/0\",\"/aspects/Mercury/0\",\"/aspects/Rahu/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Jupiter in the 11th house supports gains, networks, income, and fulfillment of objectives, providing a favorable resource for career outcomes even though it does not remove the 10th-house complications.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn in the 2nd house can support disciplined accumulation and sustained effort, although its aspect on the 11th may make gains gradual or responsibility-laden.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/aspects/Saturn/2\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10, Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 10th house, suggesting potential visibility, expansion, ambition, and unconventional professional developments, but also a need for sound judgment around status and opportunity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mercury is in its own sign Gemini but placed in the 12th house, supporting specialized intellectual or communicative ability while also connecting career activity with institutions, foreign settings, seclusion, expenditure, or behind-the-scenes work.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/dispositor\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Venus occupies the ascendant, adding a potentially diplomatic, relational, aesthetic, or client-facing quality to professional expression.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/graha\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific career event, profession, decision, or target date was supplied, so timing and suitability for a particular role cannot be assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart contains substantial career support through Mercury's dual lordship of the 1st and 10th houses, its aspect to the 10th, exalted Jupiter in the gains house, and notable D10 emphasis on the 10th. However, Mercury's combustion, Rahu's involvement, Ketu in the natal 10th, and D10 Mercury in the 12th complicate a uniformly supportive judgment. The evidence therefore favors meaningful professional capacity and gains, but with unconventional direction, periodic instability, or work occurring away from straightforward public-status pathways.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation, without implying generosity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the second may support earning and accumulation under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats Mars in the second as supportive rather than as necessarily preventing accumulation.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Mars is placed in house 2, the house associated with wealth and accumulated resources. Therefore A applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C asserts the opposite of the stated rule; consequently D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation, without implying generosity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the second may support earning and accumulation under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats Mars in the second as supportive rather than as necessarily preventing accumulation.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Mars is placed in house 2, the house associated with wealth and accumulated resources. Therefore A applies. B improperly turns a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C asserts the opposite of the stated rule; consequently D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second-house lord is placed in the first house, supporting wealth earned through personal effort, intelligence, or learning under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support wealth but does not guarantee it.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the placement is supportive rather than primarily an inability-to-earn indication.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart: the second lord is placed in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly records the second-house lord as Venus and places that lord in house 1. Therefore A applies. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second-house lord is placed in the first house, supporting wealth earned through personal effort, intelligence, or learning under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support wealth but does not guarantee it.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the placement is supportive rather than primarily an inability-to-earn indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart: the second lord is placed in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly records the second-house lord as Venus and places that lord in house 1. Therefore A applies. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, C reverses the stated polarity, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation without implying generosity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the second may support wealth-building capacity under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats Mars in the second as supportive of accumulation rather than necessarily indicating inability to accumulate.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A directly matches the computed placement of Mars in house 2. Options B and C improperly convert or reverse the stated qualified indication, while D is false because A is established. Therefore, the polarity of the applicable listed statement is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation without implying generosity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the second may support wealth-building capacity under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats Mars in the second as supportive of accumulation rather than necessarily indicating inability to accumulate.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A directly matches the computed placement of Mars in house 2. Options B and C improperly convert or reverse the stated qualified indication, while D is false because A is established. Therefore, the polarity of the applicable listed statement is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The supplied facts identify the first-house lord as Venus placed in the first house; they do not establish that the second-house lord is in the first house.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"omission","correction":"This rule cannot be applied without the second house's lord and its placement.","evidence":["/houses/1"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required second-lord placement is not provided, and such a placement would indicate support rather than guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/houses/1"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule does not primarily characterize the second lord in the first as inability to earn; moreover, that placement is not established here.","evidence":["/houses/1"]}],"missing_information":["Identity of the second-house lord","House placement of the second-house lord"],"rationale":"Only first-house lord data are supplied. Therefore none of A–C is established by the chart facts, making D the applicable option and the result insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The supplied facts identify the first-house lord as Venus placed in the first house; they do not establish that the second-house lord is in the first house.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"omission\",\"correction\":\"This rule cannot be applied without the second house's lord and its placement.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required second-lord placement is not provided, and such a placement would indicate support rather than guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule does not primarily characterize the second lord in the first as inability to earn; moreover, that placement is not established here.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Identity of the second-house lord\",\"House placement of the second-house lord\"],\"rationale\":\"Only first-house lord data are supplied. Therefore none of A–C is established by the chart facts, making D the applicable option and the result insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A's specified challenging wealth rule applies.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius; it does not establish financial struggle regardless of sign.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The rule describes a challenge involving heavy effort for limited gain; it does not guarantee poverty.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A matches both the stated condition and the computed chart. Saturn is in house 2 and in Scorpio, so the polarity of the applicable listed statement is challenging. Options B and C improperly convert a conditional indication into universal or guaranteed outcomes, while D is false because A applies."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-04\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A's specified challenging wealth rule applies.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius; it does not establish financial struggle regardless of sign.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The rule describes a challenge involving heavy effort for limited gain; it does not guarantee poverty.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A matches both the stated condition and the computed chart. Saturn is in house 2 and in Scorpio, so the polarity of the applicable listed statement is challenging. Options B and C improperly convert a conditional indication into universal or guaranteed outcomes, while D is false because A applies.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation, without implying generosity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/1/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Mars in the second may support wealth-building capacity but does not guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, Mars in the second is not necessarily an inability-to-accumulate indication; it is treated as supportive of earning and accumulation.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/houses/1/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A directly matches the computed placement and the stated wealth rule. Options B and C improperly convert a supportive indication into an absolute guarantee or an absolute denial. Therefore, considering only the applicable listed statement, the polarity is supportive."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the second house, so the stated rule treats it as supportive of earning power and accumulation, without implying generosity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Mars in the second may support wealth-building capacity but does not guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, Mars in the second is not necessarily an inability-to-accumulate indication; it is treated as supportive of earning and accumulation.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Mars is computed in the second house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A directly matches the computed placement and the stated wealth rule. Options B and C improperly convert a supportive indication into an absolute guarantee or an absolute denial. Therefore, considering only the applicable listed statement, the polarity is supportive.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A's stated challenging rule applies.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius, so it does not establish that Saturn in the second always causes financial struggle regardless of sign.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The applicable rule indicates heavy effort for limited gain; it does not guarantee poverty.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 2 and in Scorpio, satisfying the stated condition. The applicable listed statement has challenging polarity; B and C improperly universalize or intensify the rule, while D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-04\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A's stated challenging rule applies.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius, so it does not establish that Saturn in the second always causes financial struggle regardless of sign.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The applicable rule indicates heavy effort for limited gain; it does not guarantee poverty.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 2 and in Scorpio, satisfying the stated condition. The applicable listed statement has challenging polarity; B and C improperly universalize or intensify the rule, while D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-04","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-04","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A applies and indicates heavy effort for comparatively limited financial gain under the stated rule.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being in the second house outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius; it does not establish struggle regardless of sign.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn's qualifying second-house placement supports a challenging indication under the stated rule but does not guarantee poverty.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A matches the chart and the stated conditional rule. Because the task requires polarity based solely on applicable listed statements, the conclusion is challenging. Options B and C improperly turn a conditional indication into an absolute or guaranteed outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-04\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the second house in Scorpio, which is outside Libra, Capricorn, and Aquarius; therefore statement A applies and indicates heavy effort for comparatively limited financial gain under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is conditional on Saturn being in the second house outside Libra, Capricorn, or Aquarius; it does not establish struggle regardless of sign.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn's qualifying second-house placement supports a challenging indication under the stated rule but does not guarantee poverty.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Saturn is in the second house in Scorpio.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A matches the chart and the stated conditional rule. Because the task requires polarity based solely on applicable listed statements, the conclusion is challenging. Options B and C improperly turn a conditional indication into an absolute or guaranteed outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for accumulated resources or family finances, but it does not guarantee fraud or any specific event.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a permissible interpretive statement because Ketu is placed in the second house, whose significations include wealth and accumulated resources. S2 wrongly converts an indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for accumulated resources or family finances, but it does not guarantee fraud or any specific event.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a permissible interpretive statement because Ketu is placed in the second house, whose significations include wealth and accumulated resources. S2 wrongly converts an indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the eleventh house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this supports wealth potential without guaranteeing riches.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the eleventh is supportive of gains and wealth potential, but no single placement guarantees riches.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is consistent with the chart and standard house symbolism, so it is not erroneous. S2 improperly turns a supportive indication into certainty. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the eleventh house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this supports wealth potential without guaranteeing riches.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the eleventh is supportive of gains and wealth potential, but no single placement guarantees riches.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is consistent with the chart and standard house symbolism, so it is not erroneous. S2 improperly turns a supportive indication into certainty. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for wealth, family resources, or speech, but it does not guarantee that fraud will occur.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a permissible, non-certain interpretation of Ketu occupying the wealth-signifying second house. S2 turns an indication into a guaranteed event, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for wealth, family resources, or speech, but it does not guarantee that fraud will occur.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a permissible, non-certain interpretation of Ketu occupying the wealth-signifying second house. S2 turns an indication into a guaranteed event, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["S2","S3"],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 11th house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this is supportive of wealth potential and accumulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 11th is supportive of gains and wealth potential, especially because it is exalted here, but it does not guarantee riches.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a proportionate interpretation and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"S2\",\"S3\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 11th house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this is supportive of wealth potential and accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 11th is supportive of gains and wealth potential, especially because it is exalted here, but it does not guarantee riches.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a proportionate interpretation and is not erroneous. S2 converts a supportive indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 11th house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this is supportive of wealth potential, though not a guarantee of riches.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Jupiter in the 11th is a supportive wealth indication, especially because it is exalted, but no single placement guarantees riches.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is consistent with the chart and is therefore not erroneous. S2 improperly converts a supportive indication into certainty. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 11th house, the house of gains and income, and is exalted; this is supportive of wealth potential, though not a guarantee of riches.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 11th is a supportive wealth indication, especially because it is exalted, but no single placement guarantees riches.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter occupies house 11, not house 12.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is consistent with the chart and is therefore not erroneous. S2 improperly converts a supportive indication into certainty. S3 directly contradicts Jupiter's recorded house placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-contradiction-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-contradiction-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for accumulated wealth, family resources, or speech, but it does not guarantee fraud or any specific event.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"factual","correction":"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.","evidence":["/placements/Ketu/house","/houses/1/occupants"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"S1 is a permissible general interpretation of Ketu occupying the wealth-signifying second house, so it is not erroneous. S2 improperly converts an astrological indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-contradiction-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Ketu in the second may be treated as a challenging indication for accumulated wealth, family resources, or speech, but it does not guarantee fraud or any specific event.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Ketu occupies house 2, not house 3.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Ketu/house\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"S1 is a permissible general interpretation of Ketu occupying the wealth-signifying second house, so it is not erroneous. S2 improperly converts an astrological indication into certainty, while S3 directly contradicts the recorded placement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.88,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The main wealth axis is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated wealth and the 11th house of income, and occupies its own 11th-house sign in moolatrikona dignity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1","/houses/10","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms listed dhana yogas connecting self-effort and life direction with wealth, income, networks, and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"The 11th house nevertheless receives Mars and Rahu aspects, so gains may involve competition, volatility, strong ambition, or periodic disruption rather than arriving uniformly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Yogakaraka Venus is exceptionally supportive: it rules the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign in the 9th, and participates in a raja yoga with 5th lord Mercury. This links fortune, assets, intelligence, education, judgment, and merit.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/lord","/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 5th, is well placed in the 9th in friendly dignity and conjunct Venus, supporting commercial intelligence, planning, knowledge-based earnings, and prudent opportunity recognition.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mars occupies the 5th and mutually aspects lagna lord Saturn, creating a listed raja yoga and connecting career action with intelligence, enterprise, and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Mars is in enemy dignity in the 5th, while Saturn and Ketu also influence that house; speculative activity may therefore be contentious or uneven despite Jupiter's protective aspect. The chart is stronger for structured accumulation than for risk-heavy speculation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house is unoccupied and receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th. This can connect resources with taxes, inheritance, joint assets, or sudden financial restructuring, but may also produce fluctuations or pressure around reserves.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th links expenditure or foreign/institutional themes with income. This can produce gains through such settings, while also allowing earnings to be absorbed by obligations or long-term outlays.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"D10 reinforces earning capacity through profession: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th and Venus occupies its own sign in the 4th, although Jupiter in Capricorn in the 12th suggests that some professional gains may require institutional, foreign, charitable, or behind-the-scenes expenditure.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/4"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart, the principal divisional chart for wealth, is not provided.","Quantitative strengths such as shadbala, bhavabala and ashtakavarga are not provided.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed."],"rationale":"Overall wealth potential is supportive and materially above average because the same strong Jupiter governs both accumulation and gains, occupies the 11th in moolatrikona, and joins the lagna lord in explicit dhana yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury add fortune, judgment, education, assets, and commercial intelligence, while career-to-gains connections are also favorable. The principal qualifications are affliction to the 11th and 5th, the 2nd house's connection with the 8th-house Sun, and the 12th lord's participation in the gains house. These combinations favor disciplined, knowledge-based, professional, and network-supported accumulation more than aggressive speculation; they indicate capacity rather than guaranteed outcomes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.88,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The main wealth axis is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated wealth and the 11th house of income, and occupies its own 11th-house sign in moolatrikona dignity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1\",\"/houses/10\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms listed dhana yogas connecting self-effort and life direction with wealth, income, networks, and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th house nevertheless receives Mars and Rahu aspects, so gains may involve competition, volatility, strong ambition, or periodic disruption rather than arriving uniformly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Yogakaraka Venus is exceptionally supportive: it rules the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign in the 9th, and participates in a raja yoga with 5th lord Mercury. This links fortune, assets, intelligence, education, judgment, and merit.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/lord\",\"/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 5th, is well placed in the 9th in friendly dignity and conjunct Venus, supporting commercial intelligence, planning, knowledge-based earnings, and prudent opportunity recognition.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mars occupies the 5th and mutually aspects lagna lord Saturn, creating a listed raja yoga and connecting career action with intelligence, enterprise, and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in enemy dignity in the 5th, while Saturn and Ketu also influence that house; speculative activity may therefore be contentious or uneven despite Jupiter's protective aspect. The chart is stronger for structured accumulation than for risk-heavy speculation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house is unoccupied and receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th. This can connect resources with taxes, inheritance, joint assets, or sudden financial restructuring, but may also produce fluctuations or pressure around reserves.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th links expenditure or foreign/institutional themes with income. This can produce gains through such settings, while also allowing earnings to be absorbed by obligations or long-term outlays.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 reinforces earning capacity through profession: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th and Venus occupies its own sign in the 4th, although Jupiter in Capricorn in the 12th suggests that some professional gains may require institutional, foreign, charitable, or behind-the-scenes expenditure.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart, the principal divisional chart for wealth, is not provided.\",\"Quantitative strengths such as shadbala, bhavabala and ashtakavarga are not provided.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Overall wealth potential is supportive and materially above average because the same strong Jupiter governs both accumulation and gains, occupies the 11th in moolatrikona, and joins the lagna lord in explicit dhana yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury add fortune, judgment, education, assets, and commercial intelligence, while career-to-gains connections are also favorable. The principal qualifications are affliction to the 11th and 5th, the 2nd house's connection with the 8th-house Sun, and the 12th lord's participation in the gains house. These combinations favor disciplined, knowledge-based, professional, and network-supported accumulation more than aggressive speculation; they indicate capacity rather than guaranteed outcomes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.88,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The principal wealth signature is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, and forms explicit dhana yogas with lagna lord Saturn there.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/2/lord","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's strong 11th-house placement supports income, networks and fulfilment of financial objectives, while Saturn's conjunction suggests gains through sustained, structured or long-duration effort rather than effortless windfalls.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/significations","/houses/11/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Venus, lord of the 9th and a yogakaraka by ownership of the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign in the 9th; its conjunction with 5th-lord Mercury creates a listed raja yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment and opportunity as indirect drivers of prosperity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mars and lagna lord Saturn form a listed mutual-aspect raja yoga, linking personal effort and career with the 11th house of gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Saturn","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Career capacity can materially support wealth: in D10, Mars occupies its own sign Scorpio in the 10th house, while Venus occupies its own sign Taurus.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2","/vargas/D10/placements/5"]},{"claim":"The wealth configuration is not entirely smooth because the 11th house and its occupants receive aspects from Mars and Rahu, indicating possible fluctuations, aggressive financial decisions or unconventional income dynamics.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/11/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the 5th house in enemy dignity, and the 5th also receives Saturn and Ketu aspects. This makes speculation and concentrated risk a weaker channel than income derived from career, expertise and networks.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/5/significations","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Saturn also rules the 12th house and sits in the 11th, connecting gains with expenditure, foreign links or institutional settings; however, its simultaneous role as lagna lord and conjunction with a strong Jupiter substantially moderates this leakage indication.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/12/lord","/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house itself is empty and receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th, adding some potential for episodic changes in savings or family resources despite the strong 2nd lord.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/2/occupants","/houses/2/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No wealth-specific D2 Hora chart is provided.","No ashtakavarga, shadbala or other quantified strength data is provided.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not assessed."],"rationale":"Overall wealth potential is supportive and above average because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well placed in its own 11th house, joins the lagna lord in explicit dhana yogas, and is reinforced by strong 9th-house raja-yoga factors and career signatures. The main conflict is between strong capacity for gains and affliction to the 11th and 5th houses, which can produce uneven cash flow or losses from aggressive speculation. The chart therefore favors gradual accumulation through profession, knowledge, institutions and networks more than high-risk financial bets; it indicates potential rather than guaranteed outcomes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.88,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The principal wealth signature is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, and forms explicit dhana yogas with lagna lord Saturn there.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/2/lord\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's strong 11th-house placement supports income, networks and fulfilment of financial objectives, while Saturn's conjunction suggests gains through sustained, structured or long-duration effort rather than effortless windfalls.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/significations\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, lord of the 9th and a yogakaraka by ownership of the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign in the 9th; its conjunction with 5th-lord Mercury creates a listed raja yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment and opportunity as indirect drivers of prosperity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mars and lagna lord Saturn form a listed mutual-aspect raja yoga, linking personal effort and career with the 11th house of gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career capacity can materially support wealth: in D10, Mars occupies its own sign Scorpio in the 10th house, while Venus occupies its own sign Taurus.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"The wealth configuration is not entirely smooth because the 11th house and its occupants receive aspects from Mars and Rahu, indicating possible fluctuations, aggressive financial decisions or unconventional income dynamics.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 5th house in enemy dignity, and the 5th also receives Saturn and Ketu aspects. This makes speculation and concentrated risk a weaker channel than income derived from career, expertise and networks.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/5/significations\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn also rules the 12th house and sits in the 11th, connecting gains with expenditure, foreign links or institutional settings; however, its simultaneous role as lagna lord and conjunction with a strong Jupiter substantially moderates this leakage indication.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/12/lord\",\"/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house itself is empty and receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th, adding some potential for episodic changes in savings or family resources despite the strong 2nd lord.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/occupants\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No wealth-specific D2 Hora chart is provided.\",\"No ashtakavarga, shadbala or other quantified strength data is provided.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Overall wealth potential is supportive and above average because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well placed in its own 11th house, joins the lagna lord in explicit dhana yogas, and is reinforced by strong 9th-house raja-yoga factors and career signatures. The main conflict is between strong capacity for gains and affliction to the 11th and 5th houses, which can produce uneven cash flow or losses from aggressive speculation. The chart therefore favors gradual accumulation through profession, knowledge, institutions and networks more than high-risk financial bets; it indicates potential rather than guaranteed outcomes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.91,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The principal wealth signature is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated wealth and the 11th house of income, occupies the 11th in Sagittarius, and has moolatrikona dignity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter conjoins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th, explicitly forming dhana yogas that connect self-directed effort with income, gains, networks, and resource accumulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/occupants","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Yogakaraka Venus is in its own sign in the 9th and conjoins 5th lord Mercury, producing both a conjunction-based raja yoga and Venus's single-lordship raja yoga; fortune, education, judgment, and skilled activity can therefore support wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/lord","/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Career-to-gains support is present because 10th lord Mars and ascendant lord Saturn mutually aspect one another; the D10 further places Mars in Scorpio in the 10th, favoring initiative, command, and sustained professional action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Saturn","/yogas/2","/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"The exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting public activity through stability, assets, education, caretaking, or public-facing responsibilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/aspects/Moon"]},{"claim":"Income may nevertheless be uneven or accompanied by pressure: Mars and Rahu aspect the 11th, while Saturn occupies it with Jupiter. This can produce ambition and scale but also delays, conflict, risk-taking, or fluctuating networks.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy","/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Mars/isBenefic","/placements/Rahu/isBenefic","/placements/Saturn/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect, while its lord is much better placed in the 11th; thus earning and accumulation are stronger than the unafflicted preservation signature, making disciplined saving and family-finance management important.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/isBenefic","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn simultaneously rules the 1st and 12th and sits in the 11th. This can connect gains with institutions, foreign settings, long-term projects, or expenditure, but may also create leakage or delayed realization unless resources are structured carefully.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/0/lord","/houses/0/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"The D10 is not uniformly strong for financial expression: Jupiter is in Capricorn in the 12th and Mercury is in Pisces in the 2nd, indicating that professional gains may coexist with overhead, institutional expenditure, or occasional problems in commercial accounting and communication.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart is substantially supportive for wealth because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is strongly placed in its own 11th house and joins ascendant lord Saturn, creating explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus–Mercury raja yogas and the Mars–Saturn career linkage provide additional channels through fortune, skill, profession, and networks. The result is moderated rather than effortless: malefic influence on the 11th, Saturn's 12th lordship, and mixed D10 indications suggest delays, overhead, volatile associations, and a need for conservative resource management. Overall, the capacity to earn and build gains is stronger than the indications for loss, but outcomes remain dependent on disciplined execution and timing."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.91,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The principal wealth signature is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated wealth and the 11th house of income, occupies the 11th in Sagittarius, and has moolatrikona dignity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter conjoins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th, explicitly forming dhana yogas that connect self-directed effort with income, gains, networks, and resource accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Yogakaraka Venus is in its own sign in the 9th and conjoins 5th lord Mercury, producing both a conjunction-based raja yoga and Venus's single-lordship raja yoga; fortune, education, judgment, and skilled activity can therefore support wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/lord\",\"/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career-to-gains support is present because 10th lord Mars and ascendant lord Saturn mutually aspect one another; the D10 further places Mars in Scorpio in the 10th, favoring initiative, command, and sustained professional action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/yogas/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting public activity through stability, assets, education, caretaking, or public-facing responsibilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/aspects/Moon\"]},{\"claim\":\"Income may nevertheless be uneven or accompanied by pressure: Mars and Rahu aspect the 11th, while Saturn occupies it with Jupiter. This can produce ambition and scale but also delays, conflict, risk-taking, or fluctuating networks.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Rahu/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Saturn/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect, while its lord is much better placed in the 11th; thus earning and accumulation are stronger than the unafflicted preservation signature, making disciplined saving and family-finance management important.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/isBenefic\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn simultaneously rules the 1st and 12th and sits in the 11th. This can connect gains with institutions, foreign settings, long-term projects, or expenditure, but may also create leakage or delayed realization unless resources are structured carefully.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/0/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 is not uniformly strong for financial expression: Jupiter is in Capricorn in the 12th and Mercury is in Pisces in the 2nd, indicating that professional gains may coexist with overhead, institutional expenditure, or occasional problems in commercial accounting and communication.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart is substantially supportive for wealth because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is strongly placed in its own 11th house and joins ascendant lord Saturn, creating explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus–Mercury raja yogas and the Mars–Saturn career linkage provide additional channels through fortune, skill, profession, and networks. The result is moderated rather than effortless: malefic influence on the 11th, Saturn's 12th lordship, and mixed D10 indications suggest delays, overhead, volatile associations, and a need for conservative resource management. Overall, the capacity to earn and build gains is stronger than the indications for loss, but outcomes remain dependent on disciplined execution and timing.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Income and gains are strongly supported by Jupiter occupying the 11th house in friendly dignity, although Jupiter also rules the 3rd and 6th houses for Libra lagna, making results effort- and service-dependent rather than uniformly benefic.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/3/lord","/houses/6/lord","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"A stated dhana yoga links the 9th lord Mercury with the 11th lord Sun in the ascendant, connecting fortune and gains with personal initiative, intellect, communication, or visibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2/name","/yogas/2/because","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"The dhana-yoga promise is moderated because Mercury is combust and the 11th lord Sun is debilitated, reducing consistency or ease in realizing gains.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/10/lord"]},{"claim":"Accumulation is the principal weakness: Saturn and debilitated Rahu occupy the 2nd house, indicating pressure, delay, volatility, or unconventional complications involving savings, family resources, and financial speech or decisions.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Mars occupies the 5th house, connecting wealth accumulation with intelligence, enterprise, creativity, children, or speculation; Jupiter's aspect to the 5th offers protection, but Mars makes speculative activity more risk-sensitive.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 11th receives aspects from Mars and Saturn, combining expansion in gains with competitive drive and delay or discipline; this supports eventual gains but not necessarily smooth cash flow.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th house, emphasizing expenditure, foreign or secluded settings, and possible leakage of resources; Mars and Ketu also aspect that house.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/11/aspectedBy","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"A stated vipareeta raja yoga arises because the 8th lord Venus occupies the 12th, suggesting some capacity to derive advantage after reversals, losses, or difficult transitions, but it does not remove the expenditure signature.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/3/name","/yogas/3/because","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn, ruler of both the 4th and 5th houses, forms a stated raja yoga; its involvement with the 2nd and 11th wealth houses can support assets and gains through persistence, structure, and delayed maturation, though its enemy dignity and conjunction with Rahu complicate delivery.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 10th house, providing a strong career and status foundation from which income can be generated.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The D10 reinforces professional earning capacity through Moon in the 10th, Sun in the 11th, and Venus in its own Taurus sign; Mercury in the 8th and Saturn-Rahu in the 7th indicate periodic complexity in professional transitions or partnerships.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/1","/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No D2 Hora chart is supplied for specialized wealth confirmation.","No shadbala, ashtakavarga, or quantified planetary-strength data is supplied.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not evaluated."],"rationale":"The chart has meaningful earning potential through Jupiter in the 11th, the 9th–11th lord dhana yoga, and a strong 10th lord Moon. The main conflict is between capacity to generate income and difficulty retaining it: the 2nd house is afflicted by Saturn and Rahu, while the debilitated ascendant lord occupies the 12th. Thus wealth is more likely to develop through sustained career effort, disciplined saving, and controlled risk than through effortless accumulation or speculation. Overall, the natal wealth picture is mixed but materially capable, with stronger indications for earning than for preserving resources."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Income and gains are strongly supported by Jupiter occupying the 11th house in friendly dignity, although Jupiter also rules the 3rd and 6th houses for Libra lagna, making results effort- and service-dependent rather than uniformly benefic.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"A stated dhana yoga links the 9th lord Mercury with the 11th lord Sun in the ascendant, connecting fortune and gains with personal initiative, intellect, communication, or visibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2/name\",\"/yogas/2/because\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The dhana-yoga promise is moderated because Mercury is combust and the 11th lord Sun is debilitated, reducing consistency or ease in realizing gains.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Accumulation is the principal weakness: Saturn and debilitated Rahu occupy the 2nd house, indicating pressure, delay, volatility, or unconventional complications involving savings, family resources, and financial speech or decisions.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Mars occupies the 5th house, connecting wealth accumulation with intelligence, enterprise, creativity, children, or speculation; Jupiter's aspect to the 5th offers protection, but Mars makes speculative activity more risk-sensitive.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 11th receives aspects from Mars and Saturn, combining expansion in gains with competitive drive and delay or discipline; this supports eventual gains but not necessarily smooth cash flow.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th house, emphasizing expenditure, foreign or secluded settings, and possible leakage of resources; Mars and Ketu also aspect that house.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"A stated vipareeta raja yoga arises because the 8th lord Venus occupies the 12th, suggesting some capacity to derive advantage after reversals, losses, or difficult transitions, but it does not remove the expenditure signature.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3/name\",\"/yogas/3/because\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn, ruler of both the 4th and 5th houses, forms a stated raja yoga; its involvement with the 2nd and 11th wealth houses can support assets and gains through persistence, structure, and delayed maturation, though its enemy dignity and conjunction with Rahu complicate delivery.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 10th house, providing a strong career and status foundation from which income can be generated.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 reinforces professional earning capacity through Moon in the 10th, Sun in the 11th, and Venus in its own Taurus sign; Mercury in the 8th and Saturn-Rahu in the 7th indicate periodic complexity in professional transitions or partnerships.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No D2 Hora chart is supplied for specialized wealth confirmation.\",\"No shadbala, ashtakavarga, or quantified planetary-strength data is supplied.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing are not evaluated.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart has meaningful earning potential through Jupiter in the 11th, the 9th–11th lord dhana yoga, and a strong 10th lord Moon. The main conflict is between capacity to generate income and difficulty retaining it: the 2nd house is afflicted by Saturn and Rahu, while the debilitated ascendant lord occupies the 12th. Thus wealth is more likely to develop through sustained career effort, disciplined saving, and controlled risk than through effortless accumulation or speculation. Overall, the natal wealth picture is mixed but materially capable, with stronger indications for earning than for preserving resources.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.87,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart has a direct dhana combination: the 11th lord Sun joins the 9th lord Mercury in the ascendant, linking gains, fortune and personal initiative.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/11/lord","/houses/9/lord"]},{"claim":"Mercury strengthens the fortune component by occupying a friendly sign and being vargottama, although combustion can reduce the consistency or clarity of its results.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/combust","/vargottama/0"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Sun is debilitated, so gains, recognition or support from influential networks may require sustained effort and may fluctuate despite the dhana yoga.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/11/lord","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter occupies the 11th house in friendly dignity, supporting income, networks and fulfilment of objectives; however, for Libra lagna it also rules the 3rd and 6th houses, making its wealth contribution mixed rather than unqualified.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/3/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Mars is placed in the 5th house, connecting accumulated wealth with intelligence, enterprise, creativity or speculation, but Mars also aspects the 11th and 12th houses, linking gains with volatility and expenditure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/2/lord","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house is heavily afflicted by Saturn and debilitated Rahu, with an aspect from Ketu. This is a major challenge for steady savings, family resources and disciplined financial accumulation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/2/occupants","/houses/2/aspectedBy","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn in the 2nd is also the ruler of both the 4th and 5th houses and is identified as a raja-yoga lord. It can support gradual asset formation through discipline, education or long-term planning, although its enemy dignity and association with Rahu complicate delivery.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/4/lord","/houses/5/lord","/houses/2/occupants"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 10th house, giving a strong vocational foundation and supporting earning capacity through career, status and public activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th house, emphasizing expenditure, foreign or secluded environments and possible leakage of resources. As 8th lord in the 12th it also forms a stated viparita raja yoga, suggesting some capacity to recover or benefit through difficult reversals rather than effortless prosperity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/8/lord","/yogas/3"]},{"claim":"Both Mars and Saturn aspect the 11th house occupied by Jupiter, indicating that gains can be substantial when effort and persistence are applied, but may arrive with pressure, delay, competition or unevenness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/houses/11/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No D2 Hora chart or other dedicated wealth divisional chart is provided.","No ashtakavarga, shadbala or quantified planetary-strength data is provided.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing were not assessed."],"rationale":"Earning potential is materially supported by the 9th–11th lord conjunction, Jupiter in the 11th and a strong 10th lord in its own 10th house. The principal weakness is retention: the 2nd house is afflicted by Saturn, Rahu and Ketu, while debilitated Venus in the 12th and Mars linking the 11th with the 12th emphasize expenses and volatility. Overall, the chart is better for generating income through career, initiative and networks than for effortless accumulation. Wealth is most plausibly built through disciplined, long-term management rather than speculation or reliance on smooth windfalls."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.87,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart has a direct dhana combination: the 11th lord Sun joins the 9th lord Mercury in the ascendant, linking gains, fortune and personal initiative.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury strengthens the fortune component by occupying a friendly sign and being vargottama, although combustion can reduce the consistency or clarity of its results.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/vargottama/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Sun is debilitated, so gains, recognition or support from influential networks may require sustained effort and may fluctuate despite the dhana yoga.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter occupies the 11th house in friendly dignity, supporting income, networks and fulfilment of objectives; however, for Libra lagna it also rules the 3rd and 6th houses, making its wealth contribution mixed rather than unqualified.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Mars is placed in the 5th house, connecting accumulated wealth with intelligence, enterprise, creativity or speculation, but Mars also aspects the 11th and 12th houses, linking gains with volatility and expenditure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lord\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house is heavily afflicted by Saturn and debilitated Rahu, with an aspect from Ketu. This is a major challenge for steady savings, family resources and disciplined financial accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/occupants\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the 2nd is also the ruler of both the 4th and 5th houses and is identified as a raja-yoga lord. It can support gradual asset formation through discipline, education or long-term planning, although its enemy dignity and association with Rahu complicate delivery.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/2/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Moon is in its own sign in the 10th house, giving a strong vocational foundation and supporting earning capacity through career, status and public activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th house, emphasizing expenditure, foreign or secluded environments and possible leakage of resources. As 8th lord in the 12th it also forms a stated viparita raja yoga, suggesting some capacity to recover or benefit through difficult reversals rather than effortless prosperity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/8/lord\",\"/yogas/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"Both Mars and Saturn aspect the 11th house occupied by Jupiter, indicating that gains can be substantial when effort and persistence are applied, but may arrive with pressure, delay, competition or unevenness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No D2 Hora chart or other dedicated wealth divisional chart is provided.\",\"No ashtakavarga, shadbala or quantified planetary-strength data is provided.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing were not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Earning potential is materially supported by the 9th–11th lord conjunction, Jupiter in the 11th and a strong 10th lord in its own 10th house. The principal weakness is retention: the 2nd house is afflicted by Saturn, Rahu and Ketu, while debilitated Venus in the 12th and Mars linking the 11th with the 12th emphasize expenses and volatility. Overall, the chart is better for generating income through career, initiative and networks than for effortless accumulation. Wealth is most plausibly built through disciplined, long-term management rather than speculation or reliance on smooth windfalls.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The proposed exception is not applicable here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart and stated rule, so 'none' is incorrect.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh lord is Venus. This supports only the listed challenging polarity, not certainty of divorce."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The proposed exception is not applicable here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart and stated rule, so 'none' is incorrect.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh lord is Venus. This supports only the listed challenging polarity, not certainty of divorce.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The claimed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart: Saturn is in the seventh and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option A applies. The assessment is limited to the polarity of the listed indication and does not determine the overall marital outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The claimed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart: Saturn is in the seventh and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option A applies. The assessment is limited to the polarity of the listed indication and does not determine the overall marital outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-02","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-02","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"A clear dhana combination exists: the 11th lord Sun joins the 9th lord Mercury in the ascendant, linking gains and fortune to personal initiative, intellect, communication, and visibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/2","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The wealth-producing combination is qualified because the Sun is debilitated and Mercury is combust, so gains may require sustained effort and may not manifest uniformly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/dignity","/placements/Mercury/combust","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 11th house is a major support for income, networks, and fulfillment of material objectives; it is in a friendly sign.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"The 11th house is nevertheless pressured by Mars and Saturn, indicating uneven gains, delays, obligations, or conflict around income and networks alongside its strong potential.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Saturn"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house of accumulated wealth contains Saturn and debilitated Rahu and receives Ketu's aspect, making savings, family resources, and financial stability a principal area of strain or volatility.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/2/occupants","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/houses/2/aspectedBy","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn is simultaneously a functional wealth-supporting yogakaraka because it rules both the 4th and 5th houses, but its placement with Rahu in the 2nd makes results more delayed, burdened, or unconventional.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Mars occupies the 5th house, connecting accumulated wealth with intelligence, enterprise, creativity, or speculation; Jupiter's aspect supports this placement, while Mars's natural volatility advises caution with risk-taking.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/houses/5/aspectedBy","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Moon is strong in its own sign in the 10th house, supporting career capacity, public standing, and the ability to generate income through sustained professional activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th, increasing the likelihood that income is accompanied by substantial expenditure, foreign or institutional commitments, or difficulty retaining resources.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/12/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus, as 8th lord in the 12th, forms a listed vipareeta raja yoga, suggesting some capacity to recover or derive advantage through adverse, hidden, foreign, or transformative circumstances, though this does not cancel expenditure risk.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/3","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Career divisional support is present through Moon in the D10 10th and Venus in its own sign in the D10 3rd, favoring professional visibility and self-directed skills; D10 Saturn, Rahu, and Mars in the 7th indicate that partnerships or public dealings can also create pressure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/1","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/2","/vargas/D10/placements/6","/vargas/D10/placements/7"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart is not provided; therefore, a dedicated divisional assessment of wealth accumulation cannot be made.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used."],"rationale":"The chart has substantial earning potential from Jupiter in the 11th, a 9th–11th lord dhana yoga in the ascendant, and a strong 10th lord Moon. Accumulation is less secure than earning capacity because the 2nd house is heavily afflicted, the 11th receives malefic pressure, and debilitated ascendant lord Venus occupies the expenditure-oriented 12th. Yogakaraka Saturn and the vipareeta pattern provide resilience but operate through delay, responsibility, or adversity. Overall, wealth prospects are mixed: potentially good income and recovery capacity, but irregular gains, significant outflow, and the need for disciplined saving and conservative risk management."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-02\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"A clear dhana combination exists: the 11th lord Sun joins the 9th lord Mercury in the ascendant, linking gains and fortune to personal initiative, intellect, communication, and visibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/2\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The wealth-producing combination is qualified because the Sun is debilitated and Mercury is combust, so gains may require sustained effort and may not manifest uniformly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 11th house is a major support for income, networks, and fulfillment of material objectives; it is in a friendly sign.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th house is nevertheless pressured by Mars and Saturn, indicating uneven gains, delays, obligations, or conflict around income and networks alongside its strong potential.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Saturn\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house of accumulated wealth contains Saturn and debilitated Rahu and receives Ketu's aspect, making savings, family resources, and financial stability a principal area of strain or volatility.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/occupants\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn is simultaneously a functional wealth-supporting yogakaraka because it rules both the 4th and 5th houses, but its placement with Rahu in the 2nd makes results more delayed, burdened, or unconventional.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Mars occupies the 5th house, connecting accumulated wealth with intelligence, enterprise, creativity, or speculation; Jupiter's aspect supports this placement, while Mars's natural volatility advises caution with risk-taking.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Moon is strong in its own sign in the 10th house, supporting career capacity, public standing, and the ability to generate income through sustained professional activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Venus is debilitated in the 12th, increasing the likelihood that income is accompanied by substantial expenditure, foreign or institutional commitments, or difficulty retaining resources.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/12/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, as 8th lord in the 12th, forms a listed vipareeta raja yoga, suggesting some capacity to recover or derive advantage through adverse, hidden, foreign, or transformative circumstances, though this does not cancel expenditure risk.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/3\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career divisional support is present through Moon in the D10 10th and Venus in its own sign in the D10 3rd, favoring professional visibility and self-directed skills; D10 Saturn, Rahu, and Mars in the 7th indicate that partnerships or public dealings can also create pressure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/1\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart is not provided; therefore, a dedicated divisional assessment of wealth accumulation cannot be made.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart has substantial earning potential from Jupiter in the 11th, a 9th–11th lord dhana yoga in the ascendant, and a strong 10th lord Moon. Accumulation is less secure than earning capacity because the 2nd house is heavily afflicted, the 11th receives malefic pressure, and debilitated ascendant lord Venus occupies the expenditure-oriented 12th. Yogakaraka Saturn and the vipareeta pattern provide resilience but operate through delay, responsibility, or adversity. Overall, wealth prospects are mixed: potentially good income and recovery capacity, but irregular gains, significant outflow, and the need for disciplined saving and conservative risk management.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, strongly connecting accumulated resources with career, responsibility, and public standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, reinforcing professional capacity and the potential to build resources gradually through sustained work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, placing a benefic associated with calculation, speech, and commerce in the house of wealth; however, its combustion and retrogression qualify this support.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/retrograde"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house receives Jupiter's aspect, but Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 6th house, so its financial protection is not unqualified.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Ketu also aspects the 2nd house, indicating possible irregularity, detachment, or discontinuity in family resources and accumulation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house in friendly dignity, linking gains with initiative, skills, communication, or self-directed effort rather than effortless income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Venus also rules the 5th and is identified as a Raja Yoga planet, supporting earning capacity through career and applied intelligence.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because"]},{"claim":"Venus is placed with Rahu in the 12th house, creating a significant counterweight through expenditure, foreign or secluded environments, and possible fluctuations in financial priorities.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/occupants","/houses/11/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No wealth-specific divisional chart such as D2 Hora is supplied.","No Ashtakavarga, shadbala, or other quantified strength measures are supplied.","No specific date or financial event is given, so timing through dashas and transits is outside this assessment."],"rationale":"The chart contains substantial wealth-building support, especially the exalted 2nd lord Saturn in the 10th and the linkage of gains to personal effort. Nevertheless, afflicted or qualified influences on the 2nd house and the placement of career lord Venus with Rahu in the 12th indicate that accumulation may coexist with considerable expenditure or irregularity. The represented evidence therefore supports a mixed conclusion rather than an unconditional promise of wealth."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, strongly connecting accumulated resources with career, responsibility, and public standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, reinforcing professional capacity and the potential to build resources gradually through sustained work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, placing a benefic associated with calculation, speech, and commerce in the house of wealth; however, its combustion and retrogression qualify this support.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house receives Jupiter's aspect, but Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 6th house, so its financial protection is not unqualified.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu also aspects the 2nd house, indicating possible irregularity, detachment, or discontinuity in family resources and accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house in friendly dignity, linking gains with initiative, skills, communication, or self-directed effort rather than effortless income.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Venus also rules the 5th and is identified as a Raja Yoga planet, supporting earning capacity through career and applied intelligence.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus is placed with Rahu in the 12th house, creating a significant counterweight through expenditure, foreign or secluded environments, and possible fluctuations in financial priorities.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No wealth-specific divisional chart such as D2 Hora is supplied.\",\"No Ashtakavarga, shadbala, or other quantified strength measures are supplied.\",\"No specific date or financial event is given, so timing through dashas and transits is outside this assessment.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart contains substantial wealth-building support, especially the exalted 2nd lord Saturn in the 10th and the linkage of gains to personal effort. Nevertheless, afflicted or qualified influences on the 2nd house and the placement of career lord Venus with Rahu in the 12th indicate that accumulation may coexist with considerable expenditure or irregularity. The represented evidence therefore supports a mixed conclusion rather than an unconditional promise of wealth.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The claimed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh: the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh lord is Venus.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart and stated rule, so 'none' is not applicable.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart has Saturn in house 7. Aries ascendant is ruled by Mars, while the Libra seventh house is ruled by Venus; therefore Saturn rules neither relevant house. This matches A exactly. The listed statements alone give a challenging polarity, without establishing or guaranteeing divorce."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The claimed exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh: the ascendant lord is Mars and the seventh lord is Venus.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart and stated rule, so 'none' is not applicable.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart has Saturn in house 7. Aries ascendant is ruled by Mars, while the Libra seventh house is ruled by Venus; therefore Saturn rules neither relevant house. This matches A exactly. The listed statements alone give a challenging polarity, without establishing or guaranteeing divorce.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, strongly connecting accumulated wealth with career, authority, sustained work, and public standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn forms Sasa Yoga in the 10th, reinforcing professional capacity and the potential to build resources gradually through discipline and responsibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Mars occupies the 3rd house in friendly dignity, linking gains to personal initiative, communication, practical skills, enterprise, or sustained self-effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/2/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 10th house, further connecting the lord of gains with career and worldly action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, which can support resource management and earnings through analytical, commercial, or communicative abilities, but its combustion and retrogression qualify the result.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, offering benefic support to accumulated resources; however, Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and situated in the 6th, so this support may operate through service, obligations, debts, or problem-solving rather than effortless gains.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating a stated Raja Yoga and supporting prosperity through intelligence, creativity, merit, and career; its placement in the 12th simultaneously introduces expenditure, foreign, institutional, or behind-the-scenes themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus and Rahu occupy the 12th house, indicating that meaningful earnings may coexist with substantial expenses, foreign links, unconventional financial priorities, or periodic leakage of resources.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"The D10 places Venus in the 10th and Jupiter in its own sign in the 11th, supporting professional standing and gains from career, although divisional evidence alone does not guarantee accumulated wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No D2 Hora chart or other dedicated wealth divisional chart is provided.","No specific date or event window was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used.","No information about actual income, assets, debts, inheritances, or financial behavior is available for empirical corroboration."],"rationale":"The strongest indication is the exalted 2nd lord Saturn in the 10th, supported by Sasa Yoga, which favors gradual wealth accumulation through career, authority, persistence, and structured effort. The 11th lord Mars also links gains with initiative and aspects the 10th. These are substantial supportive factors. Results are moderated by Venus—the 5th and 10th lord—occupying the 12th with Rahu, plus qualified conditions affecting Mercury and Jupiter. The chart therefore supports wealth-building capacity, especially through sustained professional effort, but also indicates significant expenditure or resource outflow. It does not justify a guarantee of financial abundance."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th house, strongly connecting accumulated wealth with career, authority, sustained work, and public standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn forms Sasa Yoga in the 10th, reinforcing professional capacity and the potential to build resources gradually through discipline and responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Mars occupies the 3rd house in friendly dignity, linking gains to personal initiative, communication, practical skills, enterprise, or sustained self-effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/2/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 10th house, further connecting the lord of gains with career and worldly action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, which can support resource management and earnings through analytical, commercial, or communicative abilities, but its combustion and retrogression qualify the result.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, offering benefic support to accumulated resources; however, Jupiter is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and situated in the 6th, so this support may operate through service, obligations, debts, or problem-solving rather than effortless gains.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, creating a stated Raja Yoga and supporting prosperity through intelligence, creativity, merit, and career; its placement in the 12th simultaneously introduces expenditure, foreign, institutional, or behind-the-scenes themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus and Rahu occupy the 12th house, indicating that meaningful earnings may coexist with substantial expenses, foreign links, unconventional financial priorities, or periodic leakage of resources.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 places Venus in the 10th and Jupiter in its own sign in the 11th, supporting professional standing and gains from career, although divisional evidence alone does not guarantee accumulated wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No D2 Hora chart or other dedicated wealth divisional chart is provided.\",\"No specific date or event window was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used.\",\"No information about actual income, assets, debts, inheritances, or financial behavior is available for empirical corroboration.\"],\"rationale\":\"The strongest indication is the exalted 2nd lord Saturn in the 10th, supported by Sasa Yoga, which favors gradual wealth accumulation through career, authority, persistence, and structured effort. The 11th lord Mars also links gains with initiative and aspects the 10th. These are substantial supportive factors. Results are moderated by Venus—the 5th and 10th lord—occupying the 12th with Rahu, plus qualified conditions affecting Mercury and Jupiter. The chart therefore supports wealth-building capacity, especially through sustained professional effort, but also indicates significant expenditure or resource outflow. It does not justify a guarantee of financial abundance.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The proposed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by Saturn's seventh-house placement and its lack of lordship over either the ascendant or seventh house.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while Mars and Venus rule the ascendant and seventh respectively. This supports the listed challenging polarity but not a certain outcome such as divorce."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh is a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The proposed exception does not apply when Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh; here Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by Saturn's seventh-house placement and its lack of lordship over either the ascendant or seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while Mars and Venus rule the ascendant and seventh respectively. This supports the listed challenging polarity but not a certain outcome such as divorce.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house in Libra.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/sign"]},{"claim":"Saturn rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house: Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh, while Saturn rules houses 10 and 11.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord","/houses/10/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated exception does not apply because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord","/houses/9/lord","/houses/10/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A applies: Saturn is in the seventh house, while Mars and Venus—not Saturn—rule the ascendant and seventh respectively. Because the requested polarity must derive only from the applicable listed statements, the conclusion is challenging. Exaltation or other mitigating chart factors are not used to reverse that rule-specific classification."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house in Libra.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn rules neither the Aries ascendant nor the Libra seventh house: Mars rules the ascendant and Venus rules the seventh, while Saturn rules houses 10 and 11.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as a challenging indication under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated exception does not apply because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/10/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart, so the none-of-the-above option is inapplicable.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies: Saturn is in the seventh house, while Mars and Venus—not Saturn—rule the ascendant and seventh respectively. Because the requested polarity must derive only from the applicable listed statements, the conclusion is challenging. Exaltation or other mitigating chart factors are not used to reverse that rule-specific classification.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-03","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-03","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd house of accumulated resources is ruled by Saturn, which is exalted in the 10th house; this supports wealth building through sustained career, responsibility, and public activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, reinforcing professional authority and long-term material capacity, though it does not by itself guarantee wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, supporting the relevance of speech, calculation, commerce, or intellectual skills to resources; however, its retrograde and combust conditions make this indication less straightforward.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, offering a supportive influence on accumulated resources, but natal Jupiter itself is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 6th house, so the benefit is qualified by service, debt, disputes, or obligations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter/0","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"Ketu also aspects the 2nd house, introducing possible detachment, irregularity, or discontinuity around savings and family resources.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu/0","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house, connecting gains with personal initiative, communication, technical skill, enterprise, or persistent self-effort rather than effortless income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mars/house","/reference/houseSignifications/3","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, forming the stated Raja Yoga, but it occupies the 12th house with Rahu. This combines career and creative potential with substantial expenditure, foreign connections, isolation, or fluctuating material priorities.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/11/occupants","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"The Dashamsa places Venus in the 10th and Jupiter in its own sign Pisces in the 11th, supporting professional standing and career-derived gains, although the Dashamsa is primarily a career chart rather than a complete wealth assessment.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/meaning"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart, which is specifically relevant to wealth assessment, is not provided.","No financial history or defined time horizon is supplied, so natal potential cannot be tied to a particular wealth event or period.","Asset, inheritance, debt, and income-source details are unavailable for empirical corroboration."],"rationale":"The chart supports meaningful capacity for gradual wealth accumulation, especially through career and sustained personal effort: the 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th, and the career chart contains supportive 10th- and 11th-house placements. Nevertheless, Mercury's afflictions in the 2nd, Ketu's influence there, Jupiter's qualified condition, and the 5th/10th lord Venus occupying the 12th with Rahu indicate expenses, irregularities, or complex trade-offs. The supported evidence therefore favors a mixed conclusion rather than either strong affluence or categorical financial difficulty."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-03\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house of accumulated resources is ruled by Saturn, which is exalted in the 10th house; this supports wealth building through sustained career, responsibility, and public activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Saturn in a kendra forms Sasa Yoga, reinforcing professional authority and long-term material capacity, though it does not by itself guarantee wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury occupies the 2nd house, supporting the relevance of speech, calculation, commerce, or intellectual skills to resources; however, its retrograde and combust conditions make this indication less straightforward.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 2nd house, offering a supportive influence on accumulated resources, but natal Jupiter itself is retrograde, in enemy dignity, and placed in the 6th house, so the benefit is qualified by service, debt, disputes, or obligations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter/0\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu also aspects the 2nd house, introducing possible detachment, irregularity, or discontinuity around savings and family resources.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu/0\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Mars is placed in the 3rd house, connecting gains with personal initiative, communication, technical skill, enterprise, or persistent self-effort rather than effortless income.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/3\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus rules both the 5th and 10th houses, forming the stated Raja Yoga, but it occupies the 12th house with Rahu. This combines career and creative potential with substantial expenditure, foreign connections, isolation, or fluctuating material priorities.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Dashamsa places Venus in the 10th and Jupiter in its own sign Pisces in the 11th, supporting professional standing and career-derived gains, although the Dashamsa is primarily a career chart rather than a complete wealth assessment.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/meaning\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart, which is specifically relevant to wealth assessment, is not provided.\",\"No financial history or defined time horizon is supplied, so natal potential cannot be tied to a particular wealth event or period.\",\"Asset, inheritance, debt, and income-source details are unavailable for empirical corroboration.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart supports meaningful capacity for gradual wealth accumulation, especially through career and sustained personal effort: the 2nd lord Saturn is exalted in the 10th, and the career chart contains supportive 10th- and 11th-house placements. Nevertheless, Mercury's afflictions in the 2nd, Ketu's influence there, Jupiter's qualified condition, and the 5th/10th lord Venus occupying the 12th with Rahu indicate expenses, irregularities, or complex trade-offs. The supported evidence therefore favors a mixed conclusion rather than either strong affluence or categorical financial difficulty.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"challenging","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The asserted exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house: those lords are Mars and Venus respectively.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established by the chart, so 'none' is incorrect.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/lagna/lord","/houses/6/lord"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while Mars rules the Aries ascendant and Venus rules the Libra seventh house. Therefore the stated rule assigns a challenging polarity, without supporting a guaranteed divorce or the claimed exception."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"challenging\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn occupies the seventh house and rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house; under the stated rule, this is a challenging indication for marital happiness.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Saturn in the seventh may be treated as challenging under the stated rule, but it does not guarantee divorce.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The asserted exception does not apply here because Saturn rules neither the ascendant nor the seventh house: those lords are Mars and Venus respectively.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established by the chart, so 'none' is incorrect.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. Saturn is in house 7, while Mars rules the Aries ascendant and Venus rules the Libra seventh house. Therefore the stated rule assigns a challenging polarity, without supporting a guaranteed divorce or the claimed exception.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th house is strongly activated by Sun and Mars, indicating that partnership is a prominent life arena, but one potentially marked by assertiveness, ego clashes, impatience, or conflict.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/6/significations"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, sudden changes, and deep transformation rather than straightforward stability.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, while the chart records a mutual-aspect Raja Yoga between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. This offers a meaningful protective and constructive influence, though Jupiter's natal debilitation limits an uncomplicated reading.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy/0","/yogas/1","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is unafflicted by combustion and occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting attraction, affection, and the possibility that romance plays a substantial role in partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/dignity","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, and that house receives Saturn and Ketu aspects. This can intensify attraction or produce unconventional relationship patterns while also bringing complications, discontinuity, caution, or delay in romantic matters.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The exalted retrograde Saturn in the 11th can support endurance, gradual fulfillment of desires, and gains through mature commitment, although its aspect upon the 5th may make romance feel serious, delayed, or duty-laden.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/retrograde","/aspects/Saturn","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The debilitated Moon in the 12th suggests emotional sensitivity, withdrawal, private distress, or difficulty expressing needs clearly, which may complicate intimacy unless handled consciously.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter is in Cancer, a sign traditionally favorable to Jupiter's strength, although its 12th-house position gives the benefit a private, sacrificial, foreign, or spiritually oriented expression.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"The Navamsa also places Sun in the 7th and Mars in the 8th, repeating themes of strong individuality within partnership and the need to manage conflict, pride, and difficult adjustments.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Mercury, the natal 7th lord, occupies the Navamsa ascendant, showing that partnership, communication, and negotiation are closely tied to the native's inner development and identity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/vargas/D9/placements/3/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No specific marriage date or forecast period was requested, so date-dependent dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.","The chart facts do not provide Shadbala, planetary avasthas, or detailed Navamsa aspects, so finer judgments about comparative strength cannot be made."],"rationale":"The chart supports relationship potential through Venus in the 5th, Jupiter's influence on the 7th lord, the recorded Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga, and constructive Navamsa placements for Venus and Jupiter. However, the 7th lord in the 8th, Sun and combust enemy-sign Mars in the 7th, Rahu's conjunction with Venus, nodal and Saturnine pressure on the 5th, and difficult Moon and Navamsa Mars placements point to substantial adjustment and conflict-management needs. Marriage is therefore not denied by the supplied facts, but its quality appears mixed: attraction and commitment potential coexist with volatility, emotional complexity, and transformative partnership experiences."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th house is strongly activated by Sun and Mars, indicating that partnership is a prominent life arena, but one potentially marked by assertiveness, ego clashes, impatience, or conflict.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/6/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, sudden changes, and deep transformation rather than straightforward stability.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, while the chart records a mutual-aspect Raja Yoga between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. This offers a meaningful protective and constructive influence, though Jupiter's natal debilitation limits an uncomplicated reading.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy/0\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is unafflicted by combustion and occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting attraction, affection, and the possibility that romance plays a substantial role in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, and that house receives Saturn and Ketu aspects. This can intensify attraction or produce unconventional relationship patterns while also bringing complications, discontinuity, caution, or delay in romantic matters.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exalted retrograde Saturn in the 11th can support endurance, gradual fulfillment of desires, and gains through mature commitment, although its aspect upon the 5th may make romance feel serious, delayed, or duty-laden.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/retrograde\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The debilitated Moon in the 12th suggests emotional sensitivity, withdrawal, private distress, or difficulty expressing needs clearly, which may complicate intimacy unless handled consciously.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting affection and relational goodwill, while Jupiter is in Cancer, a sign traditionally favorable to Jupiter's strength, although its 12th-house position gives the benefit a private, sacrificial, foreign, or spiritually oriented expression.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Navamsa also places Sun in the 7th and Mars in the 8th, repeating themes of strong individuality within partnership and the need to manage conflict, pride, and difficult adjustments.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, the natal 7th lord, occupies the Navamsa ascendant, showing that partnership, communication, and negotiation are closely tied to the native's inner development and identity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/3/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No specific marriage date or forecast period was requested, so date-dependent dasha and transit timing has not been assessed.\",\"The chart facts do not provide Shadbala, planetary avasthas, or detailed Navamsa aspects, so finer judgments about comparative strength cannot be made.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart supports relationship potential through Venus in the 5th, Jupiter's influence on the 7th lord, the recorded Jupiter–Mercury Raja Yoga, and constructive Navamsa placements for Venus and Jupiter. However, the 7th lord in the 8th, Sun and combust enemy-sign Mars in the 7th, Rahu's conjunction with Venus, nodal and Saturnine pressure on the 5th, and difficult Moon and Navamsa Mars placements point to substantial adjustment and conflict-management needs. Marriage is therefore not denied by the supplied facts, but its quality appears mixed: attraction and commitment potential coexist with volatility, emotional complexity, and transformative partnership experiences.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in an enemy sign, linking partnership with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, and periods of substantial transformation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity"]},{"claim":"Sun and Mars occupy the 7th house, and Mars is both combust and in an enemy sign. This can intensify pride, impatience, conflict, or competition within close partnerships unless communication is handled consciously.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, suggesting intermittent detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventional relationship dynamics, or difficulty sustaining ordinary expectations of partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Mercury, the 7th lord, and Jupiter, the lagna lord, mutually aspect one another. The chart explicitly identifies this as a raja-yoga relationship, providing a constructive link between the self and partnership despite their difficult house placements.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/yogas/1/grahas","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting romantic attraction, affection, and the desire to form relationships through personal choice or emotional connection.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu and receives influences from Saturn and Ketu. This mixes attraction with intensity, unconventional preferences, delay, uncertainty, or abrupt changes in romantic expectations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The Moon is debilitated in the 12th house, which may increase emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy sensitivities, and difficulty expressing needs consistently within a relationship.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house while Mars occupies the 8th, repeating themes of strong individuality, power negotiation, and the need for mature conflict management in marriage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus occupies the 5th house and Jupiter is placed in Cancer, offering counterweights of affection, shared values, generosity, and potential growth through relationship experience.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Saturn occupies the 11th house, indicating that durable gains, companionship, and fulfillment through marriage may develop gradually and benefit from patience and realistic expectations.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/6/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact marriage timing cannot be assessed without a specified date or period and corresponding dasha and transit analysis.","The supplied Navamsa facts do not include aspects, conjunctions, or computed strength measures, so those factors are not inferred."],"rationale":"Marriage is clearly promised as an important and transformative life area, but ease is not the dominant signature. The afflicted 7th house, the 7th lord in the 8th, Ketu's influence, and repeated Navamsa pressure indicate intensity, adjustment, and conflict-management requirements. These are moderated by the Jupiter–Mercury connection, Venus in the 5th in both D1 and D9, and supportive Navamsa placements. The overall indication is therefore mixed rather than a denial of marriage: relationships may be meaningful and growth-producing, but stability is more likely when communication, boundaries, emotional openness, and power dynamics are handled deliberately."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in an enemy sign, linking partnership with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, and periods of substantial transformation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun and Mars occupy the 7th house, and Mars is both combust and in an enemy sign. This can intensify pride, impatience, conflict, or competition within close partnerships unless communication is handled consciously.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house, suggesting intermittent detachment, dissatisfaction, unconventional relationship dynamics, or difficulty sustaining ordinary expectations of partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, the 7th lord, and Jupiter, the lagna lord, mutually aspect one another. The chart explicitly identifies this as a raja-yoga relationship, providing a constructive link between the self and partnership despite their difficult house placements.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/yogas/1/grahas\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the 5th house, supporting romantic attraction, affection, and the desire to form relationships through personal choice or emotional connection.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu and receives influences from Saturn and Ketu. This mixes attraction with intensity, unconventional preferences, delay, uncertainty, or abrupt changes in romantic expectations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is debilitated in the 12th house, which may increase emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy sensitivities, and difficulty expressing needs consistently within a relationship.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house while Mars occupies the 8th, repeating themes of strong individuality, power negotiation, and the need for mature conflict management in marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus occupies the 5th house and Jupiter is placed in Cancer, offering counterweights of affection, shared values, generosity, and potential growth through relationship experience.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Saturn occupies the 11th house, indicating that durable gains, companionship, and fulfillment through marriage may develop gradually and benefit from patience and realistic expectations.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact marriage timing cannot be assessed without a specified date or period and corresponding dasha and transit analysis.\",\"The supplied Navamsa facts do not include aspects, conjunctions, or computed strength measures, so those factors are not inferred.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is clearly promised as an important and transformative life area, but ease is not the dominant signature. The afflicted 7th house, the 7th lord in the 8th, Ketu's influence, and repeated Navamsa pressure indicate intensity, adjustment, and conflict-management requirements. These are moderated by the Jupiter–Mercury connection, Venus in the 5th in both D1 and D9, and supportive Navamsa placements. The overall indication is therefore mixed rather than a denial of marriage: relationships may be meaningful and growth-producing, but stability is more likely when communication, boundaries, emotional openness, and power dynamics are handled deliberately.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.86,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Partnership is a major life arena because the 7th house is occupied by both Sun and Mars, but this combination can also produce strong wills, competitiveness, impatience, or conflict that requires conscious management.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and has enemy dignity, indicating that marriage may involve periods of uncertainty, vulnerability, major adjustment, or transformation rather than proceeding entirely smoothly.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"Mercury, the 7th lord, and Jupiter, the ascendant lord, mutually aspect one another. This directly connects spouse and partnership matters with the native's life path and provides a constructive capacity for learning, negotiation, and recovery within relationships.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because","/yogas/1/grahas"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 8th house occupied by the 7th lord, offering some protection and scope for wisdom during marital transitions; however, Jupiter is debilitated, so this support may be inconsistent or require maturity to become effective.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the 7th house, which can correspond with detachment, unconventional expectations, intermittent distance, or dissatisfaction if emotional and practical needs are not made explicit.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Venus occupies the 5th house in neutral dignity, supporting attraction, romance, affection, and the wish to form relationships through personal choice or emotional connection.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/5"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu and that house receives Saturn and Ketu influences. This can intensify attraction or favor unusual relationship patterns, while also bringing complications, delay, ambivalence, or fluctuating romantic expectations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, Sun occupies the 7th house, reinforcing strong identity, pride, visibility, or authority themes within marriage. This can support a capable or prominent partner but may also create ego clashes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus occupies the 5th house, preserving a meaningful affectionate and romantic component in the deeper marriage chart.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/5/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Mars occupies the 8th house, suggesting that intimacy, shared resources, trust, and adaptation can become active pressure points requiring patience and transparent communication.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Jupiter is in Cancer, indicating substantial inner strength for Jupiterian qualities such as forgiveness, counsel, ethics, and restoration, although its 12th-house placement can connect those benefits with sacrifice, privacy, distance, or foreign circumstances.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No Ashtakavarga, Shadbala, or detailed planetary-strength measures are provided, limiting finer judgment of how strongly the supportive and challenging factors will manifest.","No specific event date or requested forecast window is supplied, so marriage timing is not assessed."],"rationale":"The chart supports marriage and meaningful attraction, particularly through Venus in the 5th, Navamsa Venus in the 5th, and the mutual relationship between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. Nevertheless, the 7th lord's placement in the 8th, Sun and Mars in the 7th, Ketu's aspect on the 7th, and Mars in the Navamsa 8th indicate that partnership is likely to demand substantial adjustment, emotional honesty, conflict management, and flexibility. The overall indication is therefore mixed rather than prohibitive: relationships can be significant and sustaining, but harmony is more likely to develop through maturity and deliberate communication than to arise effortlessly."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.86,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Partnership is a major life arena because the 7th house is occupied by both Sun and Mars, but this combination can also produce strong wills, competitiveness, impatience, or conflict that requires conscious management.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and has enemy dignity, indicating that marriage may involve periods of uncertainty, vulnerability, major adjustment, or transformation rather than proceeding entirely smoothly.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, the 7th lord, and Jupiter, the ascendant lord, mutually aspect one another. This directly connects spouse and partnership matters with the native's life path and provides a constructive capacity for learning, negotiation, and recovery within relationships.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/yogas/1/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 8th house occupied by the 7th lord, offering some protection and scope for wisdom during marital transitions; however, Jupiter is debilitated, so this support may be inconsistent or require maturity to become effective.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the 7th house, which can correspond with detachment, unconventional expectations, intermittent distance, or dissatisfaction if emotional and practical needs are not made explicit.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the 5th house in neutral dignity, supporting attraction, romance, affection, and the wish to form relationships through personal choice or emotional connection.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu and that house receives Saturn and Ketu influences. This can intensify attraction or favor unusual relationship patterns, while also bringing complications, delay, ambivalence, or fluctuating romantic expectations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, Sun occupies the 7th house, reinforcing strong identity, pride, visibility, or authority themes within marriage. This can support a capable or prominent partner but may also create ego clashes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus occupies the 5th house, preserving a meaningful affectionate and romantic component in the deeper marriage chart.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Mars occupies the 8th house, suggesting that intimacy, shared resources, trust, and adaptation can become active pressure points requiring patience and transparent communication.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Jupiter is in Cancer, indicating substantial inner strength for Jupiterian qualities such as forgiveness, counsel, ethics, and restoration, although its 12th-house placement can connect those benefits with sacrifice, privacy, distance, or foreign circumstances.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No Ashtakavarga, Shadbala, or detailed planetary-strength measures are provided, limiting finer judgment of how strongly the supportive and challenging factors will manifest.\",\"No specific event date or requested forecast window is supplied, so marriage timing is not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart supports marriage and meaningful attraction, particularly through Venus in the 5th, Navamsa Venus in the 5th, and the mutual relationship between the ascendant lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. Nevertheless, the 7th lord's placement in the 8th, Sun and Mars in the 7th, Ketu's aspect on the 7th, and Mars in the Navamsa 8th indicate that partnership is likely to demand substantial adjustment, emotional honesty, conflict management, and flexibility. The overall indication is therefore mixed rather than prohibitive: relationships can be significant and sustaining, but harmony is more likely to develop through maturity and deliberate communication than to arise effortlessly.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":1,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, so none of the statements concerning Saturn in the seventh applies.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Options A-C all require Saturn to be in the seventh house, whereas the computed chart fact places Saturn in the eighth house. Therefore D is the only applicable option, and the polarity of the applicable listed statements is insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":1.0,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, so none of the statements concerning Saturn in the seventh applies.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Options A-C all require Saturn to be in the seventh house, whereas the computed chart fact places Saturn in the eighth house. Therefore D is the only applicable option, and the polarity of the applicable listed statements is insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, so none of the listed rules concerning Saturn in the seventh applies.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Options A-C all require Saturn to occupy the seventh house, but the computed chart states that Saturn is in house 8. Therefore D is the only applicable option, and the polarity of the applicable listed statements is insufficient rather than supportive or challenging."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, so none of the listed rules concerning Saturn in the seventh applies.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Options A-C all require Saturn to occupy the seventh house, but the computed chart states that Saturn is in house 8. Therefore D is the only applicable option, and the polarity of the applicable listed statements is insufficient rather than supportive or challenging.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":1,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"Saturn is in the eighth house, so none of the listed rules concerning Saturn in the seventh applies to this chart.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, not the seventh; therefore this statement is not applicable.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"factual","correction":"The chart does not establish Saturn in the seventh; moreover, the claim of wholly beneficial effects is not established here.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The chart does not establish Saturn in the seventh; additionally, a necessary marital ending would be an unsupported certainty.","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only Saturn's eighth-house placement is provided. Because statements A-C are all conditional on Saturn occupying the seventh house, none applies. Option D is therefore selected, and the polarity is insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":1.0,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Saturn is in the eighth house, so none of the listed rules concerning Saturn in the seventh applies to this chart.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The chart places Saturn in the eighth house, not the seventh; therefore this statement is not applicable.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The chart does not establish Saturn in the seventh; moreover, the claim of wholly beneficial effects is not established here.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The chart does not establish Saturn in the seventh; additionally, a necessary marital ending would be an unsupported certainty.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only Saturn's eighth-house placement is provided. Because statements A-C are all conditional on Saturn occupying the seventh house, none applies. Option D is therefore selected, and the polarity is insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The natal 7th house is strongly activated but afflicted: it contains the Sun and Mars, while Ketu aspects it. This can produce attraction and initiative alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periodic detachment in partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants/0","/houses/6/occupants/1","/houses/6/aspectedBy/0","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in an enemy sign, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, sudden changes, and transformation rather than an entirely smooth partnership path.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 7th, mutually aspects Jupiter, lord of the ascendant. This directly connects self and spouse and is explicitly identified as a raja-yoga configuration, providing resilience and constructive potential despite the 7th-lord placement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1/grahas/0","/yogas/1/grahas/1","/yogas/1/because","/houses/0/lord","/houses/6/lord"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, offering some protection and capacity for counsel, reconciliation, and growth through difficult marital transitions; however, natal Jupiter is debilitated, so that protection is qualified rather than unambiguous.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter/1","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is benefic, non-combust, and placed in the 5th house, supporting affection, romance, and the desire to form an emotional bond. Its conjunction by house with Rahu and aspects from Saturn and Ketu make romantic expectations or attachment patterns less conventional and potentially unstable.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus placed in the 5th and aspecting the 11th can connect romance with fulfillment of desires and social gains, although Saturn–Ketu occupying the 11th may delay satisfaction or produce selective, changing networks.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Venus/0","/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house, reinforcing a proud, visible, independent, or authority-oriented tone in marriage. Conscious management of status and ego dynamics is therefore important.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Venus is in the 5th house in Sagittarius, supporting affection, shared values, creativity, and the possibility that marriage develops through genuine liking or a common philosophy.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Mars in the 8th and Jupiter in the 12th repeat themes of deep adjustment, intimacy, shared-resource sensitivity, sacrifice, distance, or private burdens within marriage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/2/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha"]},{"claim":"Navamsa Saturn, lord of the Aquarius 7th house, is placed in the 11th. This can connect partnership with long-term goals, friendship, and gains, while Saturnian symbolism favors maturity and sustained effort over haste.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house","/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/graha"]},{"claim":"The current Ketu–Mercury period activates both Ketu's natal influence on the 7th and Mercury's role as 7th lord, making partnership issues prominent but potentially unsettled through 2026-07-29.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/mahadasha/to","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/to","/houses/6/aspectedBy/0","/houses/6/lord"]},{"claim":"The Venus mahadasha beginning 2026-07-29 activates the natural marriage significator and natal 5th-house Venus, creating a comparatively more relationship-oriented period, but the Rahu conjunction and nodal/Saturn influences prevent treating it as a guarantee of marriage.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0/from","/dasha/upcoming/0/to","/dasha/upcoming/0/path","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.","Navamsa aspects and explicit divisional-chart dignities are not supplied.","No specific event date or proposed marriage window was requested, so date-specific transit and pratyantardasha analysis was not performed."],"rationale":"The chart has genuine marriage capacity: the ascendant and 7th lords are mutually connected, Venus receives a favorable 5th-house placement, and Navamsa Venus and the Navamsa 7th lord provide constructive indications. These are counterbalanced by substantial stress: Sun–Mars and Ketu affect the natal 7th, the 7th lord occupies the 8th, and the Navamsa repeats 7th-, 8th-, and 12th-house adjustment themes. The synthesis is therefore mixed rather than marriage-denying: partnership is plausible and can become meaningful, but it is likely to require maturity, transparent communication, management of pride and anger, and careful handling of intimacy and shared resources. The Venus period from mid-2026 is comparatively supportive for relationship development, without ensuring a specific outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The natal 7th house is strongly activated but afflicted: it contains the Sun and Mars, while Ketu aspects it. This can produce attraction and initiative alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periodic detachment in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants/0\",\"/houses/6/occupants/1\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy/0\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in an enemy sign, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, sudden changes, and transformation rather than an entirely smooth partnership path.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 7th, mutually aspects Jupiter, lord of the ascendant. This directly connects self and spouse and is explicitly identified as a raja-yoga configuration, providing resilience and constructive potential despite the 7th-lord placement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/grahas/0\",\"/yogas/1/grahas/1\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects Mercury in the 8th, offering some protection and capacity for counsel, reconciliation, and growth through difficult marital transitions; however, natal Jupiter is debilitated, so that protection is qualified rather than unambiguous.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter/1\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is benefic, non-combust, and placed in the 5th house, supporting affection, romance, and the desire to form an emotional bond. Its conjunction by house with Rahu and aspects from Saturn and Ketu make romantic expectations or attachment patterns less conventional and potentially unstable.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus placed in the 5th and aspecting the 11th can connect romance with fulfillment of desires and social gains, although Saturn–Ketu occupying the 11th may delay satisfaction or produce selective, changing networks.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Venus/0\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the Navamsa, the Sun occupies the 7th house, reinforcing a proud, visible, independent, or authority-oriented tone in marriage. Conscious management of status and ego dynamics is therefore important.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Venus is in the 5th house in Sagittarius, supporting affection, shared values, creativity, and the possibility that marriage develops through genuine liking or a common philosophy.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Mars in the 8th and Jupiter in the 12th repeat themes of deep adjustment, intimacy, shared-resource sensitivity, sacrifice, distance, or private burdens within marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"Navamsa Saturn, lord of the Aquarius 7th house, is placed in the 11th. This can connect partnership with long-term goals, friendship, and gains, while Saturnian symbolism favors maturity and sustained effort over haste.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"The current Ketu–Mercury period activates both Ketu's natal influence on the 7th and Mercury's role as 7th lord, making partnership issues prominent but potentially unsettled through 2026-07-29.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/to\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/to\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy/0\",\"/houses/6/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Venus mahadasha beginning 2026-07-29 activates the natural marriage significator and natal 5th-house Venus, creating a comparatively more relationship-oriented period, but the Rahu conjunction and nodal/Saturn influences prevent treating it as a guarantee of marriage.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0/from\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0/to\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0/path\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not supplied.\",\"Navamsa aspects and explicit divisional-chart dignities are not supplied.\",\"No specific event date or proposed marriage window was requested, so date-specific transit and pratyantardasha analysis was not performed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart has genuine marriage capacity: the ascendant and 7th lords are mutually connected, Venus receives a favorable 5th-house placement, and Navamsa Venus and the Navamsa 7th lord provide constructive indications. These are counterbalanced by substantial stress: Sun–Mars and Ketu affect the natal 7th, the 7th lord occupies the 8th, and the Navamsa repeats 7th-, 8th-, and 12th-house adjustment themes. The synthesis is therefore mixed rather than marriage-denying: partnership is plausible and can become meaningful, but it is likely to require maturity, transparent communication, management of pride and anger, and careful handling of intimacy and shared resources. The Venus period from mid-2026 is comparatively supportive for relationship development, without ensuring a specific outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The marriage house is strongly activated but afflicted: the 7th house contains Sun and Mars, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate attraction and initiative alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periodic detachment in partnership.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, and transformative or unsettled phases rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"Mercury and lagna lord Jupiter mutually aspect one another, forming the listed Raja Yoga involving the lords of houses 1 and 7. This provides a meaningful protective factor through communication, judgment, and capacity to rebuild cooperation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/1/grahas","/yogas/1/because","/aspects/Mercury","/aspects/Jupiter","/lagna/lord"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, the lagna lord and natural source of counsel, is debilitated in the 2nd house. Its connection with Mercury helps, but reduced dignity can weaken consistency in family integration, values, or wise handling of marital issues.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/1/significations","/lagna/lord"]},{"claim":"Venus occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting attraction, affection, and the desire for relationship; however, conjunction with Rahu and aspects from Saturn and Ketu make romantic expectations intense, unconventional, delayed, or intermittently dissatisfied.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/5"]},{"claim":"The Navamsa repeats substantial relationship pressure: Sun occupies the D9 7th, Mars occupies the 8th, and Jupiter occupies the 12th. These placements emphasize autonomy, adaptation, intimacy, sacrifice, and expenditure within married life.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/meaning"]},{"claim":"The D9 7th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, providing a constructive counterweight through long-term goals, friendship, networks, and gains developed over time; Saturn's symbolism nevertheless favors maturity and sustained effort over ease or speed.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/dispositor","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house"]},{"claim":"D9 Venus occupies the 5th house in Sagittarius, preserving affection, shared ideals, creativity, and goodwill as resources for sustaining partnership.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/4/house","/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign"]},{"claim":"As of 2026-01-01, Ketu–Mercury is operating. Ketu aspects the natal 7th and Mercury rules the 7th while occupying the 8th, so the current period is astrologically relevant to reassessment or transformation of relationship matters; it does not by itself guarantee marriage or separation.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha","/dasha/current/antardasha","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/houses/6/lord","/placements/Mercury/house","/transits/asOf"]},{"claim":"Venus mahadasha begins on 2026-07-29. Because natal Venus occupies the 5th house, this can increase emphasis on affection and relationship choices, but Venus's conjunction with Rahu and affliction of the 5th make outcomes dependent on discernment and the wider timing context.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/upcoming/0/from","/dasha/upcoming/0/path","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.","Darakaraka is not identified.","D9 aspects and explicit divisional dignities are not provided.","Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are not provided.","A specific relationship event or target date would be required for event-level timing."],"rationale":"The core D1 testimony is demanding: an afflicted 7th house and an 8th-house 7th lord indicate that partnership is likely to require substantial communication, emotional regulation, transparency, and adaptation. The Mercury–Jupiter mutual aspect and favorable D9 factors—especially the 7th lord in the 11th and Venus in the 5th—provide genuine capacity for durable companionship and growth. Because supportive and difficult indications coexist, the chart is best judged mixed rather than uniformly adverse: marriage is supported, but harmony is more likely through maturity and conscious conflict management than through effortless compatibility."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The marriage house is strongly activated but afflicted: the 7th house contains Sun and Mars, while Ketu aspects it. This can indicate attraction and initiative alongside ego clashes, impatience, conflict, or periodic detachment in partnership.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury occupies the 8th house in enemy dignity, linking marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, and transformative or unsettled phases rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury and lagna lord Jupiter mutually aspect one another, forming the listed Raja Yoga involving the lords of houses 1 and 7. This provides a meaningful protective factor through communication, judgment, and capacity to rebuild cooperation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/1/grahas\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/aspects/Mercury\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/lagna/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, the lagna lord and natural source of counsel, is debilitated in the 2nd house. Its connection with Mercury helps, but reduced dignity can weaken consistency in family integration, values, or wise handling of marital issues.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/1/significations\",\"/lagna/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus occupies the romantic 5th house, supporting attraction, affection, and the desire for relationship; however, conjunction with Rahu and aspects from Saturn and Ketu make romantic expectations intense, unconventional, delayed, or intermittently dissatisfied.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Navamsa repeats substantial relationship pressure: Sun occupies the D9 7th, Mars occupies the 8th, and Jupiter occupies the 12th. These placements emphasize autonomy, adaptation, intimacy, sacrifice, and expenditure within married life.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/meaning\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D9 7th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th house, providing a constructive counterweight through long-term goals, friendship, networks, and gains developed over time; Saturn's symbolism nevertheless favors maturity and sustained effort over ease or speed.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/dispositor\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D9 Venus occupies the 5th house in Sagittarius, preserving affection, shared ideals, creativity, and goodwill as resources for sustaining partnership.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/4/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"As of 2026-01-01, Ketu–Mercury is operating. Ketu aspects the natal 7th and Mercury rules the 7th while occupying the 8th, so the current period is astrologically relevant to reassessment or transformation of relationship matters; it does not by itself guarantee marriage or separation.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/transits/asOf\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus mahadasha begins on 2026-07-29. Because natal Venus occupies the 5th house, this can increase emphasis on affection and relationship choices, but Venus's conjunction with Rahu and affliction of the 5th make outcomes dependent on discernment and the wider timing context.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/upcoming/0/from\",\"/dasha/upcoming/0/path\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.\",\"Darakaraka is not identified.\",\"D9 aspects and explicit divisional dignities are not provided.\",\"Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures are not provided.\",\"A specific relationship event or target date would be required for event-level timing.\"],\"rationale\":\"The core D1 testimony is demanding: an afflicted 7th house and an 8th-house 7th lord indicate that partnership is likely to require substantial communication, emotional regulation, transparency, and adaptation. The Mercury–Jupiter mutual aspect and favorable D9 factors—especially the 7th lord in the 11th and Venus in the 5th—provide genuine capacity for durable companionship and growth. Because supportive and difficult indications coexist, the chart is best judged mixed rather than uniformly adverse: marriage is supported, but harmony is more likely through maturity and conscious conflict management than through effortless compatibility.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.87,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"A. The second lord, Venus, is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule this is treated as mixed over time—comparatively weaker health early and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is time-variable and does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This general placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus is the lord of the second house and is placed in the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the chart explicitly places Venus in the ninth house. Therefore A matches the stated placement rule. The indication is mixed rather than uniformly adverse and is too general to support diagnosis of a particular illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.87,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"A. The second lord, Venus, is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule this is treated as mixed over time—comparatively weaker health early and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is time-variable and does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This general placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus is the lord of the second house and is placed in the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"For Aries lagna, the second house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the chart explicitly places Venus in the ninth house. Therefore A matches the stated placement rule. The indication is mixed rather than uniformly adverse and is too general to support diagnosis of a particular illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.96,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house; under the stated rule, this is a mixed temporal indication—comparatively weaker health earlier and improvement later—rather than uniformly poor health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/house","/houses/8/occupants","/houses/1/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is temporally mixed and does not support uniformly poor lifelong health.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/houses/1/lord"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"A general lordship-placement rule does not diagnose a specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus, lord of the 2nd house, is in the 9th house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Aries lagna makes Venus the lord of the Taurus 2nd house, and Venus occupies the 9th. Applying only the listed rule gives the mixed polarity in A. It neither establishes uniformly poor health nor permits diagnosis of a particular illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.96,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house; under the stated rule, this is a mixed temporal indication—comparatively weaker health earlier and improvement later—rather than uniformly poor health.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/house\",\"/houses/8/occupants\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is temporally mixed and does not support uniformly poor lifelong health.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/1/lord\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"A general lordship-placement rule does not diagnose a specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus, lord of the 2nd house, is in the 9th house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Aries lagna makes Venus the lord of the Taurus 2nd house, and Venus occupies the 9th. Applying only the listed rule gives the mixed polarity in A. It neither establishes uniformly poor health nor permits diagnosis of a particular illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.91,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house; under the stated rule, this carries mixed polarity over time—comparatively weaker health early and improvement later—rather than uniformly poor health.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is temporally mixed and does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This lord-house placement is a broad astrological indication and cannot diagnose a specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A applies because Venus, lord of the 2nd house, is computed in the 9th house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"For Aries lagna, the 2nd house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the chart explicitly places Venus in the 9th house. Applying the stated interpretive rule supports A with mixed polarity. It neither supports lifelong uniformly poor health nor permits diagnosis of a particular illness."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.91,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house; under the stated rule, this carries mixed polarity over time—comparatively weaker health early and improvement later—rather than uniformly poor health.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is temporally mixed and does not indicate uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This lord-house placement is a broad astrological indication and cannot diagnose a specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A applies because Venus, lord of the 2nd house, is computed in the 9th house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"For Aries lagna, the 2nd house is Taurus and its lord is Venus; the chart explicitly places Venus in the 9th house. Applying the stated interpretive rule supports A with mixed polarity. It neither supports lifelong uniformly poor health nor permits diagnosis of a particular illness.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.97,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord is Venus, and it is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule this is treated as mixed over time—comparatively weaker health early and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule gives a changing pattern over time, not uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This general lord-placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart places the second lord Venus in the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A alone matches both the stated interpretive rule and the computed chart placement. The conclusion is therefore mixed, based strictly on the polarity of the applicable listed statement, without inferring or diagnosing a medical condition."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.97,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord is Venus, and it is placed in the ninth house; under the stated rule this is treated as mixed over time—comparatively weaker health early and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule gives a changing pattern over time, not uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This general lord-placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart places the second lord Venus in the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A alone matches both the stated interpretive rule and the computed chart placement. The conclusion is therefore mixed, based strictly on the polarity of the applicable listed statement, without inferring or diagnosing a medical condition.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"marriage","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The D1 partnership axis is significantly pressured: the 7th house contains Sun and Mars, Mars is combust and in enemy dignity, and Ketu aspects the 7th. This can manifest as strong attraction and assertive partners, but also ego clashes, impatience, detachment, or periodic conflict if communication is poor.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/combust","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and has enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, and major transformation rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"A major counterweight is the mutual relationship between lagna lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. The chart explicitly identifies their mutual aspect as a raja yoga, supporting the possibility that partnership contributes to growth and that difficulties can be negotiated constructively.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/yogas/1/grahas","/yogas/1/because","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Mercury/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter aspects the 8th house containing the 7th lord, providing some protective or moderating influence over marital crises and shared-life adjustments; however, natal Jupiter itself is debilitated, so this support is present but not uniformly strong.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/7/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is benefic, non-combust, and placed in the 5th house, supporting affection, romance, attraction, and the desire for companionship.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/house","/reference/houseSignifications/5"]},{"claim":"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. This can intensify attraction and produce unusual, highly idealized, delayed, or intermittently dissatisfied romantic patterns; discernment is therefore important before commitment.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/4/occupants","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The Moon is debilitated in the 12th house. In relationship matters this can indicate emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy-related sensitivity, or a need for substantial solitude, although it does not by itself deny marriage.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/dignity","/placements/Moon/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"The D9 provides meaningful support: Venus occupies the auspicious 5th house in Sagittarius, and the D9 7th lord Saturn—Aquarius being the 7th sign from Leo lagna—is placed in the 11th house. These placements favor affection, eventual gains through partnership, and durability when commitment is approached maturely.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D9/lagnaSign","/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/5/house","/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign","/vargas/D9/placements/6/house","/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign"]},{"claim":"The D9 7th house contains the Sun, while Mars occupies the D9 8th house. These repeat themes of pride, strong individuality, conflict potential, and transformative pressure within married life, so the D9 does not remove the D1 challenges.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D9/placements/0/house","/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha","/vargas/D9/placements/2/house","/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha"]},{"claim":"The chart contains no vargottama grahas, so there is no listed vargottama reinforcement for Venus, the 7th lord, or other marriage factors.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/vargottama"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.","Darakaraka and Jaimini relationship factors are not provided.","Shadbala and detailed planetary strength measures are not provided.","A specific marriage date or requested forecasting window is absent, so no event timing is assessed."],"rationale":"Marriage is indicated but not shown as effortless or uniformly stable. The principal difficulties are the afflicted D1 7th house, the 7th lord in the 8th, Rahu's association with Venus, and repeated Sun-Mars pressure in D1 and D9. Against this, benefic Venus in the 5th, Jupiter's aspect to the 7th lord, the explicit Jupiter-Mercury mutual-aspect yoga, D9 Venus in the 5th, and D9 7th lord Saturn in the 11th provide substantial capacity for attachment, endurance, and gains through partnership. The synthesis is therefore mixed: relationships may be intense and transformative, with better prospects when communication, emotional transparency, boundaries, and conflict management are handled deliberately."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"marriage-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"marriage\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The D1 partnership axis is significantly pressured: the 7th house contains Sun and Mars, Mars is combust and in enemy dignity, and Ketu aspects the 7th. This can manifest as strong attraction and assertive partners, but also ego clashes, impatience, detachment, or periodic conflict if communication is poor.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/combust\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 7th lord Mercury is placed in the 8th house and has enemy dignity, connecting marriage with adjustment, vulnerability, shared resources, secrecy, and major transformation rather than an uncomplicated partnership path.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"A major counterweight is the mutual relationship between lagna lord Jupiter and 7th lord Mercury. The chart explicitly identifies their mutual aspect as a raja yoga, supporting the possibility that partnership contributes to growth and that difficulties can be negotiated constructively.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/yogas/1/grahas\",\"/yogas/1/because\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter aspects the 8th house containing the 7th lord, providing some protective or moderating influence over marital crises and shared-life adjustments; however, natal Jupiter itself is debilitated, so this support is present but not uniformly strong.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the natural marriage significator, is benefic, non-combust, and placed in the 5th house, supporting affection, romance, attraction, and the desire for companionship.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus shares the 5th house with Rahu, while Saturn and Ketu aspect that house. This can intensify attraction and produce unusual, highly idealized, delayed, or intermittently dissatisfied romantic patterns; discernment is therefore important before commitment.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/occupants\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is debilitated in the 12th house. In relationship matters this can indicate emotional withdrawal, private distress, sleep or intimacy-related sensitivity, or a need for substantial solitude, although it does not by itself deny marriage.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D9 provides meaningful support: Venus occupies the auspicious 5th house in Sagittarius, and the D9 7th lord Saturn—Aquarius being the 7th sign from Leo lagna—is placed in the 11th house. These placements favor affection, eventual gains through partnership, and durability when commitment is approached maturely.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/lagnaSign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/5/sign\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/6/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D9 7th house contains the Sun, while Mars occupies the D9 8th house. These repeat themes of pride, strong individuality, conflict potential, and transformative pressure within married life, so the D9 does not remove the D1 challenges.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/0/graha\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/house\",\"/vargas/D9/placements/2/graha\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart contains no vargottama grahas, so there is no listed vargottama reinforcement for Venus, the 7th lord, or other marriage factors.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargottama\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Upapada Lagna and its lord are not provided.\",\"Darakaraka and Jaimini relationship factors are not provided.\",\"Shadbala and detailed planetary strength measures are not provided.\",\"A specific marriage date or requested forecasting window is absent, so no event timing is assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Marriage is indicated but not shown as effortless or uniformly stable. The principal difficulties are the afflicted D1 7th house, the 7th lord in the 8th, Rahu's association with Venus, and repeated Sun-Mars pressure in D1 and D9. Against this, benefic Venus in the 5th, Jupiter's aspect to the 7th lord, the explicit Jupiter-Mercury mutual-aspect yoga, D9 Venus in the 5th, and D9 7th lord Saturn in the 11th provide substantial capacity for attachment, endurance, and gains through partnership. The synthesis is therefore mixed: relationships may be intense and transformative, with better prospects when communication, emotional transparency, boundaries, and conflict management are handled deliberately.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house, so the stated rule applies and is interpreted as weaker health early and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule describes a mixed, time-dependent pattern rather than uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement-based rule does not diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because Venus, the 2nd lord, occupies the 9th house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"For Aries lagna, Taurus is the 2nd house and its lord is Venus; the computed house data places that lord in house 9. Therefore A is the applicable listed interpretation. The polarity is mixed because the statement combines an earlier challenge with later improvement. It is not a diagnosis or a claim of uniformly poor lifelong health."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Venus is placed in the 9th house, so the stated rule applies and is interpreted as weaker health early and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule describes a mixed, time-dependent pattern rather than uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement-based rule does not diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because Venus, the 2nd lord, occupies the 9th house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"For Aries lagna, Taurus is the 2nd house and its lord is Venus; the computed house data places that lord in house 9. Therefore A is the applicable listed interpretation. The polarity is mixed because the statement combines an earlier challenge with later improvement. It is not a diagnosis or a claim of uniformly poor lifelong health.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.97,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, so the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor health throughout life.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"This general lord-placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/significations","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the second lord Venus is in the ninth house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly identifies Venus as lord of the second house and places that lord in house 9. Therefore A is the applicable listed statement. Its polarity is mixed, while B improperly converts a time-varying rule into uniformly poor health and C exceeds the rule by claiming a specific diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.97,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The second lord Venus is placed in the ninth house, so the stated rule applies and gives a mixed temporal indication: weaker health earlier and better health later.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule is mixed over time, not an indication of uniformly poor health throughout life.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"This general lord-placement rule does not diagnose any specific illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/significations\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the second lord Venus is in the ninth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly identifies Venus as lord of the second house and places that lord in house 9. Therefore A is the applicable listed statement. Its polarity is mixed, while B improperly converts a time-varying rule into uniformly poor health and C exceeds the rule by claiming a specific diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant and its lord connect vitality with the gain-oriented 11th house, which can support persistence and recovery through sustained effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord Saturn is in an enemy sign and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu, indicating pressure, overexertion, or fluctuating resilience rather than uniformly easy vitality.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the first house of body and vitality, suggesting that health maintenance may require discipline, patience, and consistent routines.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn/0","/houses/0/significations"]},{"claim":"The Sun occupies the first house, providing a direct vitality emphasis, but its enemy dignity makes this support qualified rather than unambiguous.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/0/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the sixth house of disease and daily health burdens, occupies the first house. This directly links health management with the body, while Mercury's benefic status offers some capacity for practical adjustment and self-management.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the sixth house, indicating forceful engagement with obstacles but also the possibility that strain, conflict, or excessive intensity can aggravate health-related challenges.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars/2","/houses/5/significations","/placements/Mars/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a natural benefic in friendly dignity, occupies the eighth house of chronic matters and transformation; this can offer protection, insight, or recovery capacity amid difficult periods, although its eighth-house placement still highlights vulnerability to prolonged or complex health themes.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"The eighth house receives Saturn's aspect as well as the Moon's, reinforcing the possibility that chronic or recurring pressures may need long-term management.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/7/aspectedBy","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"The Moon is combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter in the second house. This suggests mixed support for emotional steadiness and nourishment-related habits, with both pressure and benefic moderation present.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"The chart records a Vipareeta Raja Yoga involving the twelfth lord Jupiter in the eighth, which traditionally suggests some capacity to obtain constructive outcomes through adversity, but it does not remove health vulnerabilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because","/placements/Jupiter/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 or D30 is not provided.","No specific health event, symptom history, or date was supplied, so dasha and transit timing cannot be assessed.","Astrological indicators cannot establish a medical diagnosis or replace clinical evaluation."],"rationale":"The natal picture is mixed. Protective elements include a benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity, strong Mars in its own sign, Mercury's benefic quality, and indications of resilience through adversity. Challenges arise because the ascendant lord is pressured by conjunction with Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the ascendant, the sixth lord occupies the first house, and the eighth house is emphasized. Overall, the chart favors disciplined, sustained health maintenance and may indicate resilience, but it does not support assuming effortless or uniformly stable vitality."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant and its lord connect vitality with the gain-oriented 11th house, which can support persistence and recovery through sustained effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Saturn is in an enemy sign and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu, indicating pressure, overexertion, or fluctuating resilience rather than uniformly easy vitality.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the first house of body and vitality, suggesting that health maintenance may require discipline, patience, and consistent routines.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn/0\",\"/houses/0/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the first house, providing a direct vitality emphasis, but its enemy dignity makes this support qualified rather than unambiguous.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/0/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the sixth house of disease and daily health burdens, occupies the first house. This directly links health management with the body, while Mercury's benefic status offers some capacity for practical adjustment and self-management.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the sixth house, indicating forceful engagement with obstacles but also the possibility that strain, conflict, or excessive intensity can aggravate health-related challenges.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars/2\",\"/houses/5/significations\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a natural benefic in friendly dignity, occupies the eighth house of chronic matters and transformation; this can offer protection, insight, or recovery capacity amid difficult periods, although its eighth-house placement still highlights vulnerability to prolonged or complex health themes.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The eighth house receives Saturn's aspect as well as the Moon's, reinforcing the possibility that chronic or recurring pressures may need long-term management.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter in the second house. This suggests mixed support for emotional steadiness and nourishment-related habits, with both pressure and benefic moderation present.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart records a Vipareeta Raja Yoga involving the twelfth lord Jupiter in the eighth, which traditionally suggests some capacity to obtain constructive outcomes through adversity, but it does not remove health vulnerabilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"A dedicated health divisional chart such as D6 or D30 is not provided.\",\"No specific health event, symptom history, or date was supplied, so dasha and transit timing cannot be assessed.\",\"Astrological indicators cannot establish a medical diagnosis or replace clinical evaluation.\"],\"rationale\":\"The natal picture is mixed. Protective elements include a benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity, strong Mars in its own sign, Mercury's benefic quality, and indications of resilience through adversity. Challenges arise because the ascendant lord is pressured by conjunction with Mars and Rahu, Saturn aspects the ascendant, the sixth lord occupies the first house, and the eighth house is emphasized. Overall, the chart favors disciplined, sustained health maintenance and may indicate resilience, but it does not support assuming effortless or uniformly stable vitality.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.78,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Saturn occupies the gain-oriented 11th house, supporting persistence and the capacity to improve through sustained routines and assistance from networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn, as ascendant lord, is in enemy dignity and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu; this creates mixed indications around resilience, with pressure, overexertion, or irregular habits potentially undermining otherwise strong endurance.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The Sun occupies the 1st house, which can reinforce vitality and personal drive, although its enemy dignity makes that support uneven rather than unqualified.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/0/significations"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house, directly connecting disease, service, and daily-routine matters with the body; this can indicate recurring health management needs, while Mercury's benefic status and lack of combustion provide some capacity for practical self-management.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding force and fighting capacity but also a tendency toward inflammatory, acute, or overexertion-type astrological themes; this is a general Jyotish indication, not a medical diagnosis.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars/2","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th house in friendly dignity, which can support recovery, adaptation, and constructive response to chronic or transformative periods, though its retrograde condition and dusthana placement make results less straightforward.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/reference/dusthanas"]},{"claim":"The 8th house receives Saturn's aspect in addition to containing Jupiter, combining protective benefic influence with Saturnine pressure and suggesting that resilience may develop through disciplined, long-term management rather than effortless robustness.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/aspects/Saturn/2"]},{"claim":"The Moon is combust in the 2nd house and receives aspects from both Mars and Jupiter, giving mixed indications for emotional steadiness, nourishment, and habitual regulation: Mars can add strain while Jupiter can moderate it.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Exalted Venus provides a notable supportive influence. As lord of both the 5th and 10th houses for Capricorn lagna, its strength can indirectly assist balance, restorative habits, and overall functional stability.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/yogas/3/because"]},{"claim":"The 1st house is aspected by both Saturn and Ketu, adding restraint, sensitivity, or fluctuating vitality to the constitution and reinforcing the need for consistent rather than extreme routines.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/houses/0/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Health-specific divisional charts such as D6 or D30 are not provided.","Quantitative planetary-strength measures such as Shadbala are not provided.","No specific symptom, diagnosis, medical history, or target date was supplied, so this is a general natal synthesis rather than medical or time-specific guidance."],"rationale":"The chart presents meaningful resilience alongside recurring pressure on the constitution. Support comes from the ascendant lord's placement in the 11th, the Sun in the ascendant, friendly-dignity benefic Jupiter in the 8th, and especially exalted Venus. Challenges arise because the ascendant lord is in enemy dignity and associated with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord is tied directly to the 1st house, Mars influences the 6th, and Saturn and Ketu influence the ascendant. Overall, the indications are mixed: the chart suggests capacity for persistence and recovery, but benefits most from disciplined, moderate, and consistent health maintenance. These are astrological themes and should not substitute for professional medical evaluation."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.78,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Saturn occupies the gain-oriented 11th house, supporting persistence and the capacity to improve through sustained routines and assistance from networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn, as ascendant lord, is in enemy dignity and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu; this creates mixed indications around resilience, with pressure, overexertion, or irregular habits potentially undermining otherwise strong endurance.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the 1st house, which can reinforce vitality and personal drive, although its enemy dignity makes that support uneven rather than unqualified.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/0/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house, directly connecting disease, service, and daily-routine matters with the body; this can indicate recurring health management needs, while Mercury's benefic status and lack of combustion provide some capacity for practical self-management.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, adding force and fighting capacity but also a tendency toward inflammatory, acute, or overexertion-type astrological themes; this is a general Jyotish indication, not a medical diagnosis.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars/2\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a natural benefic, occupies the 8th house in friendly dignity, which can support recovery, adaptation, and constructive response to chronic or transformative periods, though its retrograde condition and dusthana placement make results less straightforward.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/reference/dusthanas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house receives Saturn's aspect in addition to containing Jupiter, combining protective benefic influence with Saturnine pressure and suggesting that resilience may develop through disciplined, long-term management rather than effortless robustness.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Saturn/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is combust in the 2nd house and receives aspects from both Mars and Jupiter, giving mixed indications for emotional steadiness, nourishment, and habitual regulation: Mars can add strain while Jupiter can moderate it.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Venus provides a notable supportive influence. As lord of both the 5th and 10th houses for Capricorn lagna, its strength can indirectly assist balance, restorative habits, and overall functional stability.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/yogas/3/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 1st house is aspected by both Saturn and Ketu, adding restraint, sensitivity, or fluctuating vitality to the constitution and reinforcing the need for consistent rather than extreme routines.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/0/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Health-specific divisional charts such as D6 or D30 are not provided.\",\"Quantitative planetary-strength measures such as Shadbala are not provided.\",\"No specific symptom, diagnosis, medical history, or target date was supplied, so this is a general natal synthesis rather than medical or time-specific guidance.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart presents meaningful resilience alongside recurring pressure on the constitution. Support comes from the ascendant lord's placement in the 11th, the Sun in the ascendant, friendly-dignity benefic Jupiter in the 8th, and especially exalted Venus. Challenges arise because the ascendant lord is in enemy dignity and associated with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord is tied directly to the 1st house, Mars influences the 6th, and Saturn and Ketu influence the ascendant. Overall, the indications are mixed: the chart suggests capacity for persistence and recovery, but benefits most from disciplined, moderate, and consistent health maintenance. These are astrological themes and should not substitute for professional medical evaluation.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Saturn occupies the 11th house, an upachaya associated with gradual development, suggesting resilience may strengthen through sustained discipline and consistent routines.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the 1st house while being in enemy dignity and joined by Mars and Rahu, indicating pressure on vitality and a tendency for strain to accumulate when demands are prolonged.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"The Sun occupies the 1st house but is in enemy dignity, giving some direct emphasis to vitality while making its expression uneven rather than uniformly protective.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 6th house of disease and daily health management, is placed in the 1st house. This closely links health with habits, workload, mental activity, and self-management; Mercury's benefic status offers some capacity to understand and manage difficulties.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house from its own sign in the 11th. Its strength can support resistance and active problem-solving, but its malefic nature also suggests inflammatory, conflict-driven, or overexertion-type stress in general astrological terms.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, a natural benefic, aspects the 2nd house connected with food and nourishment, offering a protective influence over dietary resources and recovery support.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/aspects/Jupiter","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde in the 8th house and receives Saturn's aspect, emphasizing chronic or recurring health-management themes and the need for patience rather than implying a specific condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/houses/7/significations"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a benefic influence connected with emotional regulation, occupies the 2nd house and receives Jupiter's aspect, which can support nourishment and recuperative capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The Moon is marked combust and also receives Mars's aspect, suggesting that emotional agitation, irregular nourishment, or stress-reactive habits may periodically reduce equilibrium.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Exalted Venus, the yoga-karaka ruling both the 5th and 10th houses, is a notable supportive factor for balance, comfort, and the capacity to benefit from constructive routines, although its placement in the 3rd emphasizes personal effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/lord","/houses/9/lord","/yogas/3"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Jupiter placed in the 8th forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting some capacity to navigate adversity or recover through difficult periods, though it does not cancel the chart's health pressures.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"As of 2026-01-01, Saturn is in the second sign from the natal Moon, identified in the chart as a sade-sati phase; this can correspond astrologically with heavier responsibilities, fatigue, or a need for stricter pacing, without establishing a medical outcome.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/transits/asOf","/transits/saturnFromMoon","/transits/note"]},{"claim":"As of 2026-01-01, transiting Jupiter occupies the natal 6th house and aspects the 2nd, 10th, and 12th houses. This is mixed: it activates health-management matters while offering Jupiterian support for addressing them.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/transits/asOf","/transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse","/transits/contacts/4/aspectingNatalHouses"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["The D6/Shashtamsha health divisional chart is not provided, so finer health analysis cannot be corroborated through that varga.","No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle information, or clinician findings are supplied; therefore no condition-specific inference is warranted.","No requested future or past date beyond the supplied 2026-01-01 transit snapshot is specified, so broader timing conclusions are not attempted."],"rationale":"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable pressure points. Support comes from an ascendant lord in an upachaya, Mars in its own sign, benefic Jupiterian influence on nourishment, and an exalted yoga-karaka Venus. Challenges arise because Saturn aspects the ascendant while conjoined with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord connects directly with the 1st house, and the 8th house is activated by Jupiter under Saturn's aspect. The overall indication is therefore mixed: disciplined routines, pacing, stress regulation, and preventive care are astrologically favored, but the chart does not justify diagnosing any illness or predicting a definite health outcome."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Saturn occupies the 11th house, an upachaya associated with gradual development, suggesting resilience may strengthen through sustained discipline and consistent routines.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the 1st house while being in enemy dignity and joined by Mars and Rahu, indicating pressure on vitality and a tendency for strain to accumulate when demands are prolonged.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun occupies the 1st house but is in enemy dignity, giving some direct emphasis to vitality while making its expression uneven rather than uniformly protective.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 6th house of disease and daily health management, is placed in the 1st house. This closely links health with habits, workload, mental activity, and self-management; Mercury's benefic status offers some capacity to understand and manage difficulties.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house from its own sign in the 11th. Its strength can support resistance and active problem-solving, but its malefic nature also suggests inflammatory, conflict-driven, or overexertion-type stress in general astrological terms.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Mars/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, a natural benefic, aspects the 2nd house connected with food and nourishment, offering a protective influence over dietary resources and recovery support.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/aspects/Jupiter\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde in the 8th house and receives Saturn's aspect, emphasizing chronic or recurring health-management themes and the need for patience rather than implying a specific condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/7/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a benefic influence connected with emotional regulation, occupies the 2nd house and receives Jupiter's aspect, which can support nourishment and recuperative capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is marked combust and also receives Mars's aspect, suggesting that emotional agitation, irregular nourishment, or stress-reactive habits may periodically reduce equilibrium.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted Venus, the yoga-karaka ruling both the 5th and 10th houses, is a notable supportive factor for balance, comfort, and the capacity to benefit from constructive routines, although its placement in the 3rd emphasizes personal effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/yogas/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Jupiter placed in the 8th forms a listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga, suggesting some capacity to navigate adversity or recover through difficult periods, though it does not cancel the chart's health pressures.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"As of 2026-01-01, Saturn is in the second sign from the natal Moon, identified in the chart as a sade-sati phase; this can correspond astrologically with heavier responsibilities, fatigue, or a need for stricter pacing, without establishing a medical outcome.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/asOf\",\"/transits/saturnFromMoon\",\"/transits/note\"]},{\"claim\":\"As of 2026-01-01, transiting Jupiter occupies the natal 6th house and aspects the 2nd, 10th, and 12th houses. This is mixed: it activates health-management matters while offering Jupiterian support for addressing them.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/transits/asOf\",\"/transits/contacts/4/inNatalHouse\",\"/transits/contacts/4/aspectingNatalHouses\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"The D6/Shashtamsha health divisional chart is not provided, so finer health analysis cannot be corroborated through that varga.\",\"No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle information, or clinician findings are supplied; therefore no condition-specific inference is warranted.\",\"No requested future or past date beyond the supplied 2026-01-01 transit snapshot is specified, so broader timing conclusions are not attempted.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines meaningful resilience with notable pressure points. Support comes from an ascendant lord in an upachaya, Mars in its own sign, benefic Jupiterian influence on nourishment, and an exalted yoga-karaka Venus. Challenges arise because Saturn aspects the ascendant while conjoined with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord connects directly with the 1st house, and the 8th house is activated by Jupiter under Saturn's aspect. The overall indication is therefore mixed: disciplined routines, pacing, stress regulation, and preventive care are astrologically favored, but the chart does not justify diagnosing any illness or predicting a definite health outcome.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Baseline constitution has resilience but also sustained pressure: Capricorn rises, while lagna lord Saturn occupies the gain-oriented 11th yet is in enemy dignity and receives no stated benefic qualification there.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 1st house is occupied by Sun and Mercury, supporting vitality, awareness, and capacity for practical self-management; their conjunction also forms Budha-Aditya Yoga.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/0/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/yogas/1/name","/yogas/1/because"]},{"claim":"Direct pressure on the body axis is significant because Saturn and Ketu aspect the 1st house; Saturn's aspect is especially relevant because it is also the lagna lord and is in enemy dignity.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Ketu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 6th house of disease is unoccupied, and its lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house. This tightly links health and daily habits to the body, but Mercury is noncombust, direct, and classified benefic, improving scope for adaptation and management.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, indicating forceful resistance and capacity to confront health obstacles, while also adding inflammatory, acute, or overexertion symbolism; Mars is strengthened by occupying its own sign.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house"]},{"claim":"The 8th house of chronic matters and transformation contains Jupiter and is aspected by Moon and Saturn. Jupiter is benefic and in friend dignity, offering protection, but Saturn's influence and the 8th-house concentration suggest that persistent or recurring vulnerabilities should not be minimized.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, in the 8th forms a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, indicating potential recovery or constructive outcomes through difficult periods, though it does not erase the underlying dusthana involvement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because","/reference/dusthanas"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a general indicator of emotional and physiological responsiveness, occupies the 2nd house and is classified benefic, but is marked combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter; this combines sensitivity or fluctuation with some benefic protection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/isBenefic","/placements/Moon/combust","/houses/1/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The Sun, a vitality indicator, occupies the ascendant but is in enemy dignity, so its angular placement is supportive while its condition moderates the strength of that support.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted, noncombust Venus provides a notable general benefic counterweight, although its placement in the 3rd house does not directly remove the afflictions to the 1st, 6th, or 8th houses.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Benefic Jupiter in the 8th and Vipareeta Raja Yoga may improve resilience or recovery symbolism, but they should not be interpreted as immunity from illness because the 8th remains occupied and receives Saturn's aspect.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/yogas/5/name"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"An unoccupied 6th house does not by itself signify freedom from disease; its lord is placed in the ascendant and the house receives Mars's aspect, keeping health matters connected to the body and active lifestyle factors.","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/5/aspectedBy"]},{"statement_id":"S3","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Sun and Mercury in the ascendant support vitality and self-management, but this must be balanced against the Sun's enemy dignity and Saturn-Ketu aspects to the 1st house.","evidence":["/houses/0/occupants","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]}],"missing_information":["Shadbala and other quantified planetary-strength measures are absent.","A health-specific divisional chart such as D6 is not provided.","No symptoms, diagnoses, medical history, lifestyle, or clinical test results are supplied; astrology cannot establish a medical diagnosis."],"rationale":"The chart gives meaningful resilience through an occupied ascendant, capable Mercury, own-sign Mars, benefic Jupiter, exalted Venus, and a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga. These protections are counterbalanced by Saturn-Ketu pressure on the ascendant, a weakened Sun, the 6th lord's placement in the 1st, Mars's aspect on the 6th, and Saturn's aspect on the occupied 8th. The technical synthesis is therefore mixed rather than uniformly supportive or challenging: recovery and management potential appear present, but chronicity, sensitivity, and strain remain relevant astrological themes. These are symbolic indications, not medical findings."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Baseline constitution has resilience but also sustained pressure: Capricorn rises, while lagna lord Saturn occupies the gain-oriented 11th yet is in enemy dignity and receives no stated benefic qualification there.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 1st house is occupied by Sun and Mercury, supporting vitality, awareness, and capacity for practical self-management; their conjunction also forms Budha-Aditya Yoga.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/yogas/1/name\",\"/yogas/1/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Direct pressure on the body axis is significant because Saturn and Ketu aspect the 1st house; Saturn's aspect is especially relevant because it is also the lagna lord and is in enemy dignity.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Ketu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house of disease is unoccupied, and its lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house. This tightly links health and daily habits to the body, but Mercury is noncombust, direct, and classified benefic, improving scope for adaptation and management.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, indicating forceful resistance and capacity to confront health obstacles, while also adding inflammatory, acute, or overexertion symbolism; Mars is strengthened by occupying its own sign.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house of chronic matters and transformation contains Jupiter and is aspected by Moon and Saturn. Jupiter is benefic and in friend dignity, offering protection, but Saturn's influence and the 8th-house concentration suggest that persistent or recurring vulnerabilities should not be minimized.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, in the 8th forms a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga, indicating potential recovery or constructive outcomes through difficult periods, though it does not erase the underlying dusthana involvement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\",\"/reference/dusthanas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a general indicator of emotional and physiological responsiveness, occupies the 2nd house and is classified benefic, but is marked combust and receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter; this combines sensitivity or fluctuation with some benefic protection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun, a vitality indicator, occupies the ascendant but is in enemy dignity, so its angular placement is supportive while its condition moderates the strength of that support.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted, noncombust Venus provides a notable general benefic counterweight, although its placement in the 3rd house does not directly remove the afflictions to the 1st, 6th, or 8th houses.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Benefic Jupiter in the 8th and Vipareeta Raja Yoga may improve resilience or recovery symbolism, but they should not be interpreted as immunity from illness because the 8th remains occupied and receives Saturn's aspect.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/yogas/5/name\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"An unoccupied 6th house does not by itself signify freedom from disease; its lord is placed in the ascendant and the house receives Mars's aspect, keeping health matters connected to the body and active lifestyle factors.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S3\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Sun and Mercury in the ascendant support vitality and self-management, but this must be balanced against the Sun's enemy dignity and Saturn-Ketu aspects to the 1st house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/occupants\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and other quantified planetary-strength measures are absent.\",\"A health-specific divisional chart such as D6 is not provided.\",\"No symptoms, diagnoses, medical history, lifestyle, or clinical test results are supplied; astrology cannot establish a medical diagnosis.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart gives meaningful resilience through an occupied ascendant, capable Mercury, own-sign Mars, benefic Jupiter, exalted Venus, and a stated Vipareeta Raja Yoga. These protections are counterbalanced by Saturn-Ketu pressure on the ascendant, a weakened Sun, the 6th lord's placement in the 1st, Mars's aspect on the 6th, and Saturn's aspect on the occupied 8th. The technical synthesis is therefore mixed rather than uniformly supportive or challenging: recovery and management potential appear present, but chronicity, sensitivity, and strain remain relevant astrological themes. These are symbolic indications, not medical findings.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The available chart fact records a house lord placed in the twelfth house, not an established second-lord-in-eleventh configuration.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"The chart does not establish that the second lord occupies the eleventh house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required placement is not established, and a single placement would not justify a guarantee of lifelong illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule does not establish strong childhood vitality from this placement alone, and the referenced placement is absent.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["An explicit chart fact identifying the second house lord and its house placement."],"rationale":"None of A-C is established by the supplied chart and stated rule, so D applies. Because the only applicable listed statement rejects establishment rather than asserting a supportive or challenging health indication, the conclusion is insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The available chart fact records a house lord placed in the twelfth house, not an established second-lord-in-eleventh configuration.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The chart does not establish that the second lord occupies the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is not established, and a single placement would not justify a guarantee of lifelong illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule does not establish strong childhood vitality from this placement alone, and the referenced placement is absent.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"An explicit chart fact identifying the second house lord and its house placement.\"],\"rationale\":\"None of A-C is established by the supplied chart and stated rule, so D applies. Because the only applicable listed statement rejects establishment rather than asserting a supportive or challenging health indication, the conclusion is insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart facts do not provide the second-house lord or its placement, so none of statements A-C can be established.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"No evidence is supplied that the second lord occupies the eleventh house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The stated placement is not established, and a single placement would not justify guaranteeing lifelong illness.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The relevant second-lord placement is absent, so strong childhood vitality is not established by the stated rule and chart.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["The second house's lord and the house in which that lord is placed."],"rationale":"Only option D applies. The available entry shows Mercury placed in house 12, but it does not supply the second-house data required to test the proposed second-lord-in-eleventh rule."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart facts do not provide the second-house lord or its placement, so none of statements A-C can be established.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"No evidence is supplied that the second lord occupies the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The stated placement is not established, and a single placement would not justify guaranteeing lifelong illness.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The relevant second-lord placement is absent, so strong childhood vitality is not established by the stated rule and chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"The second house's lord and the house in which that lord is placed.\"],\"rationale\":\"Only option D applies. The available entry shows Mercury placed in house 12, but it does not supply the second-house data required to test the proposed second-lord-in-eleventh rule.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant and its lord receive substantial pressure: Saturn rules the Capricorn ascendant, occupies the 11th in enemy dignity, and the 1st house is aspected by Saturn and Ketu. This can indicate variable vitality or health burdens requiring sustained management rather than automatically signifying severe disease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/0/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord in the 11th, an upachaya associated with gains and networks, gives some capacity to improve resilience through disciplined, cumulative effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house, directly connecting disease and daily-health themes with the body. Mercury is nevertheless non-combust and also rules the 9th, so this is a mixed indication rather than an unqualified affliction.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/combust","/houses/8/lord"]},{"claim":"Mars aspects the 6th house, which can intensify conflict, inflammation-like symbolism, accidents, or acute strain; however, Mars is in its own sign and the 6th is an upachaya, giving competitive capacity to confront obstacles.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Mars","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/reference/dusthanas"]},{"claim":"The 8th house of chronic and sudden matters contains Jupiter and is aspected by Moon and Saturn. Saturn's influence adds persistence or delay, while Jupiter provides some benefic protection; Jupiter's friendly dignity and the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga further moderate the difficulty.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/7/occupants","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/yogas/5/name","/yogas/5/because"]},{"claim":"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupying the 8th links loss, hospitalization or isolation symbolism with chronic and transformative matters, but its benefic status and vipareeta configuration can support recovery after adversity.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"The Moon, a general indicator of emotional and bodily rhythms, is marked combust and receives Mars's aspect in the 2nd house. This suggests sensitivity to stress, nourishment, food habits or family atmosphere, without identifying a specific medical condition.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Sun and Mercury occupy the ascendant, emphasizing vitality, cognition and self-monitoring. Their Budha-Aditya Yoga can support awareness and problem-solving, though the Sun is in enemy dignity and rules the 8th, adding strain to the body axis.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/0/occupants","/yogas/1","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/7/lord","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The 11th-house concentration of Mars, Saturn and Rahu makes long-term outcomes dependent on disciplined habits and social environment. Strong own-sign Mars supports persistence, while Saturn's enemy dignity and debilitated Rahu add volatility and overexertion risk.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/10/occupants","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Exalted, non-combust Venus is a significant protective factor. As ruler of the 5th and 10th, it forms a listed raja yoga and can support constructive routines, creativity and recovery resources, although its placement in the 3rd does not directly remove affliction from the ascendant, 6th or 8th.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/4/lord","/houses/9/lord","/yogas/3"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"S1","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Affliction to the ascendant, 6th and 8th houses should not be converted into a diagnosis or prediction of severe illness; benefic Jupiter, strong Mars, exalted Venus and the ascendant lord's upachaya placement provide meaningful counterweights.","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/7/occupants","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Venus/dignity","/lagna/lordInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"S2","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Jupiter in the 8th is not purely protective: it is also the 12th lord connecting two dusthanas. Its effect is therefore best read as mixed, with adversity-management potential represented by the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga.","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/reference/dusthanas","/yogas/5"]}],"missing_information":["No D30 or other dedicated disease-focused divisional chart is supplied.","No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, or clinical data are provided; astrology cannot diagnose a condition.","No specific assessment date was requested, so current dasha and transit factors are not used to infer health timing."],"rationale":"The natal pattern is mixed but burdened: the body axis is pressured by Saturn and Ketu, the 6th lord occupies the ascendant, Mars influences the 6th, and the 8th house is activated by Jupiter with Moon-Saturn aspects. Counterweights are substantial—ascendant lord Saturn is in an upachaya, Mars has own-sign strength, Jupiter is benefic and in friendly dignity, and Venus is exalted. The synthesis therefore suggests sensitivity to chronic stress and periods requiring disciplined health management, alongside credible resilience and recovery capacity. It does not support a medical diagnosis or certainty of adverse outcomes."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant and its lord receive substantial pressure: Saturn rules the Capricorn ascendant, occupies the 11th in enemy dignity, and the 1st house is aspected by Saturn and Ketu. This can indicate variable vitality or health burdens requiring sustained management rather than automatically signifying severe disease.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord in the 11th, an upachaya associated with gains and networks, gives some capacity to improve resilience through disciplined, cumulative effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury is placed in the 1st house, directly connecting disease and daily-health themes with the body. Mercury is nevertheless non-combust and also rules the 9th, so this is a mixed indication rather than an unqualified affliction.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\",\"/houses/8/lord\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars aspects the 6th house, which can intensify conflict, inflammation-like symbolism, accidents, or acute strain; however, Mars is in its own sign and the 6th is an upachaya, giving competitive capacity to confront obstacles.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/reference/dusthanas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house of chronic and sudden matters contains Jupiter and is aspected by Moon and Saturn. Saturn's influence adds persistence or delay, while Jupiter provides some benefic protection; Jupiter's friendly dignity and the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga further moderate the difficulty.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/yogas/5/name\",\"/yogas/5/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter, lord of the 12th, occupying the 8th links loss, hospitalization or isolation symbolism with chronic and transformative matters, but its benefic status and vipareeta configuration can support recovery after adversity.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon, a general indicator of emotional and bodily rhythms, is marked combust and receives Mars's aspect in the 2nd house. This suggests sensitivity to stress, nourishment, food habits or family atmosphere, without identifying a specific medical condition.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun and Mercury occupy the ascendant, emphasizing vitality, cognition and self-monitoring. Their Budha-Aditya Yoga can support awareness and problem-solving, though the Sun is in enemy dignity and rules the 8th, adding strain to the body axis.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/occupants\",\"/yogas/1\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th-house concentration of Mars, Saturn and Rahu makes long-term outcomes dependent on disciplined habits and social environment. Strong own-sign Mars supports persistence, while Saturn's enemy dignity and debilitated Rahu add volatility and overexertion risk.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted, non-combust Venus is a significant protective factor. As ruler of the 5th and 10th, it forms a listed raja yoga and can support constructive routines, creativity and recovery resources, although its placement in the 3rd does not directly remove affliction from the ascendant, 6th or 8th.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/yogas/3\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"S1\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Affliction to the ascendant, 6th and 8th houses should not be converted into a diagnosis or prediction of severe illness; benefic Jupiter, strong Mars, exalted Venus and the ascendant lord's upachaya placement provide meaningful counterweights.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/7/occupants\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"S2\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Jupiter in the 8th is not purely protective: it is also the 12th lord connecting two dusthanas. Its effect is therefore best read as mixed, with adversity-management potential represented by the listed Vipareeta Raja Yoga.\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/reference/dusthanas\",\"/yogas/5\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"No D30 or other dedicated disease-focused divisional chart is supplied.\",\"No medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, or clinical data are provided; astrology cannot diagnose a condition.\",\"No specific assessment date was requested, so current dasha and transit factors are not used to infer health timing.\"],\"rationale\":\"The natal pattern is mixed but burdened: the body axis is pressured by Saturn and Ketu, the 6th lord occupies the ascendant, Mars influences the 6th, and the 8th house is activated by Jupiter with Moon-Saturn aspects. Counterweights are substantial—ascendant lord Saturn is in an upachaya, Mars has own-sign strength, Jupiter is benefic and in friendly dignity, and Venus is exalted. The synthesis therefore suggests sensitivity to chronic stress and periods requiring disciplined health management, alongside credible resilience and recovery capacity. It does not support a medical diagnosis or certainty of adverse outcomes.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"health","conclusion":"mixed","confidence":0.82,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant and its lord carry substantial affliction: Saturn and Ketu aspect the 1st house, while ascendant lord Saturn is in enemy dignity and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu. This can indicate fluctuating vitality and susceptibility to stress or persistent health burdens, without identifying a specific disease.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/0/aspectedBy","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"The ascendant lord in the 11th provides an upachaya placement, offering scope for endurance and gradual improvement; Mars is also strong in its own sign in the same house, although its conjunction with Saturn and Rahu makes the result mixed rather than uniformly protective.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/10/occupants"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Mercury occupies the 1st house, directly connecting illness, service, and daily strain with the body. Mercury is nevertheless marked benefic, neutral in dignity, direct, and non-combust, which supplies some capacity for management and recovery.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/placements/Mercury/retrograde","/placements/Mercury/combust"]},{"claim":"The 6th house is unoccupied but receives Mars's aspect, adding an inflammatory, acute, competitive, or injury-prone quality to health challenges in traditional Jyotish interpretation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/5/occupants","/houses/5/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"The 8th house, associated with chronic matters and sudden changes, contains Jupiter and receives aspects from Moon and Saturn. Saturn's involvement can prolong burdens, while benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity can moderate adversity; Jupiter's recorded Vipareeta Raja Yoga further supports resilience through difficult periods.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/reference/houseSignifications/8","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/7/aspectedBy","/yogas/5"]},{"claim":"The Sun, a vitality significator and 8th lord, is in the ascendant in enemy dignity. This reinforces the connection between vitality and 8th-house themes, but its angular placement also makes it prominent rather than simply weak.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/houses/7/lord","/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The Moon is marked combust and occupies the 2nd house; it receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter. This gives mixed indications around emotional steadiness, nourishment, family support, and accumulated bodily resources: Mars challenges, while Jupiter can protect.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/combust","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Exalted, non-combust Venus is a notable general protective factor. As ruler of both the 5th and 10th houses, it forms a recorded raja yoga, although its 3rd-house placement does not directly cancel the afflictions to the ascendant, 6th, and 8th houses.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Venus/combust","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/3"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Shadbala and other quantitative planetary-strength measures","Drekkana or other specialized medical divisional analysis","Exact aspect strengths and planetary war data","Medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, and clinical findings","A target date for dasha and transit-based health timing"],"rationale":"The chart combines meaningful resilience with clear affliction. Protective features include the ascendant lord in an upachaya, Mars in its own sign, benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity, exalted Venus, and a recorded Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Against these are direct affliction to the ascendant, the ascendant lord's association with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord placed in the 1st, Mars influencing the 6th, and Saturn influencing the occupied 8th. The appropriate overall judgment is mixed: endurance and recovery potential are present, but health may require sustained discipline and timely professional evaluation. These are astrological indications, not a medical diagnosis."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"mixed\",\"confidence\":0.82,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant and its lord carry substantial affliction: Saturn and Ketu aspect the 1st house, while ascendant lord Saturn is in enemy dignity and shares the 11th house with Mars and Rahu. This can indicate fluctuating vitality and susceptibility to stress or persistent health burdens, without identifying a specific disease.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/aspectedBy\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord in the 11th provides an upachaya placement, offering scope for endurance and gradual improvement; Mars is also strong in its own sign in the same house, although its conjunction with Saturn and Rahu makes the result mixed rather than uniformly protective.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/10/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Mercury occupies the 1st house, directly connecting illness, service, and daily strain with the body. Mercury is nevertheless marked benefic, neutral in dignity, direct, and non-combust, which supplies some capacity for management and recovery.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/retrograde\",\"/placements/Mercury/combust\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th house is unoccupied but receives Mars's aspect, adding an inflammatory, acute, competitive, or injury-prone quality to health challenges in traditional Jyotish interpretation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/occupants\",\"/houses/5/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 8th house, associated with chronic matters and sudden changes, contains Jupiter and receives aspects from Moon and Saturn. Saturn's involvement can prolong burdens, while benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity can moderate adversity; Jupiter's recorded Vipareeta Raja Yoga further supports resilience through difficult periods.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/7/aspectedBy\",\"/yogas/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Sun, a vitality significator and 8th lord, is in the ascendant in enemy dignity. This reinforces the connection between vitality and 8th-house themes, but its angular placement also makes it prominent rather than simply weak.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/houses/7/lord\",\"/houses/7/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Moon is marked combust and occupies the 2nd house; it receives aspects from Mars and Jupiter. This gives mixed indications around emotional steadiness, nourishment, family support, and accumulated bodily resources: Mars challenges, while Jupiter can protect.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/combust\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Exalted, non-combust Venus is a notable general protective factor. As ruler of both the 5th and 10th houses, it forms a recorded raja yoga, although its 3rd-house placement does not directly cancel the afflictions to the ascendant, 6th, and 8th houses.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Venus/combust\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/3\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Shadbala and other quantitative planetary-strength measures\",\"Drekkana or other specialized medical divisional analysis\",\"Exact aspect strengths and planetary war data\",\"Medical history, symptoms, lifestyle, and clinical findings\",\"A target date for dasha and transit-based health timing\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart combines meaningful resilience with clear affliction. Protective features include the ascendant lord in an upachaya, Mars in its own sign, benefic Jupiter in friendly dignity, exalted Venus, and a recorded Vipareeta Raja Yoga. Against these are direct affliction to the ascendant, the ascendant lord's association with Mars and Rahu, the 6th lord placed in the 1st, Mars influencing the 6th, and Saturn influencing the occupied 8th. The appropriate overall judgment is mixed: endurance and recovery potential are present, but health may require sustained discipline and timely professional evaluation. These are astrological indications, not a medical diagnosis.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"health-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"health-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"health","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The only supplied lord-placement fact places the listed house lord in the twelfth house, not the eleventh; therefore statements A and B are not applicable.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"The supplied placement does not establish the strong-childhood-vitality claim in statement C.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["An explicit computed placement for the second-house lord is absent; the available object is at /houses/1."],"rationale":"Select D. The stated eleventh-house condition required by A and B is not shown, and C is not established by the available fact. Because none of A-C applies, the listed statements alone provide insufficient polarity for a health conclusion."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"health-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"health\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The only supplied lord-placement fact places the listed house lord in the twelfth house, not the eleventh; therefore statements A and B are not applicable.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"The supplied placement does not establish the strong-childhood-vitality claim in statement C.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"An explicit computed placement for the second-house lord is absent; the available object is at /houses/1.\"],\"rationale\":\"Select D. The stated eleventh-house condition required by A and B is not shown, and C is not established by the available fact. Because none of A-C applies, the listed statements alone provide insufficient polarity for a health conclusion.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"A. The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success, visibility, or specialization under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The ascendant lord in the tenth is not primarily a career-loss indication under the stated rule.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Cancer rises, its lord is Moon, and Moon occupies the tenth house. Thus A applies as a supportive career indication. B reverses the usual polarity, C claims unjustified certainty and specificity, and D is false because A is directly supported by the computed chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"A. The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success, visibility, or specialization under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the tenth is not primarily a career-loss indication under the stated rule.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Cancer rises, its lord is Moon, and Moon occupies the tenth house. Thus A applies as a supportive career indication. B reverses the usual polarity, C claims unjustified certainty and specificity, and D is false because A is directly supported by the computed chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success or specialization under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/reference/houseSignifications/10"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/10"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon occupies the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart explicitly identifies Moon as ascendant lord and places it in house 10. Therefore A applies. B reverses the stated rule, C claims an unsupported guarantee, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success or specialization under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/10\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/10\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon occupies the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart explicitly identifies Moon as ascendant lord and places it in house 10. Therefore A applies. B reverses the stated rule, C claims an unsupported guarantee, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"A. For Cancer ascendant, the ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success, visibility, or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The ascendant lord in the tenth is not primarily classified by the stated rule as a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support career prominence or specialization, but it does not by itself guarantee a specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart has Cancer lagna, making Moon the ascendant lord, and Moon occupies the tenth house. Therefore A applies and has supportive polarity. B reverses the stated interpretation, C claims an unwarranted guarantee, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"A. For Cancer ascendant, the ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success, visibility, or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the tenth is not primarily classified by the stated rule as a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support career prominence or specialization, but it does not by itself guarantee a specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart has Cancer lagna, making Moon the ascendant lord, and Moon occupies the tenth house. Therefore A applies and has supportive polarity. B reverses the stated interpretation, C claims an unwarranted guarantee, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Cancer ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success or specialization under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as professionally supportive, not primarily as an indication of career loss.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly placed in house 10.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Statement A alone applies. The chart explicitly places ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, whose significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. Statements B and C respectively reverse and overstate the rule, so D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Cancer ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, supporting professional success or specialization under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as professionally supportive, not primarily as an indication of career loss.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement can support career prominence or specialization but does not guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly placed in house 10.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Statement A alone applies. The chart explicitly places ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, whose significations include career, status, authority, and public standing. Statements B and C respectively reverse and overstate the rule, so D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.98,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"A. The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, a placement treated as supportive of professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated placement is treated as professionally supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The ascendant lord in the tenth may support professional prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Cancer rises, making Moon the ascendant lord, and the computed chart places Moon in the tenth house. Under the stated rule this is a supportive career indication. It is neither primarily loss-producing nor sufficient to guarantee a particular occupation."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.98,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"A. The ascendant lord Moon is placed in the tenth house, a placement treated as supportive of professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated placement is treated as professionally supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the tenth may support professional prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Cancer ascendant's lord, Moon, occupies the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Cancer rises, making Moon the ascendant lord, and the computed chart places Moon in the tenth house. Under the stated rule this is a supportive career indication. It is neither primarily loss-producing nor sufficient to guarantee a particular occupation.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Cancer ascendant is ruled by the Moon, and the Moon occupies the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success or specialization.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon is computed in the tenth house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Moon/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The computed chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, so the listed rule has supportive polarity. B reverses the rule, C adds an unwarranted guarantee, and D is false because A is established."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Cancer ascendant is ruled by the Moon, and the Moon occupies the tenth house; under the stated rule, this supports professional success or specialization.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the tenth as supportive, not primarily as a career-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement may support career prominence or specialization but does not by itself guarantee any specific profession.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Moon is computed in the tenth house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Moon/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The computed chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Moon in the tenth house, so the listed rule has supportive polarity. B reverses the rule, C adds an unwarranted guarantee, and D is false because A is established.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly connecting personal direction and identity with career, public responsibility, and status.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter rules both the 1st and 4th houses and is identified as forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting professional standing and constructive responsibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, linking career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, or advisory work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, favoring polished communication, negotiation, commercial judgment, and work that combines intellect with presentation or relationship management.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 5th lord Mars is strong in its own sign in the 5th house, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, creativity, leadership, and independent decision-making.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Career can generate gains because the 11th lord Venus is placed in the 2nd house, connecting income and networks with accumulated resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"In the D10 career chart, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing gains through intellectual, communicative, administrative, or commercial capabilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer, indicating strong underlying capacity for guidance, knowledge, management, or service, although its 6th-house placement emphasizes effort, competition, and problem-solving.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/dispositor"]},{"claim":"D10 Sun, Moon, and Venus occupy the 2nd house, highlighting speech, knowledge, values, financial administration, and client-facing presentation as important professional resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/2/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Natal Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in an enemy sign, so professional growth may involve revisions, non-linear development, self-questioning, or delayed recognition despite the strong career emphasis.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, suggesting periodic detachment from titles, dissatisfaction with conventional career structures, or abrupt changes in professional direction.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The 2nd and 3rd lord Saturn occupies the 12th house in an enemy sign alongside Rahu, introducing potential expenditure, isolation, foreign or institutional settings, and uneven consolidation of income or skills.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/2/lord","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/11/occupants"]},{"claim":"In D10, Saturn is in its own sign but placed in the 12th house with Ketu, supporting endurance in foreign, institutional, research, secluded, or behind-the-scenes environments while also indicating periods of professional withdrawal, heavy responsibility, or reduced visibility.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/8/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No career history, occupation, education, or event dates were supplied, so the chart indications cannot be matched to specific roles or verified against lived outcomes.","No planetary strength metrics beyond the supplied dignity and placement data are available."],"rationale":"The chart is professionally supportive overall because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects career with the wealth house, and the D10 emphasizes gains, communication, knowledge, service, and financial or client-facing abilities. Strong Mars adds initiative and strategic capacity. The principal complications are Jupiter's retrograde enemy-sign condition, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and repeated 12th-house emphasis from Saturn, Rahu, and the D10 Saturn-Ketu pattern. These factors suggest that progress may be non-linear and may involve foreign, institutional, technical, research, advisory, service-oriented, or behind-the-scenes work rather than a uniformly conventional climb. The synthesis is supportive but not effortless."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, strongly connecting personal direction and identity with career, public responsibility, and status.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter rules both the 1st and 4th houses and is identified as forming a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting professional standing and constructive responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, linking career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, commerce, or advisory work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, favoring polished communication, negotiation, commercial judgment, and work that combines intellect with presentation or relationship management.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 5th lord Mars is strong in its own sign in the 5th house, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, creativity, leadership, and independent decision-making.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career can generate gains because the 11th lord Venus is placed in the 2nd house, connecting income and networks with accumulated resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10 career chart, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing gains through intellectual, communicative, administrative, or commercial capabilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter is in Cancer, indicating strong underlying capacity for guidance, knowledge, management, or service, although its 6th-house placement emphasizes effort, competition, and problem-solving.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/dispositor\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Sun, Moon, and Venus occupy the 2nd house, highlighting speech, knowledge, values, financial administration, and client-facing presentation as important professional resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in an enemy sign, so professional growth may involve revisions, non-linear development, self-questioning, or delayed recognition despite the strong career emphasis.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, suggesting periodic detachment from titles, dissatisfaction with conventional career structures, or abrupt changes in professional direction.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd and 3rd lord Saturn occupies the 12th house in an enemy sign alongside Rahu, introducing potential expenditure, isolation, foreign or institutional settings, and uneven consolidation of income or skills.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/2/lord\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"In D10, Saturn is in its own sign but placed in the 12th house with Ketu, supporting endurance in foreign, institutional, research, secluded, or behind-the-scenes environments while also indicating periods of professional withdrawal, heavy responsibility, or reduced visibility.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No career history, occupation, education, or event dates were supplied, so the chart indications cannot be matched to specific roles or verified against lived outcomes.\",\"No planetary strength metrics beyond the supplied dignity and placement data are available.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is professionally supportive overall because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects career with the wealth house, and the D10 emphasizes gains, communication, knowledge, service, and financial or client-facing abilities. Strong Mars adds initiative and strategic capacity. The principal complications are Jupiter's retrograde enemy-sign condition, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and repeated 12th-house emphasis from Saturn, Rahu, and the D10 Saturn-Ketu pattern. These factors suggest that progress may be non-linear and may involve foreign, institutional, technical, research, advisory, service-oriented, or behind-the-scenes work rather than a uniformly conventional climb. The synthesis is supportive but not effortless.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Career and public contribution are prominent because ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking personal direction closely with professional action and status.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 10th can support advisory, educational, managerial, ethical, or knowledge-centered work, although its enemy-sign dignity and retrograde status suggest a less linear path, periodic reassessment, or delayed recognition.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with speech, analysis, commerce, counsel, finance, family enterprise, or the management of accumulated resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury joins Venus in the 2nd house, strengthening the possibility that communication, negotiation, presentation, relationship management, design, or refined commercial judgment contribute to earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus also occupies the 2nd house, creating a constructive link between gains and accumulated resources; professional networks or client-facing skills may translate into income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, and the ability to pursue gains vigorously; it may also increase competitiveness or risk-taking.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, indicating possible dissatisfaction with conventional status, abrupt changes of professional direction, or preference for specialized and autonomous work despite outward achievement.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th house, while the 2nd lord Saturn is also placed there. This can connect work and finances with foreign environments, large institutions, remote settings, research, isolation, or substantial overhead, but it can also produce leakage of resources and periods of professional strain.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing gains through intellectual, communicative, commercial, or network-based activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign"]},{"claim":"The D10 places Sun, Moon, and Venus together in the 2nd house, emphasizing livelihood through voice, visibility, relationship skills, values, or resource stewardship.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter and Rahu in the 6th house favor engagement with demanding service environments, competition, problem-solving, or complex organizations, but can bring heavy workloads and workplace friction.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn and Ketu in the 12th house repeat the natal 12th-house emphasis, strengthening themes of institutional or foreign work while also indicating isolation, delayed rewards, behind-the-scenes responsibility, or periodic disengagement from conventional ambitions.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/8/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house"]},{"claim":"The recorded Jupiter Raja Yoga adds general support for responsibility and elevation because Jupiter rules both the ascendant and the 4th house, though its practical expression remains moderated by Jupiter's natal dignity and the 10th-house Ketu influence.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The chart is broadly supportive for career because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th and 11th lords converge in the wealth-and-speech-oriented 2nd house, and the D10 reinforces earnings through communication, networks, visibility, and resource management. The strongest challenges are the repeated 6th- and 12th-house themes, Ketu's influence on the natal 10th, and Jupiter's retrograde enemy-sign condition. These combinations suggest meaningful professional capacity and potential standing, but with a non-linear trajectory, demanding service obligations, institutional or foreign links, and periodic dissatisfaction with purely conventional measures of success."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Career and public contribution are prominent because ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking personal direction closely with professional action and status.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 10th can support advisory, educational, managerial, ethical, or knowledge-centered work, although its enemy-sign dignity and retrograde status suggest a less linear path, periodic reassessment, or delayed recognition.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with speech, analysis, commerce, counsel, finance, family enterprise, or the management of accumulated resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury joins Venus in the 2nd house, strengthening the possibility that communication, negotiation, presentation, relationship management, design, or refined commercial judgment contribute to earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus also occupies the 2nd house, creating a constructive link between gains and accumulated resources; professional networks or client-facing skills may translate into income.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, and the ability to pursue gains vigorously; it may also increase competitiveness or risk-taking.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, indicating possible dissatisfaction with conventional status, abrupt changes of professional direction, or preference for specialized and autonomous work despite outward achievement.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th house, while the 2nd lord Saturn is also placed there. This can connect work and finances with foreign environments, large institutions, remote settings, research, isolation, or substantial overhead, but it can also produce leakage of resources and periods of professional strain.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing gains through intellectual, communicative, commercial, or network-based activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 places Sun, Moon, and Venus together in the 2nd house, emphasizing livelihood through voice, visibility, relationship skills, values, or resource stewardship.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter and Rahu in the 6th house favor engagement with demanding service environments, competition, problem-solving, or complex organizations, but can bring heavy workloads and workplace friction.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn and Ketu in the 12th house repeat the natal 12th-house emphasis, strengthening themes of institutional or foreign work while also indicating isolation, delayed rewards, behind-the-scenes responsibility, or periodic disengagement from conventional ambitions.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The recorded Jupiter Raja Yoga adds general support for responsibility and elevation because Jupiter rules both the ascendant and the 4th house, though its practical expression remains moderated by Jupiter's natal dignity and the 10th-house Ketu influence.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The chart is broadly supportive for career because the ascendant lord occupies the 10th, the 10th and 11th lords converge in the wealth-and-speech-oriented 2nd house, and the D10 reinforces earnings through communication, networks, visibility, and resource management. The strongest challenges are the repeated 6th- and 12th-house themes, Ketu's influence on the natal 10th, and Jupiter's retrograde enemy-sign condition. These combinations suggest meaningful professional capacity and potential standing, but with a non-linear trajectory, demanding service obligations, institutional or foreign links, and periodic dissatisfaction with purely conventional measures of success.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"Career and public contribution are prominent because the ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking personal direction directly with profession, responsibility, and standing.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"Jupiter also rules both the 1st and 4th houses and is explicitly identified as producing a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting responsibility, recognition, guidance, education, administration, or advisory work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/0/lord","/houses/3/lord","/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/yogas/0/grahas"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, family enterprises, communication, analysis, or knowledge-based activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening the potential role of diplomacy, presentation, negotiation, commercial judgment, client relations, or refined communication in earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus is also in the 2nd house, creating a direct link between gains and accumulated wealth; this can support monetizing professional networks or communication-oriented abilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/houses/10/significations","/houses/1/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th house, indicating initiative, strategic intelligence, competitive drive, creativity, and active pursuit of gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/houses/4/significations","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"In the D10 career chart, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing a career connection with gains, professional networks, communication, calculation, commerce, or coordination.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter occupies the 6th house, suggesting that career development may be expressed through service, problem-solving, institutional duties, competition, or managing difficult practical conditions rather than through effortless advancement alone.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn and Ketu both occupy the 12th house, indicating possible periods of professional isolation, work behind the scenes, foreign or large institutional environments, disengagement from status, or effort that receives limited immediate visibility.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/8/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"Natal Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and recorded in enemy dignity, so its otherwise strong career prominence may involve revisions of professional direction, uneven confidence in authority, or delayed consolidation of recognition.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, adding the possibility of periodic detachment from conventional ambition, sudden changes in professional motivation, or preference for specialized and less conventional work.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/aspects/Ketu","/houses/9/aspectedBy","/placements/Ketu/house"]},{"claim":"The 2nd lord Saturn is placed in the 12th house with Rahu, qualifying the otherwise favorable income combinations with potential expenditure, delayed accumulation, foreign connections, institutional costs, or fluctuations between earnings and outflow.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/occupants","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/houses/11/significations"]},{"claim":"Saturn aspects the 2nd house containing Mercury and Venus, suggesting that earnings and professional communication may require discipline, patience, consistency, and long-term financial management.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Saturn","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/houses/1/occupants"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["Exact career timing is not assessed because no specific target date or career event was requested.","D10 aspects, conjunction rules, and quantified planetary strengths are not supplied, so the divisional-chart assessment is limited to the stated placements."],"rationale":"The career pattern is broadly supportive but not effortless. The strongest indications are the ascendant lord Jupiter in the 10th, the explicit Jupiter Raja Yoga, the 10th lord Mercury joining Venus in the wealth-oriented 2nd house, and D10 Mercury in the 11th. These favor visible responsibility and careers involving communication, advice, analysis, education, administration, finance, negotiation, or client-facing coordination. The main qualifications are Jupiter's retrograde enemy dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house themes involving Saturn, Rahu, and the D10 placements of Saturn and Ketu. Consequently, professional success is indicated more through sustained service, expertise, disciplined communication, and adaptation to institutional or behind-the-scenes settings than through a simple or continuously upward trajectory."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"Career and public contribution are prominent because the ascendant lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking personal direction directly with profession, responsibility, and standing.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter also rules both the 1st and 4th houses and is explicitly identified as producing a single-lordship Raja Yoga, supporting responsibility, recognition, guidance, education, administration, or advisory work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, family enterprises, communication, analysis, or knowledge-based activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening the potential role of diplomacy, presentation, negotiation, commercial judgment, client relations, or refined communication in earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus is also in the 2nd house, creating a direct link between gains and accumulated wealth; this can support monetizing professional networks or communication-oriented abilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\",\"/houses/1/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th house, indicating initiative, strategic intelligence, competitive drive, creativity, and active pursuit of gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/houses/4/significations\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10 career chart, Mercury occupies the 11th house, reinforcing a career connection with gains, professional networks, communication, calculation, commerce, or coordination.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter occupies the 6th house, suggesting that career development may be expressed through service, problem-solving, institutional duties, competition, or managing difficult practical conditions rather than through effortless advancement alone.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn and Ketu both occupy the 12th house, indicating possible periods of professional isolation, work behind the scenes, foreign or large institutional environments, disengagement from status, or effort that receives limited immediate visibility.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"Natal Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and recorded in enemy dignity, so its otherwise strong career prominence may involve revisions of professional direction, uneven confidence in authority, or delayed consolidation of recognition.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu aspects the natal 10th house, adding the possibility of periodic detachment from conventional ambition, sudden changes in professional motivation, or preference for specialized and less conventional work.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Ketu\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Ketu/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd lord Saturn is placed in the 12th house with Rahu, qualifying the otherwise favorable income combinations with potential expenditure, delayed accumulation, foreign connections, institutional costs, or fluctuations between earnings and outflow.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/houses/11/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn aspects the 2nd house containing Mercury and Venus, suggesting that earnings and professional communication may require discipline, patience, consistency, and long-term financial management.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/1/occupants\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"Exact career timing is not assessed because no specific target date or career event was requested.\",\"D10 aspects, conjunction rules, and quantified planetary strengths are not supplied, so the divisional-chart assessment is limited to the stated placements.\"],\"rationale\":\"The career pattern is broadly supportive but not effortless. The strongest indications are the ascendant lord Jupiter in the 10th, the explicit Jupiter Raja Yoga, the 10th lord Mercury joining Venus in the wealth-oriented 2nd house, and D10 Mercury in the 11th. These favor visible responsibility and careers involving communication, advice, analysis, education, administration, finance, negotiation, or client-facing coordination. The main qualifications are Jupiter's retrograde enemy dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house themes involving Saturn, Rahu, and the D10 placements of Saturn and Ketu. Consequently, professional success is indicated more through sustained service, expertise, disciplined communication, and adaptation to institutional or behind-the-scenes settings than through a simple or continuously upward trajectory.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The career axis is prominent because Jupiter, the lagna lord, occupies the 10th house, linking identity and life direction directly with profession, status and public responsibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/reference/houseSignifications/10"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 10th forms the chart's stated raja yoga through its lordship of both the 1st and 4th houses, supporting leadership, recognition and constructive institutional roles.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because","/houses/0/lord","/houses/3/lord","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity in Virgo, so professional authority may develop through revision, experience and problem-solving rather than through an entirely smooth or conventional rise.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/house"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis and advisory or commercial skills.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening diplomacy, communication, negotiation, financial judgment and the ability to earn through refined intellectual or client-facing work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 6th lord Venus and 11th lord Venus are also in the 2nd, linking service and daily work with gains and resource accumulation; this supports earnings through employment, professional networks or sustained client service.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, enterprise and forceful pursuit of gains, although it can encourage speculative or overly assertive decisions.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/reference/houseSignifications/5","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Sun in the 3rd supports self-directed effort, communication and courage, but its enemy dignity suggests that dealings with authority or recognition may periodically require extra tact and persistence.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Sun/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/3"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th introduce professional themes of large institutions, foreign environments, work behind the scenes, isolation or substantial expenditure; Saturn's enemy dignity makes these areas potential sources of delay or burden.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"Ketu's aspect on the natal 10th can produce periodic detachment from titles, unconventional career turns or dissatisfaction even when objective professional standing is sound.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The D10 reinforces earning and public-expression potential: Sun, Moon and Venus occupy the 2nd house, while Mercury occupies the 11th in Sagittarius, favoring communication, advice, networks and gains from professional knowledge.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter in the 6th supports service, administration and solving operational problems, though its conjunction by house with Rahu can bring competitive, politically complex or unconventional work environments.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Mars in the 9th in Libra supports initiative in consulting, policy, higher knowledge or long-distance professional activity, with success depending on balanced collaboration rather than unilateral action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2/house","/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign","/reference/houseSignifications/9"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn in its own sign Capricorn in the 12th gives endurance and organizational capacity in institutional, foreign or behind-the-scenes settings, but also indicates slow progress, heavy responsibility or periods of professional seclusion.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No profession, employment history or career goals were supplied, so the indicated fields cannot be matched against lived outcomes.","Shadbala, avasthas and detailed D10 aspects or lordship analysis are not supplied, limiting finer ranking of planetary strength."],"rationale":"The strongest evidence is the lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th and the 10th lord Mercury in the wealth-producing 2nd with Venus. The 6th and 11th lord's connection to the 2nd, Mars's strength and aspect to the 11th, and supportive D10 placements for Mercury and the 2nd house collectively favor a substantial career built through knowledge, communication, administration, finance, consulting or institutional service. The principal counterweights are Jupiter's imperfect dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house signatures in both D1 and D10, which can create delays, foreign or behind-the-scenes work, changing attachment to status, and periods of withdrawal or elevated expenditure. Overall, career potential is supportive but more consistent with gradual, responsibility-heavy achievement than effortless advancement."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The career axis is prominent because Jupiter, the lagna lord, occupies the 10th house, linking identity and life direction directly with profession, status and public responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 10th forms the chart's stated raja yoga through its lordship of both the 1st and 4th houses, supporting leadership, recognition and constructive institutional roles.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\",\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity in Virgo, so professional authority may develop through revision, experience and problem-solving rather than through an entirely smooth or conventional rise.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with income, accumulated resources, speech, analysis and advisory or commercial skills.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, strengthening diplomacy, communication, negotiation, financial judgment and the ability to earn through refined intellectual or client-facing work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 6th lord Venus and 11th lord Venus are also in the 2nd, linking service and daily work with gains and resource accumulation; this supports earnings through employment, professional networks or sustained client service.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, enterprise and forceful pursuit of gains, although it can encourage speculative or overly assertive decisions.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Sun in the 3rd supports self-directed effort, communication and courage, but its enemy dignity suggests that dealings with authority or recognition may periodically require extra tact and persistence.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Sun/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/3\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th introduce professional themes of large institutions, foreign environments, work behind the scenes, isolation or substantial expenditure; Saturn's enemy dignity makes these areas potential sources of delay or burden.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"Ketu's aspect on the natal 10th can produce periodic detachment from titles, unconventional career turns or dissatisfaction even when objective professional standing is sound.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 reinforces earning and public-expression potential: Sun, Moon and Venus occupy the 2nd house, while Mercury occupies the 11th in Sagittarius, favoring communication, advice, networks and gains from professional knowledge.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter in the 6th supports service, administration and solving operational problems, though its conjunction by house with Rahu can bring competitive, politically complex or unconventional work environments.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Mars in the 9th in Libra supports initiative in consulting, policy, higher knowledge or long-distance professional activity, with success depending on balanced collaboration rather than unilateral action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/9\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn in its own sign Capricorn in the 12th gives endurance and organizational capacity in institutional, foreign or behind-the-scenes settings, but also indicates slow progress, heavy responsibility or periods of professional seclusion.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No profession, employment history or career goals were supplied, so the indicated fields cannot be matched against lived outcomes.\",\"Shadbala, avasthas and detailed D10 aspects or lordship analysis are not supplied, limiting finer ranking of planetary strength.\"],\"rationale\":\"The strongest evidence is the lagna lord Jupiter in the 10th and the 10th lord Mercury in the wealth-producing 2nd with Venus. The 6th and 11th lord's connection to the 2nd, Mars's strength and aspect to the 11th, and supportive D10 placements for Mercury and the 2nd house collectively favor a substantial career built through knowledge, communication, administration, finance, consulting or institutional service. The principal counterweights are Jupiter's imperfect dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house signatures in both D1 and D10, which can create delays, foreign or behind-the-scenes work, changing attachment to status, and periods of withdrawal or elevated expenditure. Overall, career potential is supportive but more consistent with gradual, responsibility-heavy achievement than effortless advancement.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The career axis is prominent because lagna lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking identity and life direction directly with profession, status, counsel, and public responsibility.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/houses/9/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, information, and family or institutional assets.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, supporting polished communication, negotiation, commercial judgment, advisory work, and monetization of intellectual or interpersonal skills.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/isBenefic","/placements/Venus/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in enemy dignity, so professional growth may involve revisions, non-linear advancement, or tension between ideals and practical institutional demands rather than effortless recognition.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"The natal 10th house receives Ketu's aspect, indicating periodic detachment from titles, changes of professional direction, unconventional work conditions, or dissatisfaction even when external achievement is present.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, technical or entrepreneurial capacity, and the conversion of creativity into gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/sign","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/reference/houseSignifications/5","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus is in the 2nd, forming a direct relationship between gains and accumulated wealth; this supports income through professional networks, clients, communication, or value-oriented activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th emphasize work connected with large institutions, foreign environments, remote or behind-the-scenes operations, regulated systems, research, or periods of professional isolation and heavy expenditure of effort.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/occupants","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house in Sagittarius, reinforcing gains through intellect, communication, administration, consulting, commerce, or network-based professional activity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign","/vargas/D10/meaning"]},{"claim":"The D10 places Sun, Moon, and Venus together in the 2nd house, emphasizing professional income, reputation expressed through speech, stakeholder relations, presentation, and the management of resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/house"]},{"claim":"D10 Jupiter in the 6th favors service, problem-solving, competition, administration, and responsibility, though it can bring demanding routines or conflict-management duties.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"D10 Saturn occupies Capricorn in the 12th, showing strong capacity for disciplined work in institutional, foreign, secluded, compliance-oriented, or long-horizon settings, but with possible delay, invisibility, or work-life sacrifice.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"The chart explicitly identifies Jupiter as producing a raja yoga through rulership of the 1st and 4th houses, adding potential for responsibility, standing, and constructive leadership when Jupiter-related factors are activated.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/grahas","/yogas/0/because"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"The strongest pattern is the mutual linkage of self, career, and wealth: lagna lord Jupiter is in the 10th, while 10th lord Mercury is in the 2nd with Venus. The D10 repeats the income and communication emphasis through Mercury in the 11th and a three-graha concentration in the 2nd. This supports advisory, analytical, administrative, financial, commercial, educational, consulting, communication-heavy, or institutional work, with scope for leadership and independent strategy. The principal counterweights are Jupiter's compromised dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house signatures in both D1 and D10; these suggest a less linear career, periodic disengagement from status, and substantial behind-the-scenes or foreign/institutional themes. Overall, the chart is supportive for durable professional accomplishment, but recognition and satisfaction are likely to develop through persistence, specialization, and adaptability rather than an uninterrupted conventional rise."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The career axis is prominent because lagna lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, linking identity and life direction directly with profession, status, counsel, and public responsibility.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/houses/9/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, connecting career with earnings, accumulated resources, speech, analysis, information, and family or institutional assets.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury shares the 2nd house with benefic Venus, supporting polished communication, negotiation, commercial judgment, advisory work, and monetization of intellectual or interpersonal skills.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/isBenefic\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter in the 10th is retrograde and in enemy dignity, so professional growth may involve revisions, non-linear advancement, or tension between ideals and practical institutional demands rather than effortless recognition.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The natal 10th house receives Ketu's aspect, indicating periodic detachment from titles, changes of professional direction, unconventional work conditions, or dissatisfaction even when external achievement is present.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies its own sign in the 5th and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategic intelligence, independent decision-making, technical or entrepreneurial capacity, and the conversion of creativity into gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/sign\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus is in the 2nd, forming a direct relationship between gains and accumulated wealth; this supports income through professional networks, clients, communication, or value-oriented activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Rahu in the 12th emphasize work connected with large institutions, foreign environments, remote or behind-the-scenes operations, regulated systems, research, or periods of professional isolation and heavy expenditure of effort.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/occupants\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the D10, Mercury occupies the 11th house in Sagittarius, reinforcing gains through intellect, communication, administration, consulting, commerce, or network-based professional activity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/meaning\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 places Sun, Moon, and Venus together in the 2nd house, emphasizing professional income, reputation expressed through speech, stakeholder relations, presentation, and the management of resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Jupiter in the 6th favors service, problem-solving, competition, administration, and responsibility, though it can bring demanding routines or conflict-management duties.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"D10 Saturn occupies Capricorn in the 12th, showing strong capacity for disciplined work in institutional, foreign, secluded, compliance-oriented, or long-horizon settings, but with possible delay, invisibility, or work-life sacrifice.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/dispositor\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"The chart explicitly identifies Jupiter as producing a raja yoga through rulership of the 1st and 4th houses, adding potential for responsibility, standing, and constructive leadership when Jupiter-related factors are activated.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/grahas\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"The strongest pattern is the mutual linkage of self, career, and wealth: lagna lord Jupiter is in the 10th, while 10th lord Mercury is in the 2nd with Venus. The D10 repeats the income and communication emphasis through Mercury in the 11th and a three-graha concentration in the 2nd. This supports advisory, analytical, administrative, financial, commercial, educational, consulting, communication-heavy, or institutional work, with scope for leadership and independent strategy. The principal counterweights are Jupiter's compromised dignity, Ketu's influence on the 10th, and strong 12th-house signatures in both D1 and D10; these suggest a less linear career, periodic disengagement from status, and substantial behind-the-scenes or foreign/institutional themes. Overall, the chart is supportive for durable professional accomplishment, but recognition and satisfaction are likely to develop through persistence, specialization, and adaptability rather than an uninterrupted conventional rise.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"career","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.84,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The primary career signature is strong: lagna lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, directly connecting personal direction with career, status and public action.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/reference/houseSignifications/10"]},{"claim":"Jupiter also rules the 4th house, and the chart explicitly identifies its combined 1st- and 4th-house lordship as a Raja Yoga; this supports responsibility, visibility and potential advancement.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/0/lord","/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/0/name","/yogas/0/because"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, linking career with income, accumulated resources, speech, family enterprise or knowledge-based work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Mercury conjoins Venus in the 2nd house. This favors careers combining communication, analysis or commerce with diplomacy, presentation, client relations or value creation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house"]},{"claim":"The 11th lord Venus also occupies the 2nd house, creating a direct relationship between gains and accumulated resources; however, outcomes remain dependent on sustained professional execution rather than guaranteed wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11","/reference/houseSignifications/2"]},{"claim":"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategy, technical or entrepreneurial intelligence and the ability to convert personal effort into gains; it can also produce competitiveness or risk-taking.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Mars/house","/aspects/Mars","/reference/houseSignifications/5","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"The D10 reinforces earnings and network potential: Mercury occupies the 11th, while Sun, Moon and Venus occupy the 2nd. This favors career gains through communication, organizations, reputation and resource-facing responsibilities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/3/house","/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/0/house","/vargas/D10/placements/1/house","/vargas/D10/placements/5/house","/vargas/D10/meaning"]},{"claim":"The D10 also emphasizes service and problem-solving because Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 6th house. This can suit complex institutions, operations, competition or difficult assignments, but may bring workplace politics and uneven routines.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4/house","/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha","/vargas/D10/placements/7/house","/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha","/reference/houseSignifications/6"]},{"claim":"Saturn and Ketu occupy the D10 12th house, while natal Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th. This adds themes of large or remote institutions, foreign environments, behind-the-scenes work, expenditure and periodic professional isolation or detachment.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/6/house","/vargas/D10/placements/8/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"Career growth is not entirely smooth: natal Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity, and Ketu aspects the 10th house. These factors can manifest as revisions of direction, dissatisfaction with conventional status or intermittent discontinuity despite the strong 10th-house foundation.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/retrograde","/placements/Jupiter/dignity","/houses/9/aspectedBy","/aspects/Ketu"]},{"claim":"The current Saturn mahadasha places emphasis on long-term discipline and 12th-house Saturn themes; the Mercury antardasha activates the 10th lord and therefore makes professional organization, communication and financial decisions especially relevant during the stated period.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord","/dasha/current/mahadasha/from","/dasha/current/mahadasha/to","/placements/Saturn/house","/dasha/current/antardasha/lord","/dasha/current/antardasha/from","/dasha/current/antardasha/to","/houses/9/lord"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No Shadbala, Ashtakavarga or quantified varga strength is supplied, so the relative strength of competing career factors cannot be ranked numerically.","No profession history, education record or occupational alternatives are provided, so specific job titles cannot be selected reliably."],"rationale":"The chart is career-supportive because the lagna lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects profession with the wealth house, the 11th lord reinforces resource accumulation, and the D10 repeats strong 2nd- and 11th-house themes. The principal conflict is between this advancement potential and substantial 6th/12th-house emphasis, plus a weakened retrograde Jupiter and Ketu's influence on the 10th. The synthesis therefore favors meaningful advancement through analytical, advisory, communicative, commercial, institutional or resource-management work, but with periodic redirection, heavy responsibility or behind-the-scenes phases rather than a uniformly linear career."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.84,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The primary career signature is strong: lagna lord Jupiter occupies the 10th house, directly connecting personal direction with career, status and public action.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/10\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter also rules the 4th house, and the chart explicitly identifies its combined 1st- and 4th-house lordship as a Raja Yoga; this supports responsibility, visibility and potential advancement.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/0/name\",\"/yogas/0/because\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mercury is placed in the 2nd house, linking career with income, accumulated resources, speech, family enterprise or knowledge-based work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury conjoins Venus in the 2nd house. This favors careers combining communication, analysis or commerce with diplomacy, presentation, client relations or value creation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th lord Venus also occupies the 2nd house, creating a direct relationship between gains and accumulated resources; however, outcomes remain dependent on sustained professional execution rather than guaranteed wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars is in its own sign in the 5th house and aspects the 11th, supporting initiative, strategy, technical or entrepreneurial intelligence and the ability to convert personal effort into gains; it can also produce competitiveness or risk-taking.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 reinforces earnings and network potential: Mercury occupies the 11th, while Sun, Moon and Venus occupy the 2nd. This favors career gains through communication, organizations, reputation and resource-facing responsibilities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/1/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5/house\",\"/vargas/D10/meaning\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 also emphasizes service and problem-solving because Jupiter and Rahu occupy the 6th house. This can suit complex institutions, operations, competition or difficult assignments, but may bring workplace politics and uneven routines.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4/graha\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/7/graha\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/6\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn and Ketu occupy the D10 12th house, while natal Saturn and Rahu occupy the 12th. This adds themes of large or remote institutions, foreign environments, behind-the-scenes work, expenditure and periodic professional isolation or detachment.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/6/house\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/8/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career growth is not entirely smooth: natal Jupiter is retrograde and in enemy dignity, and Ketu aspects the 10th house. These factors can manifest as revisions of direction, dissatisfaction with conventional status or intermittent discontinuity despite the strong 10th-house foundation.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/retrograde\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Ketu\"]},{\"claim\":\"The current Saturn mahadasha places emphasis on long-term discipline and 12th-house Saturn themes; the Mercury antardasha activates the 10th lord and therefore makes professional organization, communication and financial decisions especially relevant during the stated period.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/from\",\"/dasha/current/mahadasha/to\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/lord\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/from\",\"/dasha/current/antardasha/to\",\"/houses/9/lord\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No Shadbala, Ashtakavarga or quantified varga strength is supplied, so the relative strength of competing career factors cannot be ranked numerically.\",\"No profession history, education record or occupational alternatives are provided, so specific job titles cannot be selected reliably.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is career-supportive because the lagna lord occupies the 10th, the 10th lord connects profession with the wealth house, the 11th lord reinforces resource accumulation, and the D10 repeats strong 2nd- and 11th-house themes. The principal conflict is between this advancement potential and substantial 6th/12th-house emphasis, plus a weakened retrograde Jupiter and Ketu's influence on the 10th. The synthesis therefore favors meaningful advancement through analytical, advisory, communicative, commercial, institutional or resource-management work, but with periodic redirection, heavy responsibility or behind-the-scenes phases rather than a uniformly linear career.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"career","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places the tenth lord, Mars, in the second house rather than the first, so the stated tenth-lord-in-first rule does not apply.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"Although this is framed as a supportive rule, its required placement is absent: the tenth lord is in house 2, not house 1.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required first-house placement is absent, and a placement rule would not by itself guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The required first-house placement is absent; moreover, the absolute claim of necessary career dependence is not established by the stated rule.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option D applies because the chart explicitly shows the tenth lord placed in the second house. Therefore none of A-C is established by this chart, and no supportive or challenging career polarity can be assigned from those statements."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places the tenth lord, Mars, in the second house rather than the first, so the stated tenth-lord-in-first rule does not apply.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Although this is framed as a supportive rule, its required placement is absent: the tenth lord is in house 2, not house 1.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required first-house placement is absent, and a placement rule would not by itself guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The required first-house placement is absent; moreover, the absolute claim of necessary career dependence is not established by the stated rule.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option D applies because the chart explicitly shows the tenth lord placed in the second house. Therefore none of A-C is established by this chart, and no supportive or challenging career polarity can be assigned from those statements.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/sign","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"For the listed rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is treated primarily as supportive of gains rather than as a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is computed in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in the eleventh, whose significations include gains and income. This supports earning capacity but cannot justify a guaranteed magnitude of profit."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/sign\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"For the listed rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is treated primarily as supportive of gains rather than as a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is computed in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in the eleventh, whose significations include gains and income. This supports earning capacity but cannot justify a guaranteed magnitude of profit.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is a gains-supporting indication, not primarily a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Sun in the eleventh house, whose significations include gains and income. This supports earning capacity without guaranteeing any particular magnitude of profit."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement is supportive of gains but does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is a gains-supporting indication, not primarily a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A applies. The chart explicitly places the ascendant lord Sun in the eleventh house, whose significations include gains and income. This supports earning capacity without guaranteeing any particular magnitude of profit.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/10/significations"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"This placement is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The ascendant lord in the eleventh is treated here as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/significations"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly shown in house 11.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The chart identifies Sun as ascendant lord and places it in the eleventh, whose significations include gains and income. This is a supportive indication, not a guarantee of exceptional profits and not primarily a loss indication."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"This placement is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The ascendant lord in the eleventh is treated here as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly shown in house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The chart identifies Sun as ascendant lord and places it in the eleventh, whose significations include gains and income. This is a supportive indication, not a guarantee of exceptional profits and not primarily a loss indication.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"career","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places the tenth lord, Mars, in the second house rather than the first, so the shared premise of statements A-C is not established.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"This rule is inapplicable because the tenth lord is placed in house 2, not house 1.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The placement premise is absent, and a single placement would not by itself guarantee fame.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The placement premise is absent; moreover, tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication.","evidence":["/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option D applies. The computed chart fact states that the tenth lord is Mars and is placed in the second house, so none of the first-house statements A-C can be applied."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places the tenth lord, Mars, in the second house rather than the first, so the shared premise of statements A-C is not established.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"This rule is inapplicable because the tenth lord is placed in house 2, not house 1.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The placement premise is absent, and a single placement would not by itself guarantee fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The placement premise is absent; moreover, tenth lord in the first is not necessarily a dependent-career indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option D applies. The computed chart fact states that the tenth lord is Mars and is placed in the second house, so none of the first-house statements A-C can be applied.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"career-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"career-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"career","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places the tenth lord in the second house, so the shared premise of statements A-C—tenth lord in the first—is not present.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"This rule is inapplicable because the tenth lord is recorded in house 2, not house 1.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required placement is absent; moreover, a single placement would not justify a guarantee of fame.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The required placement is absent, so this claim cannot be applied to the chart.","evidence":["/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only option D applies. The supplied chart fact records the tenth lord as placed in the second house rather than the first, leaving none of A-C established for this chart."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"career-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"career\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places the tenth lord in the second house, so the shared premise of statements A-C—tenth lord in the first—is not present.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"This rule is inapplicable because the tenth lord is recorded in house 2, not house 1.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is absent; moreover, a single placement would not justify a guarantee of fame.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is absent, so this claim cannot be applied to the chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only option D applies. The supplied chart fact records the tenth lord as placed in the second house rather than the first, leaving none of A-C established for this chart.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord is the Sun, and it occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is primarily supportive of gains rather than a primary financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in house 11.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only A applies. The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun is placed in the eleventh house of gains and income. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord is the Sun, and it occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, the ascendant lord in the eleventh is primarily supportive of gains rather than a primary financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the chart explicitly places the ascendant lord in house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only A applies. The Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun is placed in the eleventh house of gains and income. B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity; therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord is the Sun, and it occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the eleventh as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the Sun is the ascendant lord and is placed in the eleventh house.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Only statement A correctly applies the listed rule to the computed chart. The eleventh house signifies gains and income, and the Leo ascendant lord Sun occupies that house. The rule is supportive rather than a guarantee, so B is excessive, C reverses the rule's polarity, and D is false."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord is the Sun, and it occupies the eleventh house; under the stated rule, this supports gains and earning capacity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh is supportive, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule treats the ascendant lord in the eleventh as supportive of gains, not primarily as a financial-loss indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the Sun is the ascendant lord and is placed in the eleventh house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Only statement A correctly applies the listed rule to the computed chart. The eleventh house signifies gains and income, and the Leo ascendant lord Sun occupies that house. The rule is supportive rather than a guarantee, so B is excessive, C reverses the rule's polarity, and D is false.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["A"],"factors":[{"claim":"The ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house, supporting gains and earning capacity under the stated rule.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh may support gains, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"doctrinal","correction":"Under the stated rule, this placement is supportive of gains rather than primarily indicative of financial loss.","evidence":["/lagna/lordInHouse","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"statement_id":"D","error_type":"factual","correction":"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly placed in house 11.","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option A directly matches the computed chart: Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house of gains and income. Option B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity. Therefore D is also inapplicable."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"A\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The ascendant lord Sun is placed in the eleventh house, supporting gains and earning capacity under the stated rule.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Placement of the ascendant lord in the eleventh may support gains, but it does not guarantee enormous profits.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"doctrinal\",\"correction\":\"Under the stated rule, this placement is supportive of gains rather than primarily indicative of financial loss.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"D\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Statement A is established because the ascendant lord is explicitly placed in house 11.\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option A directly matches the computed chart: Leo ascendant is ruled by the Sun, and the Sun occupies the eleventh house of gains and income. Option B improperly converts a supportive indication into a guarantee, while C reverses the rule's polarity. Therefore D is also inapplicable.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.88,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The strongest wealth indicator is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying the 11th in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity. This supports earning capacity, gains, and wealth accumulation through networks or large organizations.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1","/houses/10","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's conjunction with ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th directly links personal effort and life direction with income and fulfillment of material aims; the chart explicitly identifies this combination as Dhana Yoga.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/10/occupants","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Venus, the favorable ruler of the 4th and 9th houses, is strong in its own Libra sign in the 9th. Its conjunction with 5th-lord Mercury forms a Raja Yoga, supporting fortune, education, judgment, and opportunities that can indirectly improve prosperity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The exalted Moon in the 4th gives underlying material stability and can support property, comforts, and assets connected with the home.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/sign","/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/3/significations"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mars participates in a Raja Yoga through mutual aspect with ascendant lord Saturn, linking career activity with the 11th-house sphere of gains. This favors gains through initiative, technical or competitive work, although results may require sustained effort.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"The 11th house is also pressured by aspects from Mars and Rahu. This can produce volatility, aggressive financial decisions, irregular gains, or periods in which ambition outruns prudent planning.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Rahu"]},{"claim":"Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th can make gains gradual, delayed, responsibility-laden, or dependent on long-term organization rather than quick returns. Because Saturn also rules the 12th, earnings may be accompanied by substantial expenses or obligations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/occupants","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the speculative 5th house in enemy dignity and receives Saturn's aspect. This cautions against impulsive speculation and suggests that disciplined, researched strategies are more suitable than high-risk bets.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect while its lord is strongly placed in the 11th. This is mixed: the lord strongly supports accumulation, but pride, authority-related obligations, or abrupt financial priorities may periodically affect savings.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No D2 Hora chart is provided, so the natal wealth assessment cannot be cross-checked in the primary wealth divisional chart.","No specific date or financial event was requested; therefore dasha and transit timing has not been used."],"rationale":"The wealth outlook is broadly supportive because the same strong Jupiter governs both principal wealth houses and occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, where it joins ascendant lord Saturn and forms explicit Dhana Yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury in the 9th, an exalted Moon in the 4th, and career-to-gains connections add further support. The main qualifications are pressure on the 11th from Mars and Rahu, Saturn's tendency toward delayed or obligation-linked gains, and affliction of the speculative 5th. Overall, the chart favors durable prosperity built through expertise, institutions, networks, disciplined work, and long-term accumulation more than rapid or highly speculative enrichment."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.88,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The strongest wealth indicator is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying the 11th in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity. This supports earning capacity, gains, and wealth accumulation through networks or large organizations.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1\",\"/houses/10\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's conjunction with ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th directly links personal effort and life direction with income and fulfillment of material aims; the chart explicitly identifies this combination as Dhana Yoga.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, the favorable ruler of the 4th and 9th houses, is strong in its own Libra sign in the 9th. Its conjunction with 5th-lord Mercury forms a Raja Yoga, supporting fortune, education, judgment, and opportunities that can indirectly improve prosperity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exalted Moon in the 4th gives underlying material stability and can support property, comforts, and assets connected with the home.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/3/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mars participates in a Raja Yoga through mutual aspect with ascendant lord Saturn, linking career activity with the 11th-house sphere of gains. This favors gains through initiative, technical or competitive work, although results may require sustained effort.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th house is also pressured by aspects from Mars and Rahu. This can produce volatility, aggressive financial decisions, irregular gains, or periods in which ambition outruns prudent planning.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Rahu\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th can make gains gradual, delayed, responsibility-laden, or dependent on long-term organization rather than quick returns. Because Saturn also rules the 12th, earnings may be accompanied by substantial expenses or obligations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/occupants\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the speculative 5th house in enemy dignity and receives Saturn's aspect. This cautions against impulsive speculation and suggests that disciplined, researched strategies are more suitable than high-risk bets.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect while its lord is strongly placed in the 11th. This is mixed: the lord strongly supports accumulation, but pride, authority-related obligations, or abrupt financial priorities may periodically affect savings.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No D2 Hora chart is provided, so the natal wealth assessment cannot be cross-checked in the primary wealth divisional chart.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested; therefore dasha and transit timing has not been used.\"],\"rationale\":\"The wealth outlook is broadly supportive because the same strong Jupiter governs both principal wealth houses and occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, where it joins ascendant lord Saturn and forms explicit Dhana Yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury in the 9th, an exalted Moon in the 4th, and career-to-gains connections add further support. The main qualifications are pressure on the 11th from Mars and Rahu, Saturn's tendency toward delayed or obligation-linked gains, and affliction of the speculative 5th. Overall, the chart favors durable prosperity built through expertise, institutions, networks, disciplined work, and long-term accumulation more than rapid or highly speculative enrichment.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.92,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The strongest wealth indication is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying its own 11th-house sign in moolatrikona dignity. This supports earnings, asset accumulation, and gains through networks or institutions.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter joins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th house, explicitly forming Dhana Yogas that connect personal effort and life direction with income and accumulation.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Yogakaraka Venus is strong in its own sign in the 9th house and conjoins 5th-lord Mercury, creating a Raja Yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment, advisory ability, and opportunities that can indirectly produce prosperity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/lord","/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 10th lord Mars and ascendant lord Saturn mutually aspect one another, linking profession and personal agency; the chart identifies this as a Raja Yoga, suggesting that sustained action can translate into status and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Saturn","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"The exalted Moon in the 4th house can support material security, property-related comfort, and a stable resource base, although it is also the 6th lord and may connect such matters with work, obligations, or liabilities.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/5/lord","/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/3/significations","/houses/5/significations"]},{"claim":"The 11th house is afflicted by the aspects of Mars and Rahu. This can make income ambitious or irregular and may bring competition, volatility, or excessive risk-taking into financial decisions.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Rahu","/placements/Mars/dignity","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect while its lord is strong. This does not cancel the wealth promise, but it can introduce pride, authority conflicts, or sharp family and financial decisions that require restraint.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/aspectedBy","/aspects/Sun","/placements/Sun/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn rules both the ascendant and the 12th house and sits in the 11th. This can produce gains through persistence, large organizations, foreign links, or long time horizons, while also tying income to recurring expenditure or delayed gratification.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the 5th house in enemy dignity, so speculation and high-risk investments are less consistently supported than wealth built through disciplined work, knowledge, and networks.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/4/significations","/houses/4/aspectedBy"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No wealth-specific divisional chart such as D2 Hora is provided.","No current financial circumstances, assets, debts, occupation, or investment behavior are supplied; therefore the synthesis describes natal potential rather than actual net worth.","No target date or financial event is specified, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed."],"rationale":"The chart is fundamentally supportive for wealth because the combined 2nd-and-11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well placed in the 11th and joins the ascendant lord, producing explicit Dhana Yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury in the 9th add fortune, judgment, education, and opportunity, while the career–ascendant lord relationship can convert sustained effort into gains. The promise is moderated rather than negated by Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's participation in the income house, and a less stable speculative signature. Overall, the chart favors gradual, structured accumulation through profession, expertise, institutions, and networks more than effortless windfalls or aggressive speculation."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.92,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The strongest wealth indication is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying its own 11th-house sign in moolatrikona dignity. This supports earnings, asset accumulation, and gains through networks or institutions.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter joins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th house, explicitly forming Dhana Yogas that connect personal effort and life direction with income and accumulation.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Yogakaraka Venus is strong in its own sign in the 9th house and conjoins 5th-lord Mercury, creating a Raja Yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment, advisory ability, and opportunities that can indirectly produce prosperity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/lord\",\"/houses/8/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 10th lord Mars and ascendant lord Saturn mutually aspect one another, linking profession and personal agency; the chart identifies this as a Raja Yoga, suggesting that sustained action can translate into status and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exalted Moon in the 4th house can support material security, property-related comfort, and a stable resource base, although it is also the 6th lord and may connect such matters with work, obligations, or liabilities.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/5/lord\",\"/houses/5/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/3/significations\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 11th house is afflicted by the aspects of Mars and Rahu. This can make income ambitious or irregular and may bring competition, volatility, or excessive risk-taking into financial decisions.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Rahu\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect while its lord is strong. This does not cancel the wealth promise, but it can introduce pride, authority conflicts, or sharp family and financial decisions that require restraint.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Sun\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn rules both the ascendant and the 12th house and sits in the 11th. This can produce gains through persistence, large organizations, foreign links, or long time horizons, while also tying income to recurring expenditure or delayed gratification.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the 5th house in enemy dignity, so speculation and high-risk investments are less consistently supported than wealth built through disciplined work, knowledge, and networks.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/4/significations\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No wealth-specific divisional chart such as D2 Hora is provided.\",\"No current financial circumstances, assets, debts, occupation, or investment behavior are supplied; therefore the synthesis describes natal potential rather than actual net worth.\",\"No target date or financial event is specified, so dasha and transit timing is not assessed.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is fundamentally supportive for wealth because the combined 2nd-and-11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well placed in the 11th and joins the ascendant lord, producing explicit Dhana Yogas. Strong Venus and Mercury in the 9th add fortune, judgment, education, and opportunity, while the career–ascendant lord relationship can convert sustained effort into gains. The promise is moderated rather than negated by Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's participation in the income house, and a less stable speculative signature. Overall, the chart favors gradual, structured accumulation through profession, expertise, institutions, and networks more than effortless windfalls or aggressive speculation.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The strongest wealth indicator is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying the 11th in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity. This supports earning capacity, gains, and wealth accumulation through networks or large organizations.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/sign","/houses/2/lord","/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter joins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th, explicitly forming dhana yogas that connect personal effort and life direction with income and accumulated wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"The 9th house is unusually strong: its lord Venus occupies its own sign there and conjoins Mercury, producing both a conjunction-based raja yoga and Venus's single-lordship raja yoga. This can support prosperity through education, counsel, commerce, intellectual work, institutions, travel, or fortunate opportunities.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Mercury/dignity","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The exalted Moon in the 4th supports material security and assets associated with home, property, vehicles, or education, although the chart alone does not guarantee gains from any particular asset class.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/sign","/placements/Moon/dignity","/houses/4/significations"]},{"claim":"Career can contribute substantially to wealth because 10th lord Mars participates in a mutual-aspect raja yoga with ascendant lord Saturn, and the D10 places Mars in its own sign in the 10th house.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/yogas/2","/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign","/vargas/D10/placements/2/house"]},{"claim":"Income may not be entirely smooth: the 11th house and its occupants receive aspects from Mars and Rahu, introducing volatility, competitiveness, ambitious risk-taking, or periodic disruptions around gains and networks.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/11/aspectedBy","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Rahu","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th can favor durable gains through patience and sustained effort, but may also delay fulfillment or make income dependent on long-term structures and responsibilities.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/11/occupants"]},{"claim":"Because Saturn rules the 12th as well as the ascendant and is placed in the 11th, gains may be accompanied by significant expenditure, foreign or institutional commitments, or periodic diversion of income toward obligations.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/12/lord","/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/12/significations"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th, linking savings and family resources with transformation or sudden financial developments; this favors caution around concentrated exposure and irregular obligations.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Sun/house","/houses/2/aspectedBy","/houses/8/significations"]},{"claim":"Mars, the career lord, occupies the 5th in enemy dignity. This may encourage entrepreneurial or speculative initiative, but it also warns against impulsive speculation as a primary wealth strategy.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/10/lord","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/5/significations"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["No D2 Hora chart is provided for additional confirmation of wealth strength and accumulation patterns.","No Ashtakavarga, shadbala, or other quantified strength measures are provided.","No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used."],"rationale":"The chart is wealth-supportive overall. Its central signature is the strong 2nd-and-11th lord Jupiter in moolatrikona dignity in the 11th, joined by ascendant lord Saturn and recognized by the supplied chart as forming dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury, an exalted Moon, and career reinforcement in the D10 broaden the routes through which prosperity may develop. The main qualifications are Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's connection with gains, the Sun's influence on the 2nd from the 8th, and a potentially speculative Mars in the 5th. These factors suggest meaningful earning and accumulation potential, but with delays, obligations, expenditure, and occasional volatility requiring disciplined financial management rather than promising uniformly easy gains."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-paraphrase\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The strongest wealth indicator is Jupiter ruling both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income, while occupying the 11th in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity. This supports earning capacity, gains, and wealth accumulation through networks or large organizations.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/sign\",\"/houses/2/lord\",\"/houses/2/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter joins ascendant lord Saturn in the 11th, explicitly forming dhana yogas that connect personal effort and life direction with income and accumulated wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 9th house is unusually strong: its lord Venus occupies its own sign there and conjoins Mercury, producing both a conjunction-based raja yoga and Venus's single-lordship raja yoga. This can support prosperity through education, counsel, commerce, intellectual work, institutions, travel, or fortunate opportunities.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Mercury/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The exalted Moon in the 4th supports material security and assets associated with home, property, vehicles, or education, although the chart alone does not guarantee gains from any particular asset class.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/sign\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/houses/4/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career can contribute substantially to wealth because 10th lord Mars participates in a mutual-aspect raja yoga with ascendant lord Saturn, and the D10 places Mars in its own sign in the 10th house.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/yogas/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/sign\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/2/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Income may not be entirely smooth: the 11th house and its occupants receive aspects from Mars and Rahu, introducing volatility, competitiveness, ambitious risk-taking, or periodic disruptions around gains and networks.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/aspectedBy\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Rahu\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn's conjunction with Jupiter in the 11th can favor durable gains through patience and sustained effort, but may also delay fulfillment or make income dependent on long-term structures and responsibilities.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/11/occupants\"]},{\"claim\":\"Because Saturn rules the 12th as well as the ascendant and is placed in the 11th, gains may be accompanied by significant expenditure, foreign or institutional commitments, or periodic diversion of income toward obligations.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/12/lord\",\"/houses/12/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/12/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house receives the Sun's aspect from the 8th, linking savings and family resources with transformation or sudden financial developments; this favors caution around concentrated exposure and irregular obligations.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/2/aspectedBy\",\"/houses/8/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars, the career lord, occupies the 5th in enemy dignity. This may encourage entrepreneurial or speculative initiative, but it also warns against impulsive speculation as a primary wealth strategy.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/5/significations\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"No D2 Hora chart is provided for additional confirmation of wealth strength and accumulation patterns.\",\"No Ashtakavarga, shadbala, or other quantified strength measures are provided.\",\"No specific date or financial event was requested, so dasha and transit timing has not been used.\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is wealth-supportive overall. Its central signature is the strong 2nd-and-11th lord Jupiter in moolatrikona dignity in the 11th, joined by ascendant lord Saturn and recognized by the supplied chart as forming dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury, an exalted Moon, and career reinforcement in the D10 broaden the routes through which prosperity may develop. The main qualifications are Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's connection with gains, the Sun's influence on the 2nd from the 8th, and a potentially speculative Mars in the 5th. These factors suggest meaningful earning and accumulation potential, but with delays, obligations, expenditure, and occasional volatility requiring disciplined financial management rather than promising uniformly easy gains.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart places the second-house lord, Venus, in the second house rather than the first, so the stated rule does not apply.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"Its required premise is absent: the second lord is placed in house 2, not house 1.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"Its required placement is absent, and an astrological placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"Its required premise is absent: the second lord is not in the first house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":[],"rationale":"Option D is applicable because none of A-C is established by the supplied chart: Venus, the second lord, is recorded in the second house. Accordingly, no supportive or challenging wealth polarity from the stated first-house rule can be assigned."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart places the second-house lord, Venus, in the second house rather than the first, so the stated rule does not apply.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Its required premise is absent: the second lord is placed in house 2, not house 1.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"Its required placement is absent, and an astrological placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"Its required premise is absent: the second lord is not in the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[],\"rationale\":\"Option D is applicable because none of A-C is established by the supplied chart: Venus, the second lord, is recorded in the second house. Accordingly, no supportive or challenging wealth polarity from the stated first-house rule can be assigned.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The primary wealth axis is strong: the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, supporting income, accumulation, and gains through networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms stated dhana yogas connecting self and sustained effort with both accumulated wealth and income.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th links personal development and long-term effort directly to gains; Saturn can favor gradual, durable results rather than effortless or immediate wealth.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Yogakaraka Venus is in its own sign in the 9th and forms two stated raja yogas, strengthening fortune, assets, education, counsel, and opportunity as indirect wealth supports.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"The 5th lord Mercury joins Venus in the 9th, connecting intelligence, planning, and creativity with fortune; this is constructive for knowledge-based wealth, although it does not by itself guarantee speculative success.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Career can feed gains because 10th lord Mars aspects the 11th and participates in a raja yoga with lagna lord Saturn.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Mars/1","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Career execution has some volatility: Mars is in enemy dignity in the 5th, and its aspect to the 11th may produce competitive, uneven, or risk-sensitive income patterns.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars/1","/houses/10/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Rahu also aspects the 11th, adding ambition and potential for unconventional gains but increasing appetite, instability, or overextension around income and networks.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Rahu/2","/houses/10/aspectedBy","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Rahu/dignity"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house is empty but structurally well supported by its powerful lord Jupiter; the Sun's aspect can tie resources to authority or family pride while also creating occasional pressure around speech or financial control.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/1/aspectedBy","/placements/Sun/house"]},{"claim":"The D10 reinforces earning capacity through action and status: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th, while the Sun is in the 11th; however, Jupiter in the D10 12th suggests that professional gains may coexist with institutional, foreign, charitable, or overhead expenditure.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2","/vargas/D10/placements/0","/vargas/D10/placements/4"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th connects expenditure with income and networks, so gains may be accompanied by recurring obligations or reinvestment rather than remaining fully liquid.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart for a finer wealth assessment","Quantitative strength measures such as shadbala and ashtakavarga","Income, asset, debt, inheritance, and career history needed to validate how the combinations have manifested"],"rationale":"The dominant signal is favorable: both principal wealth houses are ruled by a strong Jupiter placed in its own 11th house, where it joins lagna lord Saturn and forms explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury, plus career-to-gains links, broaden the sources of prosperity. The main counterweights are Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's connection to gains, and mixed expenditure indications in D10. Thus the chart supports meaningful wealth-building potential, especially through sustained work, knowledge, institutions, and networks, but with variability, ambition-driven risk, and obligations requiring disciplined management rather than implying guaranteed riches."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The primary wealth axis is strong: the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter occupies its own 11th house in moolatrikona dignity, supporting income, accumulation, and gains through networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms stated dhana yogas connecting self and sustained effort with both accumulated wealth and income.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Lagna lord Saturn in the 11th links personal development and long-term effort directly to gains; Saturn can favor gradual, durable results rather than effortless or immediate wealth.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Yogakaraka Venus is in its own sign in the 9th and forms two stated raja yogas, strengthening fortune, assets, education, counsel, and opportunity as indirect wealth supports.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 5th lord Mercury joins Venus in the 9th, connecting intelligence, planning, and creativity with fortune; this is constructive for knowledge-based wealth, although it does not by itself guarantee speculative success.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career can feed gains because 10th lord Mars aspects the 11th and participates in a raja yoga with lagna lord Saturn.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Mars/1\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career execution has some volatility: Mars is in enemy dignity in the 5th, and its aspect to the 11th may produce competitive, uneven, or risk-sensitive income patterns.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars/1\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu also aspects the 11th, adding ambition and potential for unconventional gains but increasing appetite, instability, or overextension around income and networks.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Rahu/2\",\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house is empty but structurally well supported by its powerful lord Jupiter; the Sun's aspect can tie resources to authority or family pride while also creating occasional pressure around speech or financial control.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/1/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Sun/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"The D10 reinforces earning capacity through action and status: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th, while the Sun is in the 11th; however, Jupiter in the D10 12th suggests that professional gains may coexist with institutional, foreign, charitable, or overhead expenditure.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th connects expenditure with income and networks, so gains may be accompanied by recurring obligations or reinvestment rather than remaining fully liquid.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart for a finer wealth assessment\",\"Quantitative strength measures such as shadbala and ashtakavarga\",\"Income, asset, debt, inheritance, and career history needed to validate how the combinations have manifested\"],\"rationale\":\"The dominant signal is favorable: both principal wealth houses are ruled by a strong Jupiter placed in its own 11th house, where it joins lagna lord Saturn and forms explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury, plus career-to-gains links, broaden the sources of prosperity. The main counterweights are Mars and Rahu influencing the 11th, the 12th lord's connection to gains, and mixed expenditure indications in D10. Thus the chart supports meaningful wealth-building potential, especially through sustained work, knowledge, institutions, and networks, but with variability, ambition-driven risk, and obligations requiring disciplined management rather than implying guaranteed riches.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":1,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The supplied chart fact describes the first-house lord placed in the second house, not the second-house lord placed in the first; therefore none of A–C is established.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"The rule's required placement—second lord in the first—is not provided by this chart.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required placement is not shown, and an astrological placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The required placement is not shown; moreover, the stated rule does not establish it as primarily an inability-to-earn indication.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["The identity and house placement of the second-house lord."],"rationale":"Only the first-house record is supplied: its lord is Venus and that lord is placed in house 2. This is the converse of the placement assumed by A–C, so option D applies and no supportive or challenging wealth polarity can be inferred from the listed substantive statements."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The supplied chart fact describes the first-house lord placed in the second house, not the second-house lord placed in the first; therefore none of A–C is established.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The rule's required placement—second lord in the first—is not provided by this chart.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is not shown, and an astrological placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is not shown; moreover, the stated rule does not establish it as primarily an inability-to-earn indication.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"The identity and house placement of the second-house lord.\"],\"rationale\":\"Only the first-house record is supplied: its lord is Venus and that lord is placed in house 2. This is the converse of the placement assumed by A–C, so option D applies and no supportive or challenging wealth polarity can be inferred from the listed substantive statements.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":2,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.88,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The principal wealth axis is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income and gains, and occupies the 11th in moolatrikona dignity.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter is joined in the 11th by Saturn, the ascendant lord, directly connecting the native and sustained effort with income, networks and fulfilment of objectives; the chart explicitly identifies this as Dhana Yoga through both 2nd- and 11th-lord relationships.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/lagna/lord","/lagna/lordInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Jupiter/house","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"The 2nd house is unoccupied but its lord is strongly placed in the 11th, favoring accumulation through earnings rather than indicating an unsupported wealth house.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/occupants","/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Venus, ruler of the 4th and 9th, is in its own sign in the 9th. This strengthens fortune, assets and general prosperity support and forms a stated Raja Yoga.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/sign","/placements/Venus/dignity","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Mercury, lord of the 5th, joins Venus in the 9th, creating a stated kendra-trikona Raja Yoga and linking intelligence, planning and creativity with fortune and higher knowledge.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Mercury/house","/placements/Venus/house","/yogas/0"]},{"claim":"Career and gains are connected because 10th lord Mars aspects the 11th, while Mars and ascendant lord Saturn form a stated mutual-aspect Raja Yoga. This can support gains through initiative, enterprise or technically demanding work.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Mars","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"Mars occupies the speculative 5th in enemy dignity and aspects the 11th. This can produce ambition and active income generation, but also raises volatility and argues against treating speculative gains as consistently reliable.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/aspects/Mars","/reference/houseSignifications/5","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Rahu also aspects the 11th, potentially enlarging financial ambitions and gains through unconventional networks, but with greater variability or overreach.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/aspects/Rahu","/placements/Rahu/dignity","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]},{"claim":"Partnership-dependent wealth is less straightforward: Rahu occupies the 7th and the 7th lord Sun occupies the 8th, suggesting that contracts, joint finances or business alliances require careful governance and transparency.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/6/occupants","/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/reference/houseSignifications/7","/reference/houseSignifications/8"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th, linking gains with expenditure, foreign settings or institutions. This may support income from such channels, while also allowing earnings and outflows to remain interconnected.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12","/reference/houseSignifications/11"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart for dedicated wealth confirmation","Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures","Exact aspect strengths and applicable orb-based conjunction strengths","Income, asset, debt and professional history needed to validate manifestation"],"rationale":"The synthesis is supportive because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well situated in the 11th and joins the ascendant lord, producing two explicitly identified Dhana Yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury Raja Yogas add fortune, judgment and prosperity support, while the career lord connects with the gains house. The main qualifications are speculative volatility from Mars, amplification from Rahu, potentially complicated partnerships or joint finances, and a gains–expenditure linkage through Saturn. Overall, the chart indicates substantial wealth-building capacity through sustained work, knowledge, networks and career activity, but not a guarantee of uniformly stable returns."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.88,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The principal wealth axis is strong: Jupiter rules both the 2nd house of accumulated resources and the 11th house of income and gains, and occupies the 11th in moolatrikona dignity.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter is joined in the 11th by Saturn, the ascendant lord, directly connecting the native and sustained effort with income, networks and fulfilment of objectives; the chart explicitly identifies this as Dhana Yoga through both 2nd- and 11th-lord relationships.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/lagna/lord\",\"/lagna/lordInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 2nd house is unoccupied but its lord is strongly placed in the 11th, favoring accumulation through earnings rather than indicating an unsupported wealth house.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/occupants\",\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Venus, ruler of the 4th and 9th, is in its own sign in the 9th. This strengthens fortune, assets and general prosperity support and forms a stated Raja Yoga.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/sign\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mercury, lord of the 5th, joins Venus in the 9th, creating a stated kendra-trikona Raja Yoga and linking intelligence, planning and creativity with fortune and higher knowledge.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/yogas/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career and gains are connected because 10th lord Mars aspects the 11th, while Mars and ascendant lord Saturn form a stated mutual-aspect Raja Yoga. This can support gains through initiative, enterprise or technically demanding work.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"Mars occupies the speculative 5th in enemy dignity and aspects the 11th. This can produce ambition and active income generation, but also raises volatility and argues against treating speculative gains as consistently reliable.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Rahu also aspects the 11th, potentially enlarging financial ambitions and gains through unconventional networks, but with greater variability or overreach.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/aspects/Rahu\",\"/placements/Rahu/dignity\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]},{\"claim\":\"Partnership-dependent wealth is less straightforward: Rahu occupies the 7th and the 7th lord Sun occupies the 8th, suggesting that contracts, joint finances or business alliances require careful governance and transparency.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/6/occupants\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/7\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/8\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Saturn is placed in the 11th, linking gains with expenditure, foreign settings or institutions. This may support income from such channels, while also allowing earnings and outflows to remain interconnected.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/11\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart for dedicated wealth confirmation\",\"Shadbala and other quantitative strength measures\",\"Exact aspect strengths and applicable orb-based conjunction strengths\",\"Income, asset, debt and professional history needed to validate manifestation\"],\"rationale\":\"The synthesis is supportive because the 2nd and 11th lord Jupiter is exceptionally well situated in the 11th and joins the ascendant lord, producing two explicitly identified Dhana Yogas. Strong 9th-house Venus and Mercury Raja Yogas add fortune, judgment and prosperity support, while the career lord connects with the gains house. The main qualifications are speculative volatility from Mars, amplification from Rahu, potentially complicated partnerships or joint finances, and a gains–expenditure linkage through Saturn. Overall, the chart indicates substantial wealth-building capacity through sustained work, knowledge, networks and career activity, but not a guarantee of uniformly stable returns.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"supportive","confidence":0.9,"selected_option_ids":[],"factors":[{"claim":"The strongest wealth signature is the 2nd- and 11th-lord Jupiter occupying the 11th house in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity, directly strengthening accumulation, income and gains.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/1/lord","/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/10/lord","/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Jupiter/sign","/placements/Jupiter/dignity"]},{"claim":"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms the explicitly identified dhana yogas and connects personal effort and life direction with gains and networks.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Jupiter/house","/placements/Saturn/house","/houses/0/lord","/yogas/3","/yogas/4"]},{"claim":"Saturn in the 11th can favor durable gains through persistence, although its natural tendency is to make results gradual rather than effortless.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Saturn/house","/placements/Saturn/dignity","/houses/10/significations"]},{"claim":"The 9th house is exceptionally supportive: yogakaraka Venus, lord of the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign with 5th-lord Mercury, producing both a single-lord and conjunction-based raja yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment and opportunity as wealth-enabling resources.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/3/lord","/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/4/lord","/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse","/houses/8/lord","/placements/Venus/house","/placements/Venus/dignity","/placements/Mercury/house","/yogas/0","/yogas/1"]},{"claim":"Career-to-gains linkage is favorable: 10th-lord Mars and lagna lord Saturn mutually aspect one another, forming an identified raja yoga, while Mars also aspects the 11th house.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/houses/9/lord","/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse","/aspects/Mars","/aspects/Saturn","/yogas/2"]},{"claim":"The Dashamsa reinforces earning capacity through work: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th, Venus its own sign in the 4th, the Sun is in the 11th, and Mercury is in the 2nd.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/2","/vargas/D10/placements/3","/vargas/D10/placements/5","/vargas/D10/placements/0"]},{"claim":"An exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting practical stability, assets, public activity and career responsiveness.","effect":"supporting","evidence":["/placements/Moon/house","/placements/Moon/dignity","/aspects/Moon","/houses/9/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"Income may fluctuate or involve competitive and unconventional channels because the 11th house receives aspects from Mars and Rahu in addition to containing Saturn.","effect":"challenging","evidence":["/houses/10/aspectedBy","/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Rahu/house","/placements/Saturn/house"]},{"claim":"Speculative wealth requires restraint: Mars occupies the 5th in enemy dignity, and the 5th is additionally influenced by Saturn and Ketu, despite protection from Jupiter.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Mars/house","/placements/Mars/dignity","/houses/4/aspectedBy","/reference/houseSignifications/5"]},{"claim":"Partnership-based finances can be less predictable because Rahu occupies the 7th and the 7th lord Sun is placed in the 8th, although Jupiter's aspect gives some protection.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/placements/Rahu/house","/houses/6/lord","/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Sun/house","/houses/6/aspectedBy"]},{"claim":"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th links expenditure with income and networks; this can produce reinvestment or gains tied to foreign or institutional settings, but also creates potential leakage from earnings.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/houses/11/lord","/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse","/placements/Saturn/house","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]},{"claim":"In the career divisional chart, Jupiter in the 12th introduces a secondary indication of professional expenditure, foreign/institutional involvement, or reduced retention, moderating an otherwise strong D10.","effect":"mixed","evidence":["/vargas/D10/placements/4","/reference/houseSignifications/12"]}],"contradictions":[],"missing_information":["D2 Hora chart for a more specialized wealth assessment","Quantitative strength measures such as Shadbala and divisional dignity summaries","Exact wealth-event dates or a requested forecast interval for dasha and transit timing"],"rationale":"The chart is structurally supportive for wealth because both principal wealth houses are ruled by a strong Jupiter placed in the 11th, joined by the lagna lord and forming explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house raja yogas, the Mars-Saturn career yoga, and a powerful D10 reinforce gains through knowledge, career, networks and sustained effort. The main qualifications are gradualness from Saturn, volatility affecting the 11th, risk around speculation and partnerships, and possible expenditure or reinvestment pressure. Overall, the chart favors meaningful earning and accumulation capacity, but disciplined risk management is important."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-synthesis-01-evidence-order\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"supportive\",\"confidence\":0.9,\"selected_option_ids\":[],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The strongest wealth signature is the 2nd- and 11th-lord Jupiter occupying the 11th house in Sagittarius with moolatrikona dignity, directly strengthening accumulation, income and gains.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lord\",\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/10/lord\",\"/houses/10/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Jupiter/sign\",\"/placements/Jupiter/dignity\"]},{\"claim\":\"Jupiter's conjunction with lagna lord Saturn in the 11th forms the explicitly identified dhana yogas and connects personal effort and life direction with gains and networks.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Jupiter/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/houses/0/lord\",\"/yogas/3\",\"/yogas/4\"]},{\"claim\":\"Saturn in the 11th can favor durable gains through persistence, although its natural tendency is to make results gradual rather than effortless.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/dignity\",\"/houses/10/significations\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 9th house is exceptionally supportive: yogakaraka Venus, lord of the 4th and 9th, occupies its own sign with 5th-lord Mercury, producing both a single-lord and conjunction-based raja yoga. This supports fortune, education, judgment and opportunity as wealth-enabling resources.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/3/lord\",\"/houses/3/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/4/lord\",\"/houses/4/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/houses/8/lord\",\"/placements/Venus/house\",\"/placements/Venus/dignity\",\"/placements/Mercury/house\",\"/yogas/0\",\"/yogas/1\"]},{\"claim\":\"Career-to-gains linkage is favorable: 10th-lord Mars and lagna lord Saturn mutually aspect one another, forming an identified raja yoga, while Mars also aspects the 11th house.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/9/lord\",\"/houses/9/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/aspects/Mars\",\"/aspects/Saturn\",\"/yogas/2\"]},{\"claim\":\"The Dashamsa reinforces earning capacity through work: Mars occupies its own sign in the 10th, Venus its own sign in the 4th, the Sun is in the 11th, and Mercury is in the 2nd.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/2\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/3\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/5\",\"/vargas/D10/placements/0\"]},{\"claim\":\"An exalted Moon in the 4th aspects the 10th, supporting practical stability, assets, public activity and career responsiveness.\",\"effect\":\"supporting\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Moon/house\",\"/placements/Moon/dignity\",\"/aspects/Moon\",\"/houses/9/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"Income may fluctuate or involve competitive and unconventional channels because the 11th house receives aspects from Mars and Rahu in addition to containing Saturn.\",\"effect\":\"challenging\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/10/aspectedBy\",\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\"]},{\"claim\":\"Speculative wealth requires restraint: Mars occupies the 5th in enemy dignity, and the 5th is additionally influenced by Saturn and Ketu, despite protection from Jupiter.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Mars/house\",\"/placements/Mars/dignity\",\"/houses/4/aspectedBy\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/5\"]},{\"claim\":\"Partnership-based finances can be less predictable because Rahu occupies the 7th and the 7th lord Sun is placed in the 8th, although Jupiter's aspect gives some protection.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/placements/Rahu/house\",\"/houses/6/lord\",\"/houses/6/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Sun/house\",\"/houses/6/aspectedBy\"]},{\"claim\":\"The 12th lord Saturn placed in the 11th links expenditure with income and networks; this can produce reinvestment or gains tied to foreign or institutional settings, but also creates potential leakage from earnings.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/11/lord\",\"/houses/11/lordPlacedInHouse\",\"/placements/Saturn/house\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]},{\"claim\":\"In the career divisional chart, Jupiter in the 12th introduces a secondary indication of professional expenditure, foreign/institutional involvement, or reduced retention, moderating an otherwise strong D10.\",\"effect\":\"mixed\",\"evidence\":[\"/vargas/D10/placements/4\",\"/reference/houseSignifications/12\"]}],\"contradictions\":[],\"missing_information\":[\"D2 Hora chart for a more specialized wealth assessment\",\"Quantitative strength measures such as Shadbala and divisional dignity summaries\",\"Exact wealth-event dates or a requested forecast interval for dasha and transit timing\"],\"rationale\":\"The chart is structurally supportive for wealth because both principal wealth houses are ruled by a strong Jupiter placed in the 11th, joined by the lagna lord and forming explicit dhana yogas. Strong 9th-house raja yogas, the Mars-Saturn career yoga, and a powerful D10 reinforce gains through knowledge, career, networks and sustained effort. The main qualifications are gradualness from Saturn, volatility affecting the 11th, risk around speculation and partnerships, and possible expenditure or reinvestment pressure. Overall, the chart favors meaningful earning and accumulation capacity, but disciplined risk management is important.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}
{"runId":"pilot-six-model-20260824-c6","candidateId":"gpt-5-6-sol","caseId":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","repetition":3,"parsed":{"ok":true,"response":{"case_id":"wealth-application-02-counterfactual","domain":"wealth","conclusion":"insufficient","confidence":0.99,"selected_option_ids":["D"],"factors":[{"claim":"The chart states that the first-house lord is placed in the second house, not that the second-house lord is placed in the first house; therefore the condition required by statements A-C is not established.","effect":"neutral","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"contradictions":[{"statement_id":"A","error_type":"factual","correction":"The stated rule cannot be applied because the chart does not establish that the second lord occupies the first house.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"B","error_type":"overclaim","correction":"The required placement is not established, and such a placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]},{"statement_id":"C","error_type":"factual","correction":"The required second-lord-in-first placement is not established; moreover, the listed rule characterizes that placement as supportive rather than primarily indicating inability to earn.","evidence":["/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse"]}],"missing_information":["The lord and placement of the second house are not provided."],"rationale":"Only option D applies. The available fact describes the first-house lord as placed in house 2, which is the reverse of the placement required by A-C. Because D carries no supportive or challenging wealth polarity, the conclusion is insufficient."},"extracted":"{\"case_id\":\"wealth-application-02-counterfactual\",\"domain\":\"wealth\",\"conclusion\":\"insufficient\",\"confidence\":0.99,\"selected_option_ids\":[\"D\"],\"factors\":[{\"claim\":\"The chart states that the first-house lord is placed in the second house, not that the second-house lord is placed in the first house; therefore the condition required by statements A-C is not established.\",\"effect\":\"neutral\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"contradictions\":[{\"statement_id\":\"A\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The stated rule cannot be applied because the chart does not establish that the second lord occupies the first house.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"B\",\"error_type\":\"overclaim\",\"correction\":\"The required placement is not established, and such a placement would not by itself guarantee wealth.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]},{\"statement_id\":\"C\",\"error_type\":\"factual\",\"correction\":\"The required second-lord-in-first placement is not established; moreover, the listed rule characterizes that placement as supportive rather than primarily indicating inability to earn.\",\"evidence\":[\"/houses/1/lordPlacedInHouse\"]}],\"missing_information\":[\"The lord and placement of the second house are not provided.\"],\"rationale\":\"Only option D applies. The available fact describes the first-house lord as placed in house 2, which is the reverse of the placement required by A-C. Because D carries no supportive or challenging wealth polarity, the conclusion is insufficient.\"}"},"sourceRunId":"frontier-20260824-c6"}